But yet the government we bought it from many would contend are behaving foolishly.

:
With the purchase of Choules, that is perhaps one of the few non-foolish things Gov't has recently done. The capabilities of a
Bay-class LSD match up quite closely with some requirements of JP2048 for the third sealift/amphib ship. The ADF was able to purchase the ex-Largs Bay at a bargain price, right when the RAN was desparately in need of new vessels to provide sealift.
Firstly I empathize with navy members that have extended time away from they're families.I have done similar for work related issues myself and children need connection to they're dads and mums. If labor (in particular) are responsible for this then they are not living up to theyre ideals. But is the problem ships or is it crews?
Why isn't navy experimenting with the Blue/gold team manning arrangements? this concept was tested by the USN and they seem to think that it works.Ive lurked on this site for a while now and recently you, yourself stated that crewing the vessels isn't a major problem. why isn't navy just cycling ships that need servicing into the reserve status and taking out the fresher ships. I understand that that might not have some of the capabilities.
But they all should be able to do the Persian gulf run shouldn't they? Only one unit is fully upgraded with improved ASMD fitout as far as I know. And even if they all don't have the 8X Harpoons this shouldn't stop them from participating in low threat areas (Pacific, Asia) for the time being? I mean if what i have suggested is totally of base please update me
The problem AFAIK is neither crews nor the ships themselves, rather it is Gov't which is causing the problem. In addition to the ships which are entering the ASMD upgrade, two
Anzac-class FFH's are tied up at dock instead of going out to sea. This is done because the cost to operate a vessel at sea is higher than keeping the same ship at dock. The crew is not much of a problem, as there are sufficient naval personnel on shore duty who could be assigned to the two frigates if they were operational and at sea. In fact, some RAN personnel have opted to transfer to ACPB ops, so that they could be assigned to a vessel which still gets underway.
Having a Blue/Gold crew arrangement for the currently deploying frigates would only help in the sense that the vessel crews could have more time ashore to spend with their families. What gets missed is that some of these deployments are so far away, that in order to sustain them the deployments are by their nature long. The other part of this issue, which has been a bit of a recurring bugbear for the RAN, is that the current frigates (those not undergoing upgrade yet or tied up at dock) are seeing so much use that they are suffering accelerated wear & tear. Adding delays and deferring maintenance because the RAN needs vessels to meet service needs just exacerbates the problem. All so that in the short-term, Gov't can reduce the Defence spend and perhaps show a budgetary surplus.
I do wish people would realize that by taking such short-term actions to save money have real long-terms costs, both in actual fiscal terms as well as capabilities.
According to Wikipedia In 2006 REMORA lost its umbilical cable and sank. It was recovered in April 2007 but was never adopted into service. the reason stated is the Det Norske Veritas classification society refused it classification. But Remora was the basis for the United States Navy's Submarine Rescue Diving Recompression System. To cover its loss to RAN the British LR5 was lease to replace it.
Dont know if this correct can anybody correct me if this information is out date.
If
Skandi Bergen was being purchased to operate some form of sub rescue system, that would be one thing, but much of the undersea equipment is being removed prior to entering RAN service. The RAN is getting the
Skandi Bergen as an "amphibious" vessel. Granted, there is perhaps the capability to carry ~1,000 tons of cargo, and also can operate a helicopter... There is no way to land any cargo carried unless the vessel can dock at a port. So, no actual way for an "amphibious" vessel to actually conduct amphibious operation. Secondly, the
Skandi Bergen is only going to be in RAN service a short time, ~18 months, before being transferred to Customs. Basically the RAN is spending A$130 mil. to get 18 months of service out of a vessel which is unsuitable for the stated role, and that is before one even factors in the potential issues surrounding operating a RAN vessel with a civilian crew. There are so many elements of this which are questionable in terms of legality and rationality that it strikes me as the sort of brainchild of someone with the authority to ignore the considered advice of service and maritime personnel, coupled with the ego to do so.
-Cheers