Royal Australian Navy Discussions and Updates 2.0

Until a new Invincible class could be built....
My dad was in navy recruiting in the early 80s, and I actually have some promotional stickers from 81/82 of Invincible as part of the RAN. They were part of a series which included ddgs, ffgs and fcpb. Obviously the Invincible versions were recalled, when it kicked off in the South Atlantic, and presumably all destroyed, but I still have a handful of them. Ahhh, what could have been....
 
Given the current state of Victoria maybe one of the bluebottles would be appropriate? Or a Cape class at best.

Or does albo have a dinghy he takes out on Lake Burley Griffin?

Edit: for clarity, absolutely no disrespect intended for the previous Melbourne’s and their crews.

All disrespect to my southern neighbours however ;)
Morgo, I'm one of your southern neighbours and absolutely disgusted with the cesspool down here. I want to leave but my family and hobby shop prevent me.
 
Given the current state of Victoria maybe one of the bluebottles would be appropriate? Or a Cape class at best.

Or does albo have a dinghy he takes out on Lake Burley Griffin?

Edit: for clarity, absolutely no disrespect intended for the previous Melbourne’s and their crews.

All disrespect to my southern neighbours however ;)
Ouch!
 
Why not build 6 AAW versions of the Hunter class, suitably stretched and with additional VLS (it does not need the multiple mission bays as it is not a GP vessel). 3 to replace the AWDs at the end of their life and an additional 3 to expand the fleet. Simple.
Having asked a very senior Admiral this question ... because it would be overkill and excessive for the mission.

The main cost of the T26 design is in the ASW tech built into the hull. The quietening, the layout, it is all optimised to hunt something that, quite frankly, has every advantage over a a surface ship you could ask for.

A DDG though, that is noisy by it's very definition. It hunts something else and consequently not only needs different electronic and quietening designs, but also in damage mitigation. To use a ASW hull for a AAW mission would undermine the latter (perhaps only by a little, but when you are throwing around multi-Regimental raids with super/hypersonic weapons, little ends up mattering) and likely add little - except for cost.

While I appreciate commonality across the fleet, it made sense. As much as a one ship fleet would be intriguing (ironically, also adding risk though), having three MFU isn't really the worst. Especially if SEA 5000 delivers at least six ships. That would see a fleet of 3x DDG, 6x FFG and 11x FFH - not too shabby, minimal risk and best optimisation.
 
Having asked a very senior Admiral this question ... because it would be overkill and excessive for the mission.

The main cost of the T26 design is in the ASW tech built into the hull. The quietening, the layout, it is all optimised to hunt something that, quite frankly, has every advantage over a a surface ship you could ask for.

A DDG though, that is noisy by it's very definition. It hunts something else and consequently not only needs different electronic and quietening designs, but also in damage mitigation. To use a ASW hull for a AAW mission would undermine the latter (perhaps only by a little, but when you are throwing around multi-Regimental raids with super/hypersonic weapons, little ends up mattering) and likely add little - except for cost.

While I appreciate commonality across the fleet, it made sense. As much as a one ship fleet would be intriguing (ironically, also adding risk though), having three MFU isn't really the worst. Especially if SEA 5000 delivers at least six ships. That would see a fleet of 3x DDG, 6x FFG and 11x FFH - not too shabby, minimal risk and best optimisation.
With the exception that our current DDG don’t really have the cell count that is actually optimal - particularly if cells are given up to TLAM./ Land Strike. Particularly so noting the current RAN restrictions around downloading and changing loadout).
 
If taking into considerations the economies of scale accounting for production of the preceding Hunter class, the continuing efficiencies of continuing a known build architecture, then perhaps it’s not necessarily as prohibitively expensive after all?

Pretty good to have acoustically quiet features on your DDG, I would imagine.
 
Given the current state of Victoria maybe one of the bluebottles would be appropriate? Or a Cape class at best.

Or does albo have a dinghy he takes out on Lake Burley Griffin?

Edit: for clarity, absolutely no disrespect intended for the previous Melbourne’s and their crews.

