I believe that the Derivatsiya is a better alternative to the Tunguska if used properly.
There is definitely place for a fully passive system in the age of stealth, and it can be vastly augmented by sharing a datalink with less survivable radar-operating systems.
The guns alone do not have a very long range, so an optical system aided by some automatic scanning makes a lot of sense. But with programmable fuzes they can be extremely lethal within their operating range.
Honestly I'd be far more worried if Russia started sending Derivatsiya systems to Syria than something like the Pantsir or a shiny new S-400.
Again I'm unsure what advantage it provides over a tracked Pantsyr. The Pantsyr can also be fully passive, and can definitely datalink with other systems. If the 57mm gun is such a must, why not produce a Land Forces Pantsyr-SV with a 57mm gun? Or merge the Derivatsiya with the Sosna if an all-IR system is that important?
Missiles already exist in many forms. I don't think there needs to be a missile between the Tor and Strela, considering the Tor is quite short ranged.
There is room for a fully passive gun system that can maximize the potential of the gun. A coupled missile could be nice, but it would be a MANPADS at best, which is not a better alternative.
There is one currently. It's being replaced by what to me seems like a less capable system. And remember, the Sosna is a MANPADS, essentially. There's no downside to putting the S and D on the same chassis, and replacing the Tunguska with a Pantsyr. Literally none. No capabilities would be lost, all would be retained, and new capabilities would be added.
We can look at other very high profile examples like the American strike on the Shayrat airbase in 2017, or the multinational strike against alleged CW facilities in 2018.
In 2017, the US launched in 1 strike a total of 59 Tomahawk missiles.
US claim: 58 missiles struck their targets, and an additional 1 malfunctioned. Approximately 20 aircraft were destroyed/damaged. The airbase lost its ability to refuel and rearm planes.
Russian claim: 23 missiles struck, 6 Syrian aircraft destroyed, flights resumed shortly after, and only extremely minimal damage.
Pro Assad media: 15 planes destroyed, plus several tankers caused blasts.
SOHR: A dozen hangars, a fuel depot, and an air defense unit.
Later on ISI published satellite images showing 44 targets were hit, including some that were struck multiple times, including a 5-element SA-6 battery.
Photos surfaced online showing more at least 10 distinct aircraft were destroyed.
It gets interesting. According to the summary you provided, the pro-Assad media agrees most closely with the ISI. But even the anti-Assad SOHR is missing the destroyed aircraft. This not so much highlights a pro-Assad bias in the media as much as it showcases the inherent unreliability of the reports in question. This has been my experience as well, which is why I prefer either photographic evidence, or confirmation from both sides, before definitively stating something.
In 2018, the US, UK, and France conducted a large scale strike involving naval ships and aircraft, against 3 distinct Syrian targets.
Coalition version: 105 missiles were fired. All targets were destroyed and none was intercepted. All missiles appeared to have been either conventional cruise missiles or stealth cruise missiles.
Syria launched 40 SAMs but only after the attack ended, resulting in no effect.
Syrian version: Most of the missiles were downed. A total of 13 near al Kiswah.
Russian version: 71 missiles out of 103 were downed.
SOHR: 65 missiles were downed but considerable damage was inflicted.
Although not spoken of, IIRC, the Barzah compound which was hit by approximately 70 missiles, may have had an underground bunker, which may explain that large amount of JASSM missiles with a penetrating warhead.
In this example, as in the last, the highly anti-Assad SOHR doesn't agree with the coalition version, and even cites large numbers of missile intercepts (though how they got that information is beyond me).
Overall, we can see that Syrian and Russian sources are very inconsistent with each other, and when faced with concrete visual evidence, are often found to be untrue.
So there is just no reason to believe them when they claim something, after low profile strikes that do not always generate visual representation of things.
Sure. I wouldn't take Russian claims at face value in the absence of evidence. You are correct (in my opinion), if that is your entire argument here.