China May Soon Have 800 Missiles Targeting Taiwan

Pathfinder-X

Tribal Warlord
Verified Defense Pro
The rapid growth is causing huge inflation in cities everywhere around China. I remember I could get a bowl of noodle near my elementry school in China for 3 dollars in 1996 before I came to Canada, last time I went back about 2 years ago it cost me 23(Same noodle shop). While the rich keeps hitting the jackpot in the boom, the income for average citizens remain relatively the same. If something isn't done about it by Beijing soon, the country might be torn apart.
 

ashoaib

New Member
Well I think seek independence is the right of Taiwaness people coz its their island and they have more right over it then china and they should be allowed to do what they want to do. If they want to separate than china or other must keep their legs away. :mad
 

Pathfinder-X

Tribal Warlord
Verified Defense Pro
ashoaib said:
Well I think seek independence is the right of Taiwaness people coz its their island and they have more right over it then china and they should be allowed to do what they want to do. If they want to separate than china or other must keep their legs away. :mad
The island of Taiwan has been part of China since Tang dynasty. It was taken over by Dutch in the 1500's or 1600's(I'm bad at chinese history) but reunified by Zheng Cheng Gong in Ming dynasty. After the Chinese loss at the naval battle of Yellow Sea to Japanese navy, it was given over to Japanese along with several tons of silver and gold as compensations. Nationalist government reclaim it after the Japanese defeat but escape to the island when they got defeated by communist forces. All people from Taiwan were originally from mainland China. So tell me, what makes you think China must keep their feet away? If your son no longer wishes to carry your name and claims part of your house as his, what would you do?
 

highsea

New Member
sri said:
I heard of a freedom movement in the islands of hawaii
Pretty much every state has one group or another that advocates separation from the union. Usually these are the so-called "militias". Mainly they are just pissed off about paying taxes. :D:

Then you've got the southerners who still think they won the civil war. Lol, they are pretty harmless in general, every so often they kick up and cause some damage, but for the most part they are just blowhards.

Hawaii became a state in 1959 as a result of a political status plebiscite in which 94% of all the votes were in favor of statehood. Like Texas, the vast majority are perfectly content to remain a part of the US.

There is also a strong statehood movement in both Guam and Puerto Rico today, with the majorities of both territories favoring full statehood. I think Puerto Rico will be first, as they have more support in the US.

I support them, as I think they deserve the benefits this would afford them. Neither territory could survive economically on their own, and by gaining statehood, they would get some major economic benefits. Also, the right to vote in US elections and better representation in Congress. Both the Republican and the Democratic Parties in the US have stated that they would approve statehood if the majority of the populations of the islands voted for it. I would not be surprised to see a plebiscite in Puerto Rico in the next decade.

I also support Taiwan's full independence from China, though I don't think it will happen anytime soon. Considering they fought for and won it in 1949, I think they are entitled to it.
 

Pathfinder-X

Tribal Warlord
Verified Defense Pro
highsea said:
I also support Taiwan's full independence from China, though I don't think it will happen anytime soon. Considering they fought for and won it in 1949, I think they are entitled to it.
I believe the Nationalist was defeated and escape to Taiwan carrying everything they could in 1949. Where did the victory came from? The only reason Mao didn't attack Taiwan at the time was there wasn't enough boats and escort vessel to launch a successful campaign. Although I do consider the ROC government to be a legitimate one, for they can be traced back to 1913, a whole 14 years before Chinese communist party was formed in 1927. So technically, they're still the government of China, but realistically, communist are the government of China.
 

highsea

New Member
Pathfinder-X said:
I believe the Nationalist was defeated and escape to Taiwan carrying everything they could in 1949. Where did the victory came from? The only reason Mao didn't attack Taiwan at the time was there wasn't enough boats and escort vessel to launch a successful campaign. Although I do consider the ROC government to be a legitimate one, for they can be traced back to 1913, a whole 14 years before Chinese communist party was formed in 1927. So technically, they're still the government of China, but realistically, communist are the government of China.
Yes, Chaing-Kai-shek was defeated in mainland China. I didn't phrase my comment well. Sorry.

From what I've read, Taiwan was originally settled by people of Polynesian/Malay descent. When the Dutch took over in the 1620's, they imported Chinese from the mainland as workers. These Chinese intermarried with the aboriginal population, and their descendants are the modern day Taiwanese.

When the Dutch were driven off, the Manchu emperors tried to extend their influence over the island, but were not very successful, with continuous clashes between the locals and the officials from the mainland. It wasn't until the late 1880's that the Manchu Imperial Authorities declared Taiwan to be a province of China. When Japan defeated China in the Sino-Japanese war in 1895, China ceded Taiwan to Japan "in perpetuity".

