You know I don't disagree so much with the views in this room, I think you made the right call to build your own boats with very good support from Sweden and now the replacements will be mainly Austrailan designed. I merely say build a national capability supported by a healthy export market will reduce the cost of future construction and enable the RAN to operate a larger and more effective fleet.
.
why in all that is holy would we go with the swedes again?
10,000 welding errors in number 1, to the point where it almost was written off because it would not have survived an ASW attack in wartime. That bow section was completely done in Sweden. The Commonwealth had to force contract conditions to get it fixed.
they failed to manage Singer and blew out the times to build the combat system (eventually fixed by using a variant of the combat system used in the Seawolf and Virginias compliments of help from the USN)
they used the wrong material for the propellors (fixed after the USN provided blade technology from their SSN's). Kockums had the cheek to expect that they owned the blade IP by association and tried to stop the commonwealth from fixing it themselves
they didn't water tank the design. - fixed thanks to the US providing tank testing via Woods Hole, NAVSEA and Office of Naval Research
they didn't flow test the sail or aft for cavitation - fixed thanks to the US providing tank testing via Woods Hole, NAVSEA and Office of Naval Research
they didn't know how to get the anechoic tiles to fit properly - fixed by DSTO
employed a commercial diesel engine which has not been properly supported by the company and has had a lousy track record. in fact the two times where the boats were at risk of catastrophic events were because they non australian diesel engine provider stuffed up the connections and didn't pick it up when they did their safetys.. I have no problem using commercial engines, after all the spanish have done it with excellent maritime diesels through the likes of Guascor, or the Germans have done it with MTU.
on top of which the hull was acoustically managed and remapped using australian technology.
in fact every major fix in design was either done by ex australian sub mariners, DSTO (the aust equiv of DERA/Qinetic) or by the USG through the auspices of USN, NG, ONR , NOAA and NAVSEA
On top of which the final insult was that Gotland was the mini-me of Collins and my own belief (having worked on the project at a number of levels) was that we paid for some of Gotlands enhancements.
There is swedish kit I would most definitely buy - I would not buy another submarine through them ever unless the contract was so watertight we were adequately protected.
all of the above can be found in either Hansard recordings or in a recent history where the author was given access to unclassified material.