All disrespect to my southern neighbours however ;)
Morgo, I disavow myself from any responsibility for the Victorian dog's breakfast. LOL
 
64 Strike length VLS cells amidships plus 16 NSM canisters above them would make it into a destroyer with that much firepower. Retain the 127mm gun up front. It will certainly stop the valley of death in construction. I won't be around to see it. I really think two or more of the F110 Flight II would certainly give us a quicker increase to our firepower in dangerous times.
I think 96 cells plus RAM, SeaRAM or Phalanx is more than enough. Add a couple of 30mm guns, Nulka, a high powered laser and torpedo decoys and we're loaded for bear as the Americans like to say. We don't need Trump Battleships.

Honestly it might not even need to be stretched depending on whether or not you need the mission bay.

Fit strike length VLS into the area where the mission bay is currently as long as there is enough height and weight margins in the design.

Depending on how CEAFAR compares to the most modern SPY radar in 10-15 years time it might not even need a different sensor fitout.
There is already talks about removing the mission bay to add additional VLS's on the Hunter's without major modifications.
I dis post this a while ago, but it may make sense to have the last 3 built to this standard.

Cheers

Beefing up the Hunter class | The Australian Naval Institute
 
A hunter class class converted to straight DDG and extra VLS with out noise dampening ,how likely to be cheaper and quicker to produce ?
It wouldn’t be, even if it was possible - much of the noise control is in hull and propellor design and it is not easy (or advisable, actually) to change those - if you do you might as well start again. Then, the drive train is optimised for quietness - hence the electric drive. If you leave that intact you might as well save yourself the design effort of changing the mountings, which is also a major silencing point. If you choose to do so, then go with a straight CODAG drive - but again that’s such a major change you might as well start from scratch. DDGs do do ASW, BTW, they’re just not normally optimised for it -so some element of self noise control is useful, if not of course essential. But you wouldn’t go out of your way if you were starting from scratch. Hobarts and Burkes are actually pretty good ASW platforms, that just not their main job.
 
It wouldn’t be, even if it was possible - much of the noise control is in hull and propellor design and it is not easy (or advisable, actually) to change those - if you do you might as well start again. Then, the drive train is optimised for quietness - hence the electric drive. If you leave that intact you might as well save yourself the design effort of changing the mountings, which is also a major silencing point. If you choose to do so, then go with a straight CODAG drive - but again that’s such a major change you might as well start from scratch. DDGs do do ASW, BTW, they’re just not normally optimised for it -so some element of self noise control is useful, if not of course essential. But you wouldn’t go out of your way if you were starting from scratch. Hobarts and Burkes are actually pretty good ASW platforms, that just not their main job.
How much would the quiet hull be affected if we just removed the mission bay and added 64 Strike Length Mk.41 VLS?
Would there be a change to the hull?
 
Far better to build a purpose designed destroyer or cruiser with a decent magazine depth and a mission bay.

We have, up until the Hunter and GPF, gone smaller and lighter than we needed, aiming to increase numbers, which, never happened. These ships need to be highend, multi-role vessels.
 
Morgo, I'm one of your southern neighbours and absolutely disgusted with the cesspool down here. I want to leave but my family and hobby shop prevent me.
Without wanting to go OT I really hope it gets sorted out.

Strong Victoria = Strong Commwealth.

…. = Strong RAN

(see mods it’s relevant!)
 
How much would the quiet hull be affected if we just removed the mission bay and added 64 Strike Length Mk.41 VLS?
Would there be a change to the hull?
You would probably have to rearrange some of the surrounding spaces and modify some of the services - power and possibly water including potentially adding magazine quality firefighting support. Then, you’d have to have redone the stability, girder and deck strength, and weight and balance calculations, if the weight or deck loading exceeds the current designed capacity of the mission bay, which it might. You would have to model the effects of the exhaust plume on upper deck fitting, masts etc in the area and modify as necessary. However as the designers (BAE) have already displayed a model with that modification made one would hope that work has all been done already.
 
