Anyone questioning the cost and glacial pace and schedule of RAN ship construction. Singapore just built an 8000 tonne frigate and took 12 months from keel laying to launch. The first of a planned 6 and is planned to be commissioned into service in 2028. The ship cost is around $200m per ship.
Planned as hybrid frigates and drone motherships, the Multi-Role Combat Vessels will be able to project naval power further, and for longer, than previous Singaporean warships. Planned as hybrid frigates and drone motherships, the Multi-Role Combat Vessels will be able to project naval power...
www.twz.com
Following the announcement of the new contract signed between Singapore and ST Engineering to build multirole combat vessels, Akash Pratim Debbarma, Defense Analyst at GlobalData, offered his view:
asiapacificdefencereporter.com
TBH no, not really. I do question the TWZ article as well as the writer of the article. The capability claim sounds like it might be a bit beyond hyperbolic, particularly when one keeps in mind the claimed price tag per vessel.
That pricetag of $200 mil. per vessel is less than the cost for a set of Aegis CMS and SPY arrays for a single vessel, never mind anything else a warship requires like a hull, weapons, machinery, etc.
Now I have not been able to work out what the cost per vessel was for Sinagpore's
Formidable-class frigates, Taiwan's
Kang Ding-class frigates, another derivative of DCNS's
La Fayette-class frigate, cost roughly $300 mil. per vessel back in the early 1990's. This is the rough number I get when substracting some of the funding involved in the frigate purchase which might have actually been spent on kickbacks and other corrupt purposes. Otherwise, then one would be talking about $500 mil. per vessel, and again this would be in 1990's dollars, not 2025 dollars.
That makes me thing that whatever Singapore is getting for $200 mil. is not really that capable as a warship, or that is 'just' the price for the hull and perhaps the design, rather than an actual, completed warship. Given that the article mentions that now launched vessel will move to a yard for further outfitting, it is quite possible that a good deal of kit was not included in the pricetag.
Also, if one keeps in mind that OPV's typically run about $100 mil. and lack the sort of sophisticated sensors and CMS for a proper warship, that can provide a sort of base line when talking price.
Lastly, the article itself mentions the class including lead ship are planned for delivery starting in 2028 and onward. This means quite a bit of work remains to be done.