Tuesday, March 28, 2023
  • About us
    • Write for us
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms of use
    • Privacy Policy
  • RSS Feeds
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us
DefenceTalk
  • Home
  • Defense News
    • Defense & Geopolitics News
    • War Conflicts News
    • Army News
    • Air Force News
    • Navy News
    • Missiles Systems News
    • Nuclear Weapons
    • Defense Technology
    • Cybersecurity News
  • Military Photos
  • Defense Forum
  • Military Videos
  • Military Weapon Systems
    • Weapon Systems
    • Reports
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Defense News
    • Defense & Geopolitics News
    • War Conflicts News
    • Army News
    • Air Force News
    • Navy News
    • Missiles Systems News
    • Nuclear Weapons
    • Defense Technology
    • Cybersecurity News
  • Military Photos
  • Defense Forum
  • Military Videos
  • Military Weapon Systems
    • Weapon Systems
    • Reports
No Result
View All Result
DefenceTalk
No Result
View All Result

Commanders say Obama overruled them on Afghanistan

by Agence France-Presse
June 24, 2011
in Defense Geopolitics News
2 min read
0
Commanders say Obama overruled them on Afghanistan
14
VIEWS

US President Barack Obama’s military commanders have said he ignored their advice for a more modest drawdown from Afghanistan and warned his decision carries risks for the war effort.

Both General David Petraeus and Admiral Mike Mullen, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said Obama’s plan to withdraw 33,000 surge troops by the end of next summer was more “aggressive” than they had recommended.

Asked by Senator Carl Levin if he was prepared to resign over the war policy, Petraeus said: “I don’t think it’s the place for the commander to consider that kind of step unless you are in a very, very dire situation.”

Petraeus, who indicated that he had received emails suggesting he should quit in protest, said: “This is an important decision, it is again a more aggressive approach than the chairman (Admiral Mullen), (Central Command chief General James) Mattis and I would have, indeed certainly, put forward.

“But this is not something where one hangs up the uniform in protest or something like that.”

The four-star general, who is due to step down in weeks as Obama’s top commander in the fight against the Taliban-led insurgency and take over as CIA director, is credited by many as having salvaged the war in Iraq.

His testimony in Congress provided more ammunition to Obama’s critics on the right who accuse the president of approving an overly hasty withdrawal plan for political motives ahead of presidential elections in 2012.

Defense Secretary Robert Gates, in an interview with AFP, endorsed Obama’s plan but acknowledged that waning political support for the grinding counter-insurgency campaign was an important factor in the decision.

The “advantages and disadvantages” of a range of options were debated at three White House meetings, including “not only the situation on the ground in Afghanistan but also political sustainability here at home,” Gates said.

He suggested Petraeus had advocated a slower timetable with more troops in place through next summer’s fighting season.

“Obviously he had preferred options that gave more time,” said Gates, who according to some reports brokered the compromise drawdown plan.

The military’s top officer, Mullen, offered a qualified endorsement of Obama’s decision, telling lawmakers that he had initially favored a more modest drawdown.

Mullen said “the president’s decisions are more aggressive and incur more risk than I was originally prepared to accept.”

But he said that keeping more forces in place also carried risks, including enabling Kabul to become more dependent on the American military presence.

“Let me be candid, however. No commander ever wants to sacrifice fighting power in the middle of a war.

“And no decision to demand that sacrifice is ever without risk,” he warned.

Both Mullen and Petraeus said the president had to take into account other considerations beyond military conditions, a clear reference to political and fiscal pressures.

The American public is increasingly impatient with a war that has dragged on nearly a decade. In a new Pew Research Center poll, 56 percent of respondents — the highest ever — said American troops should be brought home as soon as possible.

White House officials insist Obama’s move was based on military strategy — not politics — and that progress on the battlefield and the killing of Al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden had made the drawdown possible.

Petraeus promised the military nevertheless would carry out Obama’s plan, saying it is “the responsibility, needless to say, of those in uniform to salute smartly and to do everything possible to execute it.”

Tags: afghanistanCommandersobamatroops
Previous Post

Raytheon Offers New Ground-Based Evolved SeaSparrow Missile

Next Post

Army on course to leave Iraq by December

Related Posts

Urban warfare ‘nightmare’ looms if Russia enters Ukraine cities

NATO rejects Russian complaints on UK uranium ammo

March 24, 2023

NATO chief Jens Stoltenberg on Thursday dismissed Russian complaints about Britain's announcement that it will send Ukraine ammunition containing depleted...

Russian navy in show of strength with 26 new ships this year

Russian navy ‘repelled’ drone attack on Crimea port

March 23, 2023

The Russian navy "repelled" a drone attack on the port of Sevastopol in Moscow-annexed Crimea early Wednesday, officials said. Defence...

Next Post
Iraqi mortar crews build confidence, prepare for Operation Iron Lion

Army on course to leave Iraq by December

Latest Defense News

Ahead of talks, North Korea says fired ‘new’ sub-launched missile

North Korea says it tested new underwater nuclear attack ‘drone’

March 24, 2023
China Naval Modernization: Implications for US Navy

Chinese military says ‘warned’ US warship to leave S. China Sea

March 24, 2023
Urban warfare ‘nightmare’ looms if Russia enters Ukraine cities

NATO rejects Russian complaints on UK uranium ammo

March 24, 2023
Russian navy in show of strength with 26 new ships this year

Russian navy ‘repelled’ drone attack on Crimea port

March 23, 2023
Officials provide details on building the Space Force, its structure, and operating imperatives

Reagan’s ‘Star Wars’ at 40: Battle of the satellites

March 23, 2023
China will ‘never commit to abandoning the use of force’ on Taiwan: Xi

China diplomatic offensive lays down new challenge for US

March 22, 2023

Defense Forum Discussions

  • NZDF General discussion thread
  • Royal Australian Navy Discussions and Updates 2.0
  • The Russian-Ukrainian War Thread
  • Indian Navy Discussions and Updates
  • Taiwan alternative options
  • Japanese Maritime Self Defense Force Thread
  • Russia and the West
  • Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF) News and Discussions
  • General Aviation Thread
  • Middle East Defence & Security
DefenceTalk

© 2003-2020 DefenceTalk.com

Navigate Site

  • Defence Forum
  • Military Photos
  • RSS Feeds
  • About us
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Defense News
    • Defense & Geopolitics News
    • War Conflicts News
    • Army News
    • Air Force News
    • Navy News
    • Missiles Systems News
    • Nuclear Weapons
    • Defense Technology
    • Cybersecurity News
  • Military Photos
  • Defense Forum
  • Military Videos
  • Military Weapon Systems
    • Weapon Systems
    • Reports

© 2003-2020 DefenceTalk.com