Tuesday, October 3, 2023
  • About us
    • Write for us
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms of use
    • Privacy Policy
  • RSS Feeds
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us
DefenceTalk
  • Home
  • Defense News
    • Defense & Geopolitics News
    • War Conflicts News
    • Army News
    • Air Force News
    • Navy News
    • Missiles Systems News
    • Nuclear Weapons
    • Defense Technology
    • Cybersecurity News
  • Military Photos
  • Defense Forum
  • Military Videos
  • Military Weapon Systems
    • Weapon Systems
    • Reports
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Defense News
    • Defense & Geopolitics News
    • War Conflicts News
    • Army News
    • Air Force News
    • Navy News
    • Missiles Systems News
    • Nuclear Weapons
    • Defense Technology
    • Cybersecurity News
  • Military Photos
  • Defense Forum
  • Military Videos
  • Military Weapon Systems
    • Weapon Systems
    • Reports
No Result
View All Result
DefenceTalk
No Result
View All Result

Canadian F-35 Fighter Jet Purchase Unnecessary: Report

by Canadian Broadcasting Corp
October 19, 2010
in Air Force News
2 min read
0
14
VIEWS

The federal government’s decision to spend $9 billion on new F-35 fighter jets is “fundamentally flawed” and totally unnecessary, according to a report released Thursday by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.

“Canada does not need the F-35, either for North American/domestic roles or for expeditionary roles,” wrote CCPA research associate and Rideau Institute president Steven Staples. “The Canadian government should not proceed with the planned procurement of the F-35.”

At the heart of Staples report is a contention that Canada simply does not need such advanced aircraft. The F-35 Lightning II would not respond better to an unpredictable emergency such as the Sept. 11 attacks than any aircraft Canada currently possesses, Staples wrote.

Also, despite being the world’s 13th largest military spender, Canada’s military expenditures are so marginal, and the likelihood of launching expeditionary operations without its allies so remote, that the country’s “contributions may be valued by our allies, but they will not be essential.”

Criticism of contract appropriate

Instead, Canada could spend the money on a smaller range of what Staples calls “more general-use capabilities,” such as pilotless surveillance aircraft, transport planes and heavy-lift helicopters.” All of these could be used in humanitarian and peacekeeping operations — as well as combat missions — if necessary.

It could also limit itself to domestic or North American surveillance, investigate the future of long-range pilotless aircraft and spend its money on securing itself and the world in more effective ways, the eight-page report suggests.

The report is the latest criticism of the Conservatives’ announcement, in July, that it would buy 65 F-35s from Lockheed Martin to replace the country’s ageing fleet of CF-18s. Liberals have slammed the Tories not just for the price tag — at least $16 billion when contracts for support and maintenance are factored in — but because Lockheed Martin was awarded the contract with no competition.

Staples called that criticism appropriate, saying the deal “has put Lockheed Martin in an extremely strong bargaining position in future negotiations over maintenance costs.”

Conservatives have also argued the purchase will create jobs at companies that produce parts for the F-35, such as Winnipeg’s Bristol Aerospace Ltd.

But “such claims are dubious at best,” Staples wrote, saying the F-35 contract contains “none of the spelled out ‘offsets’ that are typically built into such procurement projects.”

Liberals applaud report

Liberal MPs welcomed the report, saying the Conservative government has to answer key questions about the fighter deal.

“Liberals want to replace the CF-18s, but we expect honest answers from the government to ensure we’re getting the right plane and the best possible deal for taxpayers and the Canadian aerospace industry,” said Marc Garneau, the party industry critic.

“This is the single largest military procurement in Canadian history,” said Dominic LeBlanc, the defence critic. “We are deeply concerned that the government hasn’t been straight with Canadians and that without competition, we’re not getting the right plane, the best price or the greatest benefits for our aerospace industry.”

The Liberals say if they don’t get satisfactory answers, they will kill the deal if they get a chance.

The CCPA is an Ottawa-based research institute that calls itself one of Canada’s leading progressive voices in public policy debates.

Tags: air forcecanadaF-35Fighter Aircraft
Previous Post

Su-35 presentation video KNAAPO 2007

Next Post

Cyberspace is the new domain of warfare

Related Posts

China made third-largest air incursion this year, says Taiwan

China would gain swift air superiority over Taiwan, US leaks show

April 19, 2023

China would probably gain air superiority very quickly in any attack on Taiwan, something Russia crucially failed to do in...

Su-35 Fighter Aircraft, Russian Air Force

Iran says deal reached to buy Russian fighter jets

March 13, 2023

Iran has finalized a deal to buy Sukhoi Su-35 fighter jets from Russia, state media reported, as defence cooperation between...

Next Post

Cyberspace is the new domain of warfare

Latest Defense News

First Shipment of New Gepard Ammunition Now on its Way to Ukraine

First Shipment of New Gepard Ammunition Now on its Way to Ukraine

September 6, 2023
China will ‘never commit to abandoning the use of force’ on Taiwan: Xi

China warns against ‘new Cold War’ as big powers meet in SE Asia

September 6, 2023
US sending 3,000 more troops to Poland, as Ukraine tension rises: senior official

Poland to spend over 4% of GDP on defence in 2024

September 6, 2023
North Korea pursues weapons despite Covid blockade: UN report

North Korea to pay ‘price’ if it gives Russia arms: US

September 6, 2023
USAF F-16 fleet undergoing largest modification work in history

Russia says F-16 fighter jets in Ukraine will be seen as ‘nuclear’ threat

July 13, 2023
North Korea says conducted new test of solid-fuel ICBM

North Korea says conducted new test of solid-fuel ICBM

July 13, 2023

Defense Forum Discussions

  • Australian Army Discussions and Updates
  • PRC Peoples Liberation Army Navy
  • General Dynamics F-16 Fighting Falcon Danish Air Force ET-613 arrival RAF Fairford RIAT 2023
  • The Russian-Ukrainian War Thread
  • Nagorniy Karabakh
  • Indonesian Aero News
  • European Union, member states and Agencies
  • Royal Australian Navy Discussions and Updates 2.0
  • ADF General discussion thread
  • Indonesia: 'green water navy'
DefenceTalk

© 2003-2020 DefenceTalk.com

Navigate Site

  • Defence Forum
  • Military Photos
  • RSS Feeds
  • About us
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Defense News
    • Defense & Geopolitics News
    • War Conflicts News
    • Army News
    • Air Force News
    • Navy News
    • Missiles Systems News
    • Nuclear Weapons
    • Defense Technology
    • Cybersecurity News
  • Military Photos
  • Defense Forum
  • Military Videos
  • Military Weapon Systems
    • Weapon Systems
    • Reports

© 2003-2020 DefenceTalk.com