What do you mean by EMF?
Expeditionary Military Force??
What do you mean by EMF?
Expeditionary Military Force??
Ummmmm........hell no.
I understand what you are saying about the need for the Cav. to have access to a range of vehicles, but you are advocating a sort of 'jack of all trades/master of none' approach there. It might be that there is a need for bushmasters or the like to accompany the Cav but once you get to the point where you need heavy tracked IFVs you are really talking Mech Inf. and at that point the Cav would give way to 5 or 7 RAR.
285 vehicles is insufficient to equip 2/3 Cavalry Regiments and 2 Mech Infantry Battalions. 257 ASLAVs was/is barely sufficient (if at all) to equip the two Cavalry regiments as is - once Trade School, Depot Maintenance and other vehicles are taken out of the picture.
Brett.
G'day Abe, I,m replying in reference to you LAND 17 post regarding the numbers of SPH being 12 in total. Do you agree that this number is too small to be tactically useful? It leaves no room for attrition and very little for training. Also in your opinion which option do you believe will get up?
G'day Abe, I,m replying in reference to you LAND 17 post regarding the numbers of SPH being 12 in total. Do you agree that this number is too small to be tactically useful? It leaves no room for attrition and very little for training. Also in your opinion which option do you believe will get up?
It makes you wonder in hindsight why defence just didnt take the Dutch up on their offer of 18 surplus vehicles.Not when you look at the intentions for deployable units outlined in the White paper. The White Paper is fairly explicit in that only a company or battalion level group will deploy overseas to "higher intensity" conflicts.
Such will only require 2 - 4 guns at the most in support of them operationally, particularly when you take into account the increased capability of the SPG's on order (a single platform of either of the 2 vehicles has roughly the same firepower as a current RRAA 155mm battery, but with a much longer range).
If we are preparing for continental warfare, yes, they will probably be inadequate. If we want a deployable capability of only a few, but very high quality guns, that number should be fine.
As to which SPG will get up? Absolutely no idea, but I am quite happy with either vehicle. My personal preference would be for PZH-2000 to get the nod and I have an inkling that the "cost element" has been reduced somewhat with a firm number (12 "operational" vehicles plus a number of attrition and training guns is the requirement) put in place, ie: AS-9 had an advantage in cost over PZH-2000 reportedly and with varying packages being discussed that could lead to quite a difference, but with a fixed small number now, I suspect cost might not be as beneficial to the AS-9's cause as it once was, but who knows?
We will have to wait just a bit longer, I feel...
It makes you wonder in hindsight why defence just didnt take the Dutch up on their offer of 18 surplus vehicles.
It makes you wonder in hindsight why defence just didnt take the Dutch up on their offer of 18 surplus vehicles.
Of course LAND 400 as detailed in Joint Forces 2030 will cost a lot more than $1-1.5 billion. Try as much as over $5 billion. .
But the budget is for $1.5 Billion, or this figure will grow as the defence budget grows?
or,are we looking to purchase $5 Billion worth of equipment with a $1.5 Billion budget?![]()
Abraham Gubler,may i ask you what type of vehicle(s) you would purchase for the future IFV ect?
As you correctly point out, 257 ASLAV vehicles is barely sufficient to equip the units that have them already. Especially taking into account attrition, due to the heavy operational workload these vehicles have been placed under...
Abraham Gubler said:There is a strong train of support within Defence for the new large European 8x8s like the Piranha IV, AMV and Boxer. Despite the strong marketing efforts there is little support for the Puma IFV.
The LAV III did a sterling job in Afghanistan, as did the Stryker in Iraq. I don't know what experience the Australians had with there ASLAV (or their "LAV III"), but for the current missions and conflicts it seems that such large wheeled carriers are very well suited.
The ASLAV is not a LAV III it is a LAV 2 like the USMC's LAV-25. Though the Gen III ASLAV is fitted with the far more advanced sights, FCS and turret drives of the LAV III. The experience in Iraq and Afghanistan with the ASLAV has been very positive.
There is a strong train of support within Defence for the new large European 8x8s like the Piranha IV, AMV and Boxer. Despite the strong marketing efforts there is little support for the Puma IFV.
It makes you wonder in hindsight why defence just didnt take the Dutch up on their offer of 18 surplus vehicles.
"This is another example of the sorts of capabilities and commercial opportunities that can be achieved by working with allies and partners within our own region."
On that subject, Fisher announced in late-2008 that if it is selected for Land 17, the AS-9 will deliver a $234 million boon to the Australian defence industry, including SMEs, with the potential for associated Australian work to exceed $1 billion over the 20-year life of the program.
The improved capability of the AS-9 would be offered under a Product Improvement Program (PIP) for the Korean Army's K9 guns.
"This will provide an additional $440 million in opportunities for Australian companies," said Fisher.
In addition to the K9 PIP, Fisher said there is a further potential for up to $500 million in additional work for Australian industry in international sales of the AS-9.
"In all, this is a billion dollar opportunity for Australian industry.
"That means Aussie jobs and strong revenue streams for local firms.
"The unique opportunity here for Australian SMEs is not only significant work in Australia but also the potential for new export markets.
Are you aware of any preference for a particular one of them, or just a feeling that a vehicle in that class would suit Australian needs?There is a strong train of support within Defence for the new large European 8x8s like the Piranha IV, AMV and Boxer. Despite the strong marketing efforts there is little support for the Puma IFV.
Are you aware of any preference for a particular one of them, or just a feeling that a vehicle in that class would suit Australian needs?
If the latter, you're not exactly short of choice.
The UK's future rapid effects system (FRES) programme includes five families of medium-weight vehicles, in at least 16 variants, and the procurement of an estimated 3,300 vehicles. The FRES vehicles are to meet the army's long-term needs for new medium-weight armoured fighting vehicles and will be deployed on rapid intervention, enduring peacekeeping and peace enforcement operations and support to high intensity, major combat operations.
The UK Ministry of Defence (MoD) has announced the provisional selection of General Dynamic's Piranha V as the preferred design for the FRES utility vehicle.
The first FRES vehicles will enter service in 2012 and the vehicles will be in production until about 2030.
The five vehicle families are utility, reconnaissance, medium armour, manoeuvre support and basic capability utility vehicles. The requirement, first announced in 1998, was for 3,700 vehicles, but by 2006 this had been reduced to 3,300 vehicles. The actual number of vehicles to be procured will not be announced until MoD main gate approval is reached.
The £13bn FRES programme is the highest priority equipment programme within the British Army. The whole-life cost is estimated at £50bn. The utility vehicles will include 1,700 to 1,900 wheeled 8×8 vehicles from 25t to 30t, accounting for 60% of the number of FRES vehicles and about 50% of the programme costs.
The specialist FRES vehicles – reconnaissance, medium armour and manoeuvre support families – will consist of about 1,500 vehicles, 40% of the FRES vehicle total and 50% of the cost. The fifth family, basic capability utility vehicles, will not be to a full FRES specification and will be procured separately from the FRES programme.
Are you aware of any preference for a particular one of them, or just a feeling that a vehicle in that class would suit Australian needs?
LAND 400 Phase 1 was orinally intended for a decision in FY 2011/12 to 2013/14 with in-service delivery of 2015 to 2017
I guess they could look at it a little earlier if it is decided to start getting new vehicles instead of the ASLAV upgrade LAND 112 Phase 4. That was schedules for a decision in FY 2010/11 to 2012/13 with in-service delivery: 2012 to 2014.