So Japan ruled Taiwan for 50 years, but when Japan was defeated in WW2, the Allied powers agreed to let Chaing "temporarily" occupy Taiwan in 1945, as their agent. In 1949, after losing to the communists, Chaing re-established the remainder of his government permanently in Taiwan. In 1951-1952, the San Francisco Peace Treaty formally concluded the war with Japan, and the treaty allowed for Taiwan's status to be determined by the principles of the UN. Basically it meant that the Taiwanese people should determine their own fate.

So I will clarify my comment. I think the Taiwanese people should be the ones determining their fate. If they choose independence, it should be honored. If they choose to join with China, that should be honored also.

-CM
 

redsoulja

New Member
sorry i did stumble on my comment regarding chinese economy n comparison, but i ams tillsuer that india has a significant percentage of the world's poor (i still think 50%)
 

Pathfinder-X

Tribal Warlord
Verified Defense Pro
highsea said:
Yes, Chaing-Kai-shek was defeated in mainland China. I didn't phrase my comment well. Sorry.

From what I've read, Taiwan was originally settled by people of Polynesian/Malay descent. When the Dutch took over in the 1620's, they imported Chinese from the mainland as workers. These Chinese intermarried with the aboriginal population, and their descendants are the modern day Taiwanese.

When the Dutch were driven off, the Manchu emperors tried to extend their influence over the island, but were not very successful, with continuous clashes between the locals and the officials from the mainland. It wasn't until the late 1880's that the Manchu Imperial Authorities declared Taiwan to be a province of China. When Japan defeated China in the Sino-Japanese war in 1895, China ceded Taiwan to Japan "in perpetuity".

So Japan ruled Taiwan for 50 years, but when Japan was defeated in WW2, the Allied powers agreed to let Chaing "temporarily" occupy Taiwan in 1945, as their agent. In 1949, after losing to the communists, Chaing re-established the remainder of his government permanently in Taiwan. In 1951-1952, the San Francisco Peace Treaty formally concluded the war with Japan, and the treaty allowed for Taiwan's status to be determined by the principles of the UN. Basically it meant that the Taiwanese people should determine their own fate.

So I will clarify my comment. I think the Taiwanese people should be the ones determining their fate. If they choose independence, it should be honored. If they choose to join with China, that should be honored also.

-CM
Here is a quote from the official ROC government site on Taiwan's ethnic composition.

Archaeologists have found evidence of prehistoric human habitation in Taiwan that dates back 12,000 to 15,000 years, indicating that Taiwan's earliest inhabitants came from at least two places: southern China and Austronesia. In general, early settlers from southern China settled in northern and central Taiwan, while Australoid settlements were mainly in southern Taiwan and along the eastern coast. These early settlers, which now compose Taiwan's indigenous peoples, make up less than 2 percent of Taiwan's population.

In the 16th century, Han (º~) people from China's coastal provinces of Fujian (ºÖ«Ø)and Guangdong (¼sªF) began immigrating to Taiwan in large numbers to build a new homeland away from war and famine. This group of early Han immigrants consisted mainly of Southern Fujianese and Hakka. Today, these two groups constitute about 85 percent of the population, with the Fujianese outnumbering the Hakka by a ratio of approximately three to one. When the Kuomintang (¤¤°ê°ê¥ÃÄÒ,KMT) government relocated to Taipei in 1949, it brought a new influx of Han immigrants to Taiwan. The Han form the largest ethnic group in Taiwan, making up roughly 98 percent of the population; 15 percent of this group came to Taiwan after 1945. Taiwan's population also consists of almost 60 other non-Han minorities.
Link: http://www.gio.gov.tw/taiwan-website/5-gp/yearbook/chpt02.htm#2

Unifications wasn't much of a problem between people of mainland and Taiwan before late 1980's because the dispute wasn't whether Taiwan is part of China, it was mainly on who is the true government of China. The current ruling party of Taiwan, Min Jin Dang, along with Taiwan Christian Elders Society, introduced the idea that Taiwan should be independent nations, not part of China. Recently many people in Taiwan's call for replacing the name Rublic of China with Republic of Taiwan. I think that where Beijing will draw the red line on retaking the island. Btw, I should also mention the fact that Taiwan's population on the issue is divided by half, one side supports remaining the same while other pushes for Republic of Taiwan and change of consititution.
 

