Indonesia: 'green water navy'

Ananda

The Bunker Group

Asia Defence Journal talk with Fincantieri officials during IndoDefence. Basically it sum up:
  1. TNI-AL first PPA KRI Brawidjaja will leave Italy by end of next month. Predict to be inducted into TNI-AL fleet by early September. While the second one KRI Siliwangi schedulle to hand over by end of this year.
  2. Indonesia intention for Garibaldi light carrier has potential close to fruition. As expected Indonesia will use Garibaldi as drone carrier.
It is expexted as Drone carrier, Garibaldi will be equiped by Bayraktar TB3. In booth of Republikorp, mock up of TB3 being shown as part of licensing agreement betwen Baykar and Republikorp for assembly agreement.
 

Ananda

The Bunker Group

This local online military site talk about design for UAE Al Maryah, which's now PAL Officially market it as MRSS. PAL and Lunas also team up to put this design for Malaysia relaunch MRSS bid. Lunas from my understanding will conduct final assembly, with some modules from PAL.


The design now 14,000 tons and it is seems more then Makasar LPD with steroids.
 

Ananda

The Bunker Group

Xavier Video on FMP (Red White Frigate) with PAL chief designer. Basically PAL with Babcock assistance adjust around 60% of the design due to changes at:
  1. Radars and integrated mast as they are now using mostly Aselsan and some Leonardo sensors (change from Thales on original Arrowhead 140),
  2. Dimensions as FMP around 2 meters longer then basic design (make it 140m),
  3. Propulsion as TNI AL want bit faster speed. I also recheck from other source that basic speed increase by 2 knots,
  4. The possition B now have second Leonardo 76mm, thus heavier then possition B on basic Arrowhead 140,
  5. Last one is the number of VLS being increase to 64 and also ommiting angle launch SSM to become all Vertical Launch. Midlas VLS from what I gather is in similar size against Sylver and Mk 41.
This increase the full weight to 6600 tons. This from other source that I gather make FMP AAW specialist Frigate, altough it is still maintain ASW and ASuW capabilities. Aselsan radar all fixed array at integrated mast. Making them heavier then integrated mast on basic Arrowhead 140.

The design already final, and this is clear reason why Frenchie Salesman always bitter in his channels and article about this Frigate. Basically all his sales products (MBDA and Thales) being replace by Roketsan, Havelsan and Aselsan. While Leonardo still maintain piece of pies in this FMP contract.

The downturn it is adding more than a year design adjustment to the previous schedulle. With this FMP become AAW Frigate, I don't know if they still need to add Type 52 from China as plan for AAW Destroyer or getting another batch of 2 for this FMP design.
 
Last edited:

Sandhi Yudha

Well-Known Member

Xavier Video on FMP (Red White Frigate) with PAL chief designer. Basically PAL with Babcock assistance adjust around 60% of the design due to changes at:
  1. Radars and integrated mast as they are now using mostly Aselsan and some Leonardo sensors (change from Thales on original Arrowhead 140),
  2. Dimensions as FMP around 2 meters longer then basic design (make it 140m),
  3. Propulsion as TNI AL want bit faster speed. I also recheck from other source that basic speed increase by 2 knots,
  4. The possition B now have second Leonardo 76mm, thus heavier then possition B on basic Arrowhead 140,
  5. Last one is the number of VLS being increase to 64 and also ommiting angle launch SSM to become all Vertical Launch. Midlas VLS from what I gather is in similar size against Sylver and Mk 41.
This increase the full weight to 6600 tons. This from other source that I gather make FMP AAW specialist Frigate, altough it is still maintain ASW and ASuW capabilities. Aselsan radar all fixed array at integrated mast. Making them heavier then integrated mast on basic Arrowhead 140.

The design already final, and this is clear reason why Frenchie Salesman always bitter in his channels and article about this Frigate. Basically all his sales products (MBDA and Thales) being replace by Roketsan, Havelsan and Aselsan. While Leonardo still maintain piece of pies in this FMP contract.

