Gentle ocean ripples would be enough to stop the navy’s billion-dollar amphibious ships from moving key armoured vehicles to shore because of compatibility *issues with new landing craft, leaked *Defence documents reveal.
The giant 230m-long landing helicopter docks HMAS Canberra and Adelaide, which cost $1.5 billion each, are needed to land troops and vehicles via specially designed landing craft that are stored under the deck.
An official Defence document from June warns that the accompanying landing craft could *struggle to carry heavy armoured and general mobility vehicles, *potentially “limiting operations of the amphibious vessels”.
There are also questions about whether the issues could narrow the choice of vehicles available as a replacement for the Australian light armoured vehicle, known as the Land 400 program.
Defence has been working on building a US Marine Corp-type rapid reaction capability based around the two ships responding to potential flashpoints in the Asia Pacific. Key to the operations is the ability to quickly land troops and armoured vehicles on to beaches from the two ships under most conditions.
The vehicles are supposed to be carried to the beach on special landing craft that are stored *beneath the amphibious ships’ decks.
Twelve of the landing craft mechanised-1Es are being built by Spanish ship builder Navantia for about $248 million and are due to be operational by later this year.
However, Defence confirmed in *August that the landing craft *required more testing because they sank too low in the water when carrying the army’s 62-tonne M1A1 tanks.
Indepth material about what the landing craft could or couldn’t carry and under what conditions was not made public at the time.
The Australian has seen a “Landing Craft Raft Compatibility Assessment”, and vehicle weights and testing status document for the landing craft, both of which *reveal broader issues associated with compatibility.
The landing craft assessment document states the craft are “unlikely to be able to transport the new generation of armoured *vehicles or the protected general purpose vehicles” because of the *vehicle’s axle weight exceeding the craft’s deck strength limits.
It also says the landing craft were not rated to carry vehicles weighing more than 45 tonnes when wave heights were above 85cm. And they could carry up to only 63 tonnes, just over the weight of Australia’s main battle tank the M1A1 Abram when seas were below 10cm.
The document features the warning that a “number of ADF vehicle types are either at or *exceed the authorised limits of the current LLC for the full range of environmental conditions, restricting the ability to force project ADF vehicles from ship to shore”.
The weights document also *revealed certain loads would *require a waiver to be issued on “a case-by-case basis, to meet operational requirements”.
It said no waiver was *required for weights up to 38.9 tonnes but one table states this was only for sea state 3 — a classification the World Meteorological Organisation describes as “slight seas”.
It notes vehicles weighing *between 20 to 45 tonnes could be carried when seas were below 85cm — or in the middle region of the organisation’s “slight seas” measurement.
Defence vehicles that could *require a waiver under certain conditions included the Abrams tank, weighing 62.5 tonnes, the new protected recovery vehicle at 45 tonnes, the new armoured *vehicle to replace the ASLAV’s, the new protected *medium truck at 21 tonnes and the protected heavy truck that is 37 tonnes.
The scenario could complicate selection of Australia’s replacement for the light armoured *vehicle.
A Defence spokesman this week admitted the landing craft would require “more benign conditions” to carry the Abrams tank, given its size and weight.
The spokesman also revealed Defence was “undertaking design efforts to address the existing deck strength limitations identified during the trials program. “These modifications will also address the expected weight and axle configuration of either of the potential Land 400 vehicles,’’ he said.
The spokesman said the landing craft were still being tested. He said analysis of trials would inform the suitable configuration of *defence vehicles while embarking the landing craft while staying with deck stability limits.