Great post Raven. Thank you for the breakdown. I have mentally marked this post for future refI have heard that money had been taken out of the budget for Land400, but for Phase 2 and not Phase 3. It sounds like money has been taken out of both, which isn't a good sign (although who knows what will happen with a new PM and defence minister).
One thing at is probably worth pointing out, is that the current BOP for Land400 is actually very generous. On current plans there will be 225 CRVs to equip just three squadrons, and 450 IFVs to mount the fighting elements of just three infantry battalions. Compare that to Germany, which is buying just 350 Puma and 272 Boxer to equip a force of 15 armoured and mechanised infantry battalions. It is entirely possible that Australia could end up with more Puma/Boxer than Germany, which is quite surprising when you think about it.
The 450 figure for the IFV is based off an assumption that each IFV can hold only six dismounts, and therefore a total of eight vehicles are needed to lift a platoon (and 26 to lift a company). Compare that to the four vehicles per platoon in just about every other army. In fact, on that BOP, a single Australian IFV troop of 26 vehicles is almost as large as entire soviet bloc battalion (with 31 vehicles).
The BOP for the CRV is similarly generous. On current thinking, a future cavalry squadron will have four 6-vehicle troops plus a four vehicle SHQ, for a total of 28 vehicles (plus the A1 ech). Compare that to a British recce squadron of three 4-vehicle troops plus a two-vehicle SHQ, for a total of 14 vehicles. An Australian squadron therefore is literally twice the size of a British squadron.
When you consider that, individually, the vehicles being sought by army are the best money can buy, it is clear that a reduction in budget may not be as disasterous as it might otherwise be.
It will be interesting, if the budget has been reduced, how they go about reducing costs. Having a think about it, there are many ways this could be done:
One way to reduce the number of vehicles, and hence cost, is to mandate that each vehicle must hold eight dismounts. Therefore each section could consist of just six vehicles instead of eight. Of course, there essentially are no vehicles that meet the likely Phase 3 requirements and hold 8 dismounts, so this may not be workable at all.
Another way to save money would be to make the Phase 3 solution the same as the Phase 2 solution - ie, have a wheeled IFV instead of a tracked one. While not ideal, this would likely make the full 450 vehicles affordable.
Similarly, haveing a majority of vehicles being APCs and not IFVs (ie not turreted) could be a solution. You would need less vehicles, as non turreted vehicles could hold eight dismounts, plus save money as you don't have to pay for the turrets or a third crew member. Compare the cost of a six vehicle APC section (with 12 crew members and 48 dismounts) to an eight vehicle IFV section (with 24 crew members, 48 dismounts and all the costs of the 30+mm cannon and ATGM). Of course, you would lose huge amounts of combat power doing this, so it's far from ideal.
If you look at Land400 holistically, there are other outside the box solutions as well. For instance, having only APCs instead of IFVs loses huge amounts of combat power, but there are other ways of providing his combat power. On current estimates, an M1 tank is about a third of the cost of projected Land400 vehicles. Through life costs are likely slightly more for the tank, but not by a huge amount. Perhaps a bigger buy of tanks is a way of adding the combat power needed to cater for the loss of the IFVs firepower?
Just considering the vehicles needed to lift the rifle companies, an IFV-based squadron would need 78 IFVs and 234 crew. An APC-based squadron would need 60 vehicles and 120 crew to do the same job. Reinvest this saving into a second tank squadron (14 tanks and 56 crew) and you would likely still save money. Maybe the answer is not more IFVs but more tanks?
Having said all that, all I think will happen if money has been taken out is that less vehicles will be bought. I think army will still demand a gold-plated solution in terms of a full IFV, and will simply accept having less vehicles in total to still get this. As I mentioned earlier, the BOP is already quite generous, so this will hardly be the end of the world, and there is no reason more can't be bought later (as happened with ASLAV and Bushmaster and, likely, the M1).
Yes, thanks Raven, great post very informative.
Definitely hope we get more tanks, a full three squadrons of tanks in each ACR would be nice but I know has zero chance of getting up, unless of course there is a trade off in CRV numbers, i.e. the second CRV sqn becomes a third tank sqn. don't know how that would work, especially if the IFVs are displaced with APCs.
On APC verses IFV, is there any reason there can't be a mix of both? My thinking is a IFV/APC section needs 48 dismounts instead of either eight IFVs or six APCs, why not a mix of APC and IFV versions of the same vehicle? With a common turret for the IFV and CRV, as some are offering, this would be even easier, especially if it is a non penetrating turret.
There is also my favourite option, although it has not been offered so is fantasy, the Name. It exceeds the required capacity, i.e. nine dismounts instead of six or eight, meaning as few as five vehicles per section would suffice and is the best protected / most survivable vehicle of its type currently available.
