Swedish firm Saab bids to design new Royal Australian Navy submarines
You've quoted an article from the Weekend Australian, why? what's your comment or opinion? Many of us have read the paper and formed opinions, in many cases unprintable here.
Swedish firm Saab bids to design new Royal Australian Navy submarines
You've quoted an article from the Weekend Australian, why? what's your comment or opinion? Many of us have read the paper and formed opinions, in many cases unprintable here.
Post deleted
Well, I didn't see it being mentioned, so I thought I post it up as a reference point for further discussion.
Anyway, here's my thought, it is definitely an interesting play by the Swedes. From a political perspective, I don't know going with yet another Swedish sub design will play well in the public after the challenges faced building the Collins class. Well, I know many of the forumers might well be informed that there were various reasons, and wouldn't necessary point fingers at Kockum, or the Swedes, but I feel that the general public, nor some of the less well informed press, might not necessary see it in the same light.
I believe that the HDW Type 216 class or the Japanese's Soryu have the greatest potential to succeed but deep down, I still think that going with the Swede has the potential to yield greater benefits in terms of technological transfer and really firming up the technological know how in submarine building. I also think that it gives us greater potential to even onsell the design to the Canadians in the future. Who knows.
Will be the most interesting to see how the event will unfold. The only thing I think RAN nor Australia can do is to procrastinate further. Just make a decision soon I hope.... and don't god plate everything. Buying 2 subs at a time has a great merit. Just see how the Singaporean did their buy, two Type 218S at a time for an eventual 6 boats.
Fellas I am a long time lurker and first time poster.
I have 2 questions for you. I am interested to know why Angus Houston has been appointed to be in charge of the search for MH370. Not that I have anything against him and I am sure he is very competent but I would have thought that in a maritime environment and with the number of RAN and overseas naval resources involved that a senior RAN Officer would be the logical choice.
I have always wondered about the arrangements which are put in place for payment when foreign ships are replenished by our tankers such as Success and Sirius and vice versa when our ships are replenished at sea by other navy's ships. Does the host nation pay such as Australia in the search for MH370 and other exercises such as RIMPAC or does each navy pay its own expences.
Anyway, here's my thought, it is definitely an interesting play by the Swedes. From a political perspective, I don't know going with yet another Swedish sub design will play well in the public after the challenges faced building the Collins class. Well, I know many of the forumers might well be informed that there were various reasons, and wouldn't necessary point fingers at Kockum, or the Swedes, but I feel that the general public, nor some of the less well informed press, might not necessary see it in the same light.
They are a company that has never built submarines before, poaching staff from an existing submarine manufacturer does not instantly turn them into a first class shipbuilder.
On the other hand, if ASC which has now got a 25 year old history of building/maintaining submarines were to hire on people from HDW, BAe, Electric Boat etc, they would be integrating into an existing team with a clear idea of what the RAN needs (since they have been working with them for the last 25 years or so).
That is why the government will probably send the whole project off shore or build a new green fields site in WA part owned by Austal to deliver a class of trimaran aluminium submarines :finger
The article linked to upthread says that SAAB & TKMS are negotiating over the possible sale of Kockums to SAAB. That's a very different scenario than what you describe.Does it strike you as a bit lop sided that SAAB can supposedly design a suitable submarine for Australia with a couple of hundred poached designers and no background in submarine design ....
The article linked to upthread says that SAAB & TKMS are negotiating over the possible sale of Kockums to SAAB. That's a very different scenario than what you describe.
One of the linked articles seemed to convey the notion that Saab felt it could design/build subs in Sweden and/or Australia if it could purchase Kockums from the Germans, and the subs would be suitable for use by Sweden, Australia, and possibly export to other nations.
IIRC the article was written by McPhedran who either has NFI what he is talking about, or has been put deep into Saab's pocket.
:rolling You are killing me.... :rolling
On a serious note, I do have serious doubt that just having built 1 class of submarine, ASC would be able to design a brand new class of sub independently. I think getting a well established company like TKDM or Mitsubishi Heavy Industries/Kawasaki Shipbuilding Corporation to help in the design of the new "sons of Collins" will ensure that the project will have less design issues, especially on the hull. Components are most likely going to be sourced from foreign firms US/UK/European/Japanese. Don't think ASC has any proven track record in designing the hull or the screw...
Just my 2 cents
:rolling You are killing me.... :rolling
On a serious note, I do have serious doubt that just having built 1 class of submarine, ASC would be able to design a brand new class of sub independently. I think getting a well established company like TKDM or Mitsubishi Heavy Industries/Kawasaki Shipbuilding Corporation to help in the design of the new "sons of Collins" will ensure that the project will have less design issues, especially on the hull. Components are most likely going to be sourced from foreign firms US/UK/European/Japanese. Don't think ASC has any proven track record in designing the hull or the screw...
Just my 2 cents