Last edited:
You would probably have to rearrange some of the surrounding spaces and modify some of the services - power and possibly water including potentially adding magazine quality firefighting support. Then, you’d have to have redone the stability, girder and deck strength, and weight and balance calculations, if the weight or deck loading exceeds the current designed capacity of the mission bay, which it might. You would have to model the effects of the exhaust plume on upper deck fitting, masts etc in the area and modify as necessary. However as the designers (BAE) have already displayed a model with that modification made one would hope that work has all been done already.
It's a lot of weight up high.

Ballast, increased draft and an additional GT to compensate for the weight. An AW ship will need more sensors, not less, so even more top weight.

Volume limits will require the removal of additional ASW systems.

Bite the bullet and get a new hull designed for the job. Multiple navies have requirements for large, multi role ships that would fit the bill.

Italy (Italian Navy)
  • DDX Next-Generation Destroyers: In September 2026, Italy signed a €3.7 billion contract via OCCAR with Orizzonte Sistemi Navali (Fincantieri and Leonardo) for two 13,500-tonne destroyers. Scheduled for delivery in 2033 and 2035, the 180-metre ships feature 80 Vertical Launch System (VLS) cells, Leonardo's SADOC 5 combat system, a digital S-band AESA radar, and integrated air and ballistic/hypersonic missile defence. [1, 2, 3]

Germany (German Navy)
  • F127 Next-Generation Air-Defence Frigates: Germany plans to procure eight 12,000-tonne F127 air-defence frigates (destroyer-sized combatants) starting in the mid-2030s to replace its F124 Sachsen-class ships. Approved for US export in April 2026, the baseline design pairs 96 Mk 41 VLS cells with the AN/SPY-6(V)1 radar and Aegis combat system to fire SM-2, SM-3, and SM-6 interceptors, though the program is undergoing cost scrutiny in late 2026 after estimates exceeded €40 billion. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • Uncrewed "Wingman" Arsenal Ships: Alongside the F127, Germany plans to acquire three large remote missile vessels to act as uncrewed magazine extensions for its air-defence frigates. [1]

France (French Navy)
  • SCX26 Stealth Destroyer Concept: Unveiled by Naval Group at Euronaval in November 2026, the SCX26 is a 170-metre next-generation stealth destroyer concept intended to eventually succeed the Horizon class. It is designed as a drone-warfare command hub carrying up to 96–100+ missile cells alongside extensive facilities for uncrewed surface, aerial, and underwater systems.
Japan (Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force)
  • Aegis System Equipped Vessels (ASEV): Japan has two massive 14,000-tonne (standard displacement) ballistic missile defence cruisers under construction to replace the cancelled Aegis Ashore land batteries. Equipped with Lockheed Martin's AN/SPY-7(V)1 radar, J7.B Aegis combat system, and 128 VLS cells, the two vessels remain on track for commissioning in 2028. [1, 2, 3]

South Korea (Republic of Korea Navy)
  • KDDX Next-Generation Destroyers: Following a two-year procurement delay, South Korea awarded Hanwha Ocean the detailed design and lead-ship construction contract in mid-2026 for six 6,000-tonne KDDX "mini-Aegis" destroyers. Featuring full-electric propulsion and an indigenous multi-function radar and combat system, the lead ship is scheduled for delivery in 2032.
 
You would probably have to rearrange some of the surrounding spaces and modify some of the services - power and possibly water including potentially adding magazine quality firefighting support. Then, you’d have to have redone the stability, girder and deck strength, and weight and balance calculations, if the weight or deck loading exceeds the current designed capacity of the mission bay, which it might. You would have to model the effects of the exhaust plume on upper deck fitting, masts etc in the area and modify as necessary. However as the designers (BAE) have already displayed a model with that modification made one would hope that work has all been done already.
Thanks Spoz
 
It's a lot of weight up high.

Ballast, increased draft and an additional GT to compensate for the weight. An AW ship will need more sensors, not less, so even more top weight.

