Russian Navy Discussions and Updates

RobWilliams

Super Moderator
Staff member
I vaguely recall reading one major section was floated from Russia to France to be completed because the Russian yards weren't capable of doing the work up to scratch in the given time.
 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
I vaguely recall reading one major section was floated from Russia to France to be completed because the Russian yards weren't capable of doing the work up to scratch in the given time.
In time, and in price limits, certainly not. In principle, maybe.
 

StobieWan

Super Moderator
Staff member
Let's be really cynical and observe that if the Russians want to put money into assets which can be tracked and terminated easily..let them..
 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Let's be really cynical and observe that if the Russians want to put money into assets which can be tracked and terminated easily..let them..
By whom? NATO, well yes. But then there's the nuclear stick. Which is the only way Russia can handle NATO. Mistrals or no Mistrals. Everyone else though? Not so easy. Especially not if they're properly escorted. For example, could Ukraine or Georgia easily eliminate a Mistral? I doubt it. Ukrainian coastal missile units are in shambles, maritime strike capability is non-existent, and aerial recon is extremely limited, for example. And of course I don't see Somalian pirates doing much to a Mistral. This about summs up the roster of maritime threats Russia is realistically going to handle with these sorts of means.
 

StobieWan

Super Moderator
Staff member
I was referring to the uproar over the French selling them on - they're no threat to a NATO allied country is my point. They're no real additional threat to any country they could approach with impunity - if the Russians are in a position to use a Mistral in an amphib role, they likely have superiority in the air and sea I'd be guessing.
 

KiwiRob

Well-Known Member
Let's be really cynical and observe that if the Russians want to put money into assets which can be tracked and terminated easily..let them..
You could say the same for Australia, France, the US, or basically anyone who operates this type of vessel.
 

StobieWan

Super Moderator
Staff member
I wouldn't - they can all put a blue water battlegroup out to sea that can travel distances without ocean going tugs.


I don't think the Russian Navy gets enough time at sea to practise decent ASW drills for example.
 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
I was referring to the uproar over the French selling them on - they're no threat to a NATO allied country is my point. They're no real additional threat to any country they could approach with impunity - if the Russians are in a position to use a Mistral in an amphib role, they likely have superiority in the air and sea I'd be guessing.
I don't know about additional threat in principle but it does make it easier for Russia to do the things it does. As Russian command stated, they could have completed their amphibious operations in the Georgian war much much easier had they a Mistral. This is not to say that the outcome would have changed.
 

Klaus

New Member
Four more are to be built. I wonder what will be the future of the Lada class. There were reports that their technical problems would be solved, but I've heard nothing since. Two of them should still be under construction, but I'm not sure.
 
Some brief updates from media outlets (both sides) regarding Mistral

ITAR-TASS: Economy - No obstacles for Mistral supplies to Russia

Fresh Ukraine tension sparks questions over French warship sale to Russia | Business Recorder

Ignoring for a moment the huge comp factor, hadn't really considered the current Rafale deal to India as a problem, but raises a good point. Tough decision for France if this crisis worsens.

Understand Sevastopol is under initial trials in the Bay of Biscay currently.
 

PO2GRV

Member
Russia Tests Nuclear Missile

Another successful test launch of the Bulava. Putin, Lavrov and Shoigu are all smiles im sure considering Putins references to Russian nuclear arsenal these past few weeks. Further launches set for October and November so we'll see how far the programs come
 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
The project 956 Rastoporniy has been pulled out of long term dock, and is being taken somewhere. It's unclear whether it will be cut up for scrap or modernized.

kuleshovoleg:
 

Sandhi Yudha

Well-Known Member
The project 956 Rastoporniy has been pulled out of long term dock, and is being taken somewhere. It's unclear whether it will be cut up for scrap or modernized.

kuleshovoleg:
Thanks for sharing the link, still a good looking ship.
Decommissioned 5 years ago in 2009 wasn't it?
Many project 956s are already retired and as far as i know none of them are modernized. So its likely that it will be scrapped.....
Its time that the Admiral Gorshkov-class frigates will entering service!
 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Thanks for sharing the link, still a good looking ship.
Decommissioned 5 years ago in 2009 wasn't it?
Many project 956s are already retired and as far as i know none of them are modernized. So its likely that it will be scrapped.....
Its time that the Admiral Gorshkov-class frigates will entering service!
The cannon for the first Gorshkov has just arrived, so we may see this long term project finally reach a serial production status. There is the engine question though, since Zarya has suspended deliveries on Russian MoD contracts and Saturn is years away from producing something comparable.
 

wsb05

Member
The cannon for the first Gorshkov has just arrived, so we may see this long term project finally reach a serial production status. There is the engine question though, since Zarya has suspended deliveries on Russian MoD contracts and Saturn is years away from producing something comparable.
Isnt Zarya in Mariupol?... They may still get those engines depending on the settlment conditions with DPR.

Can't the russians offer citizinship and higher pay for ukrainian experts in the defense industry? Many are already in russian speaking areas.
 
Top