1. Probably yes, as long as it is mutually beneficial as it so far has been.
Is it mutually beneficial to the US as a nation-state? I have my doubts. If Israel is really going to cut the US leash, it may lead to the US reconsidering how much it's willing to provide diplomatic support.
2. Probably unaffected. Israel has many reasons to buy American. The aid mechanism is pretty low on the list.
The person you quoted implies this would happen. I'm specifically doubting that argument.
3. Why would it? Except a negligible amount.
Ok so the leash remains. Refuse to sell Israel extra bombs or artillery shells when they need them for a big campaign and you continue to control Israel's behavior. Her whole argument seems to be that by cutting the aid Israel would no longer depend on the US.
4. True.
5. A step in a direction is a step nonetheless.
I think this is no step at all. I think direct aid is only a small portion of Israel's dependence on the US. Cutting it would hurt Israel in terms of financial benefits but wouldn't substantially help in cutting the leash. I think if Israel really wants to be independent on US influence then Israel needs to diversify their security partners. Israel is too small to go it alone, but increasing domestic capacity somewhat might help. Partnering with other major players would too, though it gets really tricky. Because in principle Israel could by Russian FABs and I'm pretty sure Israel has the technical skills to integrate them on their platforms. Except Russia is busy bombing Ukraine into sawdust and anyone openly working with them will have problems in their relationship with most western countries, not to mention issues of availability. Turkey is hostile to Israel and China is a Russian supporter, not to mention they're heading for a potential war with the US, though I suppose Israel could try to partner with them. EU countries are likely to be more of a problem than the US when it comes to Israel going into Gaza. Who's left? South Korea, Indonesia, Japan I guess. There isn't a good alternative to the US for Israel.