The downturn it is adding more than a year design adjustment to the previous schedulle. With this FMP become AAW Frigate, I don't know if they still need to add Type 52 from China as plan for AAW Destroyer or getting another batch of 2 for this FMP design.
So this modified and enlarged design is actual closer to the original Iver Huitveldt design, than the Arrowhead 140/Type 31.

The Iver had also double OTO Melara 76 mm guns at A and B position, had more launch cells (32-cell Mk41 + 12-cell Mk56), was also 6600 ton fully loaded and had a topspeed of 28 kts.
 

Ananda

The Bunker Group
this modified and enlarged design is actual closer to the original Iver Huitveldt design, than the Arrowhead 140/Type 31.
Just like Danes configure Iver more as AAW Frigate, seems this is also what TNI-AL plan to do with FMP. Question will be if the SAM missile that going to be equiped will be more for Short to Medium or long range. From what I gather potentially more to Short-Medium range first.

Just like TNI-AU that has NASAMS with AIM 120, TNI-AD Trisula system in begining will also equiped more with Hisar O/RF that has similar range between 25-40 Km. TNI-AL FMP Midlas also reported potentially will be equiped with similar HisarO/RF. While their PPA potentialy also will be equiped with similar range Aster 15. All three then operating 25-40 km range SAM.

There're talk for Hisar U/Siper and Aster 30, but seems it will be for next round budget allocation. Roketsan already shown their Midlas can accomodate both Hisar O and Siper, just like Sylver for Aster 15 and 30. Will see what type of Midlas and Sylver that being procure, as rumours say the Light + PPA equiped with Sylver 43 and not 50. Means only can be equiped by Aster 15.


Video on KRI Brawijaya trial in Italy with TNI-AL crew. Just got a feeling if TNI-AL PPA equiped with Aster 15, then potentialy FMP will also be equiped with similar class Hisar O/RF. Still it is already improvement then VL Mica and Mistral.

From what I heard TNI still want to evaluate Siper as it is relatively new, while Hisar O/RF already operational for some time TCG Istanbul (F 515) Fires HİSAR-D RF Missile from MİDLAS | TURDEF. Personally I see it more to budget issue. Having 25-40 km SAM is in the end more economics then 80-100+km SAM. Also more importantly TNI can done gradual learning from Shorad to Short Range then Medium Range before operating long range theater defence SAM.
 
Last edited:

Ananda

The Bunker Group
have to check again, but seems as this moment, there are two SRV project,one with SMP using SRV-F Mk3 and now with FET using LR600. Perhaps this explain why there are two mother ship program. One using mother ship build by Citra Shipyard, and other using BHO.
It is confirm that there are two SRV project. FET one with LR600 and BHO mother ship, and the other is SMP with SRV-F mk3. BTI Indo Tekno as SMP local partner that should prepare mother ship sign MoU with Ben Santosa Shipyard in Surabaya area, during last IndoDefence https://x.com/indomiliter/status/1934503875899466010.

7b2253b3-bd7c-4080-84c5-570b17f3b38d.jpg

The design is still the same, however they change shipyard partner from Citra to Ben Santosa. I suspect due to price disagreement with previous Shipyard. I don't know why SMP or TNI AL choose this BTI Indo Tekno as local partner in system integration. With their changing Shipyard Partner after two years in project, just not seems prepared enough.

So personally I suspect FET with BHO mother ship will be more ready as first SRV operational with TNI-AL. On Paper SMP SRV are supposedly have bigger capacity for 50 crew, against FAT capacity of 20 crew.
 
Last edited:

Sandhi Yudha

Well-Known Member

Effective contract for SRV, launch and recovery system plus decompression chamber. Whole system will be pair with BHO vessel that now being finish by Abekin-Rasmussen in Germany.

I have to check again, but seems as this moment, there are two SRV project,one with SMP using SRV-F Mk3 and now with FET using LR600. Perhaps this explain why there are two mother ship program. One using mother ship build by Citra Shipyard, and other using BHO.

