Todjaeger
Potstirrer
I'm torn when it comes to what Canada should do regarding submarines, one of the biggest considerations will be on arctic & ice operations. Are modern SSK's effective in this environment?
To me SSN's have such a clear advantage here that it would seem to be a waste to spend so much capital on a fleet of SSK's (Obviously in a perfect world we would go ahead and acquire a fleet of SSN's but we all know the odds of that ever happening are nearly impossible). So what then? with SSK's we'd pretty much be limited to monitoring entrances and exists of these sea-lanes below the ice but we wouldn't be able to follow any foreign SSN's that are sailing on through in any meaningful way - even with AIP.
Instead of buying a fleet of ~8 SSK's perhaps we'd get more value in keeping a smaller fleet (4-5 subs) and investing the remainder in acoustical surveillance (SOSUS) systems and P-8's?
Subs in JMSDF service have a reputation for being able to dive and engage nuke boats at depth. RAN subs similarly have reputations for being able to operate im enviros usually considered nuke boat territory. AIP is IMO more applicable to littoral ops, as it can allow lurking in an area with a minimal indiscretion rate. It does not provide for high power output, which is something which seems useful vs. nuke boats operating at depth.