Volume limits will require the removal of additional ASW systems.

Bite the bullet and get a new hull designed for the job. Multiple navies have requirements for large, multi role ships that would fit the bill.

Italy (Italian Navy)
  • DDX Next-Generation Destroyers: In September 2026, Italy signed a €3.7 billion contract via OCCAR with Orizzonte Sistemi Navali (Fincantieri and Leonardo) for two 13,500-tonne destroyers. Scheduled for delivery in 2033 and 2035, the 180-metre ships feature 80 Vertical Launch System (VLS) cells, Leonardo's SADOC 5 combat system, a digital S-band AESA radar, and integrated air and ballistic/hypersonic missile defence. [1, 2, 3]

Germany (German Navy)
  • F127 Next-Generation Air-Defence Frigates: Germany plans to procure eight 12,000-tonne F127 air-defence frigates (destroyer-sized combatants) starting in the mid-2030s to replace its F124 Sachsen-class ships. Approved for US export in April 2026, the baseline design pairs 96 Mk 41 VLS cells with the AN/SPY-6(V)1 radar and Aegis combat system to fire SM-2, SM-3, and SM-6 interceptors, though the program is undergoing cost scrutiny in late 2026 after estimates exceeded €40 billion. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • Uncrewed "Wingman" Arsenal Ships: Alongside the F127, Germany plans to acquire three large remote missile vessels to act as uncrewed magazine extensions for its air-defence frigates. [1]

France (French Navy)
  • SCX26 Stealth Destroyer Concept: Unveiled by Naval Group at Euronaval in November 2026, the SCX26 is a 170-metre next-generation stealth destroyer concept intended to eventually succeed the Horizon class. It is designed as a drone-warfare command hub carrying up to 96–100+ missile cells alongside extensive facilities for uncrewed surface, aerial, and underwater systems.
Japan (Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force)
  • Aegis System Equipped Vessels (ASEV): Japan has two massive 14,000-tonne (standard displacement) ballistic missile defence cruisers under construction to replace the cancelled Aegis Ashore land batteries. Equipped with Lockheed Martin's AN/SPY-7(V)1 radar, J7.B Aegis combat system, and 128 VLS cells, the two vessels remain on track for commissioning in 2028. [1, 2, 3]

South Korea (Republic of Korea Navy)
  • KDDX Next-Generation Destroyers: Following a two-year procurement delay, South Korea awarded Hanwha Ocean the detailed design and lead-ship construction contract in mid-2026 for six 6,000-tonne KDDX "mini-Aegis" destroyers. Featuring full-electric propulsion and an indigenous multi-function radar and combat system, the lead ship is scheduled for delivery in 2032.
Interesting how you hear the argument that surface ships have had their day and here you have some of the worlds bigger navy’s building even bigger ships to deal with the maritime domain of the future.

Things just keep evolving

Cheers S
 
The Italian, Korean and French ships would require a lot of rework for the RAN since they are using locally developed radar, combat system, VLS and weapons.

The German ship could be an option, and probably a bit closer in size to what the RAN is likely to get funding for?

Alternatively if the RAN wanted to go for a CEAFAR equipped ship, maybe see if the RN (AUKUS) would consider a joint development? I'm assuming they are likely to stick with Aster & CAMM, but they are planning on all their future ships having Mk.41 VLS so unless BAe has a fixed face AESA under development maybe they would consider CEAFAR, with PAAMS Mk.II and Aster/CAMM?

If the RAN decided to stick with CEAFAR radars for their next AAW combatants they would be able to leverage the work done for Hunter class.
 
Or design our own hull and use the supply chains we established for Hunter and Mogami. It's not rocket science, we have the talent and the whole idea of doing Hunter the way we did it was to build a sovereign ship design and build capability
 
Or design our own hull and use the supply chains we established for Hunter and Mogami. It's not rocket science, we have the talent and the whole idea of doing Hunter the way we did it was to build a sovereign ship design and build capability

Sure, but the program probably needs to start now before any of those people get a chance to move on?
 
Back
Top