I’ve got it, it was not Smith at all.
Nope
Incorrect. But not in a position to add more in an open forum
I’ve got it, it was not Smith at all.
I think we need to maintain perspective on this thread. Its not about what may be nice to have and I agree there are many scenarios that can be voiced.
The travesty imposed on the RAN by Smith is simply that; there was no requirement in the DCP, it seems there was no advocacy by either Navy or Defence to purchase it and the ship simply does not fit any force structure.
As others have stated, if the ship was leased/purchased by CMU or AMSA and used for patrols South of 48 degs (see SEA 1180 geographical limits) there would be no controversy. He simply seems to have gone out of his way to antagonise the RAN
Can anyone offer an explanation for Smith's actions in purchasing it?
Nope
Incorrect. But not in a position to add more in an open forum
Shame, I was hoping to have uncovered some dodgy government conspiracy, I would assume somehow he is involved however being the minister responsible for new vessels and the Australian Customs.
Many thanks for the link, this is perhaps the funniest and most pathetic reply we've provided to a story, and to say its a load of shite is really poor argument.It seems Smith and Defence was asked by the Canberra Times about the Skandi Bergen as well as some pointed questions about the current woes of the Tobruk and the Success.
Their reply is that Success has had shaft alignment problems for over 10 years. Attempts to rectify the problems only managed the issue and not fix it. They don't say whether the double-hull conversion worsened the issue, but that the current repairs are an attempt at a long-term fix and will cost $4.1m.
The recent repairs to the Tobruk since 2011 have cost $20.6m and she is planned to be operational in May. Her planned retirement is still set for 2014.
Its no surprise to see the minister cover his arse, but as a serving sailor its disappointing to see the CN tow the line and criticise the article. If he thinks the purchase was correct, hes either being fooled by a political wolf, or is in denial.
I know I am beating my own drum here, final post on this, I promise,
but is there any chance of australia getting patrol boats in the 500t - 600t range
.
]Its no surprise to see the minister cover his arse, but as a serving sailor its disappointing to see the CN tow the line and criticise the article. If he thinks the purchase was correct, hes either being fooled by a political wolf, or is in denial.
By the sound of it and the direction the navy seems to be taking getting 20 corvette type vessels will a long shot at best? how does 20 tinnies sound with sling shots? especially if we could unload them onto the fisheries department after 18months to fill the hole in their budget? Sorry for being stupid but it is REALLY DEPRESSING to me to see what seems to be happening with our defence dept at the moment, and this is only from an observer I can only imagine what its like as an employee.:
...
3. It sits in Sydney harbour looking pretty, and we thought the cruise liners took up to much room in our base.
I know I am beating my own drum here, final post on this, I promise,
but is there any chance of australia getting patrol boats in the 500t - 600t range
here is one
Esmeralda class - Helicopter Database
.
Get thee to an Optomitrist ASAP old son, that is no "greyhound of the seas"...
Functional it may be but I don't think it can ever be described as pretty... unless that word is followed by ugly. I mean the helipad perched where it is...That's not even close to putting lipstick on a pig - more like putting braces on one.
I'd say what we get will be somewhere between the Austral MRV80, the Spanish BAM & the Protector class OPV. If we continue in the same direction they'll be armed with portable sling shots, run on solar power & be made of recycled tissue paper.![]()
First pass for SEA 1180 which will approve the capability requirement (which will cover such things as sling shots and sails) isn’t due until at least 2015. Now I don’t know about you but I’m a card carrying member of the ALP and even I don’t think Labor has a 0.005% chance of winning the next federal election ;-)
So methinks there will be a different in government around when SEA 1180 gets its approved capability requirement. Of course the good Dr. Jensen could be MINDEF under an Abbott Government in which case SEA 1180 first pass approval could be defined as an Air Power Australia mini carrier for the F-111S strike aircraft.
First pass for SEA 1180 which will approve the capability requirement (which will cover such things as sling shots and sails) isn’t due until at least 2015. Now I don’t know about you but I’m a card carrying member of the ALP and even I don’t think Labor has a 0.005% chance of winning the next federal election ;-)
So methinks there will be a different in government around when SEA 1180 gets its approved capability requirement. Of course the good Dr. Jensen could be MINDEF under an Abbott Government in which case SEA 1180 first pass approval could be defined as an Air Power Australia mini carrier for the F-111S strike aircraft.
First pass for SEA 1180 which will approve the capability requirement (which will cover such things as sling shots and sails) isn’t due until at least 2015