Explaining the obvious
Calling the ADA a "key" defence group is a bit rich. They may get plenty of play in the media desperate for defence commentators but have had no discernable impact in Canberra on defence issues. Since they are pushing for a nuclear submarine I can't see their track record changing for the better.
The irony of the Australia Defence Association (ADA) being criticised by Abraham Gubler is surely not lost on anyone who keeps up to date with informed public debate on Australian defence issues.
We agree with Abraham though about the general poor quality of media coverage of defence issues in Australia - including by professed defence industry journalists such as himself.
Abraham has based his attempted criticism of the ADA on insufficient research.
First, the ADA's longstanding contributions to informed public debate stem from our role (since 1975) as the national, independent, community-based, non-partisan public-interest watchdog for defence and wider national security matters.
Second, our media work comprises only a small amount of our activities to ensure Australia is adequately and efficiently defended. That Abraham has admitted to being unaware of this says much more about him than it does about us.
As for his opinion as to our "discernible impact" (to spell it correctly), the fact that the ADA membership comprises a broad cross-section of the defence and wider Australian communities nationally speaks for itself. Including, for example, recent MInisters for Defence from both sides of politics who so respected our contributions that they joined after retiring as the minister. Those who know about informed debate in Australia respect the ADA for our effectiveness and for our candour, discretion and public-interest integrity.
Third, our letter-to-the-editor on the future submarine project sent to the "Australian" on 28 Dec 11 can be readily found on our website on the recent letters-to-the-edtor page (the forum software will not permit inclusion of the direct link). The newspaper edited the letter - which may partly explain Abraham's confusion although he appears not to have read the published version anyway.
Within the word-limits applying, this letter summarised recent public debate on the future submarine project. As part of a general discussion, it also suggested that any examination of options should at least look at the possibility of leasing some nuclear-powered boats from the US. This is obviously far removed from "pushing for a nuclear submarine" - just as we have not advocated any other particular option.
As the relevant national public-interest watchdog the ADA naturally continues to view the various claims for home-grown, European and other submarine designs with some scepticism. All claims need to be tested, especially for as yet unbuilt and unproven designs.
Our scepticism also includes due care when reading the unsupported claims by defence industry journalists with or without "skin in the game".
Neil James
Executive Director
Australia Defence Association
(web then ada.asn.au)