berry580

New Member
Who has what right is debatable. But blaming someone for war mongering after talking about military action yourself and aiming 800 odd missiles at them is just plain hipocritical and sad.
That is IF they want to become rebels (as in officially) by declaring independence. In case you don't know, those missiles are aimed to the sky, not any particular island.
China will not get Taiwan back by power these types of problems are solved by political manner not by power.
Depends on what the Taiwanese themselves do. (i.e If they declare independence, then byebye....)
thus india must one day reabsorb pakistan and bangladesh
If they want their country to be strong, then yes. Unity is what makes a country strong.
China drives the production engine of the world, China is producing waay too much. The main player on the consumer side is the US which is not seeing growth. Hence eventually if China keeps producing more and more, then eventually a time will come when no one could buy what they produce. Hence the Chinese don't get any ROI (return of investment), and in just one season the economy could crash back to the middle ages.
Do you have a clue what is non-durable goods, talk about economics? People will sooner or later need to buy stuff, and since Chinese product are the cheapest, they'll generally choose "made in China" produces.
Second, India doesn't have half the world's poor, your facts are messed up. Please check them again.
That was an exaggeration
- There is a growing perception that India will be able to compete with China on more equitable terms within 10 years. If India had not taken a hit in 1997, some economists and strategists believe that she would be even closer to achieving parity.
You mean China had taken nothing back in 1997?
Chinas economy is overheating, couple that with some significant social separation, she could go through a revisit of 1949 in a worst case scenario.
Well is an overheating economy with a sustainable level of economic growth!!
Going back to 1949? What? You mean when all and US, European investors leave China?
That almost scared me...... LOL
The rapid growth is causing huge inflation in cities everywhere around China. I remember I could get a bowl of noodle near my elementry school in China for 3 dollars in 1996 before I came to Canada, last time I went back about 2 years ago it cost me 23(Same noodle shop). While the rich keeps hitting the jackpot in the boom, the income for average citizens remain relatively the same. If something isn't done about it by Beijing soon, the country might be torn apart.
Well they're trying to keep it down. These thinbgs are simply inevitable in a growing economy.
I heard of a freedom movement in the islands of hawaii
In thats case, then I guess you'll hear Hawaiians accused of being armed with WMD in CNN soon. And guess who's gonna save the world?!! ROFLMAO
 

srirangan

Banned Member
>> In case you don't know, those missiles are aimed to the sky,
>> not any particular island.

Do you think I'm a 2 year old kid, that is a rubbish argument/

>> Do you have a clue what is non-durable goods, talk about economics?
>> People will sooner or later need to buy stuff, and since Chinese
>> product are the cheapest, they'll generally choose "made in China"
>> produces.

Yea well, you are producing a lot more than they can buy. There is a limit, like it or not, China is exceeding it, at their own peril.

Berry, of topic comment, cut down the pro-China anti-US anti-India anti-Taiwan rhetoric. Your arguments and posts seem very unorganized and plain propaganda'ish instead of a serious discussion of the issue. It does not paint a good picture of yourself or your background.
 

gf0012-aust

Grumpy Old Man
Staff member
Verified Defense Pro
berry580 said:
In case you don't know, those missiles are aimed to the sky, not any particular island.
I'm assuming you're joking? They're short range ballistic missiles - they can only reach Taiwan or Japan

The shore based batteries use variations fo the Russian Styx - which also means that they can only reach Taiwan. In addition, the C8 series of shore based missiles are ramp launched, they're not VLS (which is irrelevant)
 

tatra

New Member
Verified Defense Pro
berry580 said:
In case you don't know, those missiles are aimed to the sky, not any particular island.
In that case, there will be no objections to having them point to the sky somewhere out of range of this particular island, or will there?

berry580 said:
If they want their country to be strong, then yes. Unity is what makes a country strong.
What drivel! Confusing QUALITY ("national unity") with QUANTITY ("whether a country oncludes some territory or people") here. Also, sound a little too much like that little Austrian corporal used to say: "heim ins Reich".
 

ashoaib

New Member
Pathfinder-X said:
ashoaib said:
Well I think seek independence is the right of Taiwaness people coz its their island and they have more right over it then china and they should be allowed to do what they want to do. If they want to separate than china or other must keep their legs away. :mad
The island of Taiwan has been part of China since Tang dynasty. It was taken over by Dutch in the 1500's or 1600's(I'm bad at chinese history) but reunified by Zheng Cheng Gong in Ming dynasty. After the Chinese loss at the naval battle of Yellow Sea to Japanese navy, it was given over to Japanese along with several tons of silver and gold as compensations. Nationalist government reclaim it after the Japanese defeat but escape to the island when they got defeated by communist forces. All people from Taiwan were originally from mainland China. So tell me, what makes you think China must keep their feet away? If your son no longer wishes to carry your name and claims part of your house as his, what would you do?
Yeah I'll give him a fair share coz as a father I will be responsible of his arival in this world.
 

Pathfinder-X

Tribal Warlord
Verified Defense Pro
WOW!!! China pointing missiles in the sky, they must plan to attack aliens and establish a moon colony. :D:
 
Top