View attachment 53022
Thanks God they have learned from the past. It was really emberrassing that the navy with the most submarine-experience of South-East Asia, couldn't do anything when KRI Nanggala 402 was unfindable. Ordering two motherships for Submarine Rescue Vehicles is not a waste of money, even if one Submarine Rescue Ship is under maintenance, there will be always at least one standby in case of emergencies.

Just like Danes configure Iver more as AAW Frigate, seems this is also what TNI-AL plan to do with FMP. Question will be if the SAM missile that going to be equiped will be more for Short to Medium or long range. From what I gather potentially more to Short-Medium range first.

Just like TNI-AU that has NASAMS with AIM 120, TNI-AD Trisula system in begining will also equiped more with Hisar O/RF that has similar range between 25-40 Km. TNI-AL FMP Midlas also reported potentially will be equiped with similar HisarO/RF. While their PPA potentialy also will be equiped with similar range Aster 15. All three then operating 25-40 km range SAM.

There're talk for Hisar U/Siper and Aster 30, but seems it will be for next round budget allocation. Roketsan already shown their Midlas can accomodate both Hisar O and Siper, just like Sylver for Aster 15 and 30. Will see what type of Midlas and Sylver that being procure, as rumours say the Light + PPA equiped with Sylver 43 and not 50. Means only can be equiped by Aster 15.


Video on KRI Brawijaya trial in Italy with TNI-AL crew. Just got a feeling if TNI-AL PPA equiped with Aster 15, then potentialy FMP will also be equiped with similar class Hisar O/RF. Still it is already improvement then VL Mica and Mistral.

From what I heard TNI still want to evaluate Siper as it is relatively new, while Hisar O/RF already operational for some time TCG Istanbul (F 515) Fires HİSAR-D RF Missile from MİDLAS | TURDEF. Personally I see it more to budget issue. Having 25-40 km SAM is in the end more economics then 80-100+km SAM. Also more importantly TNI can done gradual learning from Shorad to Short Range then Medium Range before operating long range theater defence SAM.
Thanks for sharing the video.
1. So these two PPA vessels will have the largest helicopterdeck on an Indonesian frigate ever, and the first double hangar.
2. With these two PPA vessels, TNI-AL also get the largest naval gun since RI Irian 201, being larger than the Bofors 120 mm from the Fatahillah Class.
3. I still do not understand why they started with 320 for Brawijaya, and not with 321. This is also the first time they start with a 0 for a new class.
 
Last edited:

Ananda

The Bunker Group

SRV_2.jpg


On specification SMP SRV-F Mk 3 has more than twice rescue capacity then LET LR600 (50 vs 20). However on paper LR600 can reach around 100m deeper then SRV-F Mk 3 (600m vs 500m). I suspect considering Indonesia water depth, they are preparing on possible scenario.

One thing that I suspect, with two SRV, they aim to get ability on getting all crew at one journey. Also with two mother ship perhaps station on different Naval Base, they can achieve at least one of them to get into distress Sub faster. From rumours that I gather, one will be station in Jakarta and other one in Surabaya. This I suspect is also related to the situation where Hospitals with hyperbaric chambers are mostly situated on both cities. Thus the submariners can be transfer from Field Hyperbaric modules at each mother ship toward Hyperbaric and pressure facilities in hospitals.
 

Ananda

The Bunker Group

This more explanation on Atmaca SSM deal from Turkish media. The deal that sign in IndoDefence are
  1. Between Roketsan and Turkish Shipyard that currently building KCR-70 for Atmaca SSM.
  2. Between Roketsan and Republikorp on building JV on assembly line for Atmaca.
The #2 potentialy can be enlarge to other Roketsan missiles later on. It is rumours this JV later on can also assembly Hisar RF for usage at FMP Midlas and Trisula land base SAM system.

Either way this shown how Prabowo already impatience with local missile development, including reverse engineering C705. From what I heard that JV facility and willingness by Roketsan to outsource some missiles components manufacturing that got them deal, instead MBDA. Something that make Frenchie and Euro salesman continue livid when heard the name Turkey.

Add:
Roketsan video on their booth at IndoDefence
 
Last edited:
Top