On APC verses IFV, is there any reason there can't be a mix of both? My thinking is a IFV/APC section needs 48 dismounts instead of either eight IFVs or six APCs, why not a mix of APC and IFV versions of the same vehicle? With a common turret for the IFV and CRV, as some are offering, this would be even easier, especially if it is a non penetrating turret.
There is also my favourite option, although it has not been offered so is fantasy, the Name. It exceeds the required capacity, i.e. nine dismounts instead of six or eight, meaning as few as five vehicles per section would suffice and is the best protected / most survivable vehicle of its type currently available.
It is obvious that 59 tanks are insufficient for the Australian Army. Now would someone with more recent experience, or more experience, nominate how many more we should be getting?/ (My only experience with armoured vehicles was with the Ferret, so you can see it was not yesterday.)
Speaking as an absolute observer...but as a taxpayer in Australia, I'm interested in views on whether the right decision been made with the purchase of the Hawkei?
I have read what I can find...mainly company material, but I would value the thoughts of those with experience.
I can certainly see this as a political decision, and saw what I considered an extraordinary comment in recent days, suggesting the possibility of sales to the US Marines.
Oskosh would have something to say about that, I would think.
Looking at potential conflicts either in conjunction with American/NATO lead coalitions or a PLA foe, most militaries are moving to increase leathality of their IFV. I this a CROWS larger than .50 cal is almost a requirement. I think SAAB and Konigsberg both have RWS that can handle up to a 30mm system.I'd like to see what RWS options are being considered for it. The open hatch / flex mount idea is nice and cheap, but doesn't reflect what is needed on Ops...
Looking at potential conflicts either in conjunction with American/NATO lead coalitions or a PLA foe, most militaries are moving to increase leathality of their IFV. I this a CROWS larger than .50 cal is almost a requirement. I think SAAB and Konigsberg both have RWS that can handle up to a 30mm system.
I'd like to see something along those lines or a remote turret on the Styker platforms similar to the USMC LAV25
So, with all the talk about the number of IFV/APC the Army would need, I was just wanting to get an idea of unit sizes and what the Army was/is hoping to be able to lift into battle.
Is the platoon still based on the Inf 2012 design? And is that still 40 personnel or is it more? Raven was saying 48, or was I misreading that?
The size of the company, I've seen referred to as 130 personnel in the Infantry Magazine, is this correct or is it more? I thought it was more like 140?
And was it Army's intention to be able to lift both infantry battalions of the brigade with the IFV squadron or just 1 and the other conducted light infantry, airmobile or used Bushmaster for lift?
Will or could the CRV be used in the infantry lift role as well as the IFV? Or will it be solely be used as a recon capability?
Foxtrot has already given the size of an SIB platoon/company, but when talking about the number of vehicles required to lift a platoon/company it's important to remember that you will very rarely see a 'pure' rifle platoon/company any more. Almost always you will see some sort of enablers attached - a joint fires team (JFT), engineers, interpreters, CIMIC, attachments from support coy etc etc. That's why you need spare seats in vehicles above the base number of grunts in a platoon/company.
In addition, the amount of equipt carried by today's infantry is above that carried in the past - and all this needs space in the vehicles. Consider the manoeuvre support section which is equipped with 84s and Mag-58s with tripods. Add in all the ammunition, day and night sights and batteries for everything, and space in the back of vehicles starts to fill up pretty quick. All this adds up to a lot of vehicles needed to lift the infantry, far more than in the past.
Again, as Foxtrot said the lift squadron is equipped to lift the fighting elements of a single the battalion. The other battalion, as you said, can walk, be airlifted in or use the PMV squadron from the CSSB. Or, the lift squadron of the ACR can kick the first battalion out the back at their objective then come back to pick up the second battalion in a subsequent move (although the crews will fatigue very, very quickly like this).
The CRVs, in their primary role, will not be used to lift infantry (unless they are being used as pseudo cav scouts). However, they will retain the physical capability to do so. That is a key reason why a wheeled vehicle is being bought for the CRV and not a tracked vehicle, even though tracked vehicles would likely be more suited to the very demanding protection requirements. A wheeled CRV provides flexibility, and for deployments of an intensity where deploying tracked vehicles would be unnecessary or provocative, CRVs could be used in the same manner as ASLAVs in Iraq and Afghanistan. They are also far cheaper.
The key issue with the Hawkei is that is about as good as any of the other contenders. It may not necessarily be the absolute best, but it's close enough as makes no practical difference. That being the case, it wouldn't make any sense to buy a foreign made vehicle and lose all the advantages of a domestic build.