Don't forget they are doing the job of the 2 Albions and Ocean too!
Just to clarify, I'm saying the RN should have merged the replacement of the: LPD (2 hulls & 25,000t) & CVH (3 hulls & 60,000t) with 3 ships of 45-50,000.
Still a massive increase in tonnage 85,000t (105,000 if you include the LPH) v 135-150,000t. It is worth note what we have available today: 1 x LPH, 2 x LPD (1 reserve) & 1 X CVH = 73,000
The assumption is the LPH/Ocean was not needed as the role could have been covered by a CVH (even before this was proved when one went into reserve).
The trouble with single role focused ships, is they are often not able to be used to the full extent, and people then looking for economies start laying them up. The more multi role a ship is, the more active and visible, a virtuous circle. We see this at the moment with Albion and the proposal with one CVF.
A multi role ship would probably not be able to avoid this either, but it’s more flexible having 1 out of 3 in dock than if you have 2 + 2 and you end up with 1+1 and 1+1 in reserve.
I think it was the right decision to increase carrier aviation, but the scale was quite unaffordable. We had c40 FA2 (just looking at RN numbers), how much better is the F35b, so to equal numbers would be a massive improvement. I think a modest increase in numbers would be good to aspire to, so maybe 3 x 18/20 (or 2 x 30 for CVF).
This does not include GR9 numbers, which were the original F35 proposal of c130, so maybe the CVF size was driven be other consideration (the potential for CATOBAR my original point.