The Russian-Ukrainian War Thread

The place of Putin is clear.
During the whole meeting he was only a little sidekick. Trump and XI rule and devide the world.
Have you been inside? I am just wondering because so much confidence and I would be interested in knowing the base for that degree of confidence. To take a shot in the dark, you probably read stuff about pictures and the like? Like this:


IMG_7604.jpeg

Or

IMG_7598.jpeg
IMG_7599.jpeg

Or like the AI slop I mentioned previously, which spread like wildfire and a whole bunch of serious people mentioned it, retweeted it, etc? Or the statements by Sikorsky and others about Russia not being worthy or whatever (while it should be the EU there - note how it wasn’t)? Propaganda analysis in the media? And so on.

Another pic:

IMG_7606.jpeg

There are a few more I saw… all with this very arrangement. Take note of the flag arrangement as well.

This entire discussion is silly. The US is the superpower. China and Russia have a strategic alliance to compete with the superpower. Russia currently being a “junior” partner in the alliance (not to be confused with mutual influence potential). For the two, each one comes first and the US second. The US prefers Russia because of the current arrangement. Trump would melt in front of both about equally because both are “the most powerful man in the world”. Putin is his “better friend” for the same reason China was the better friend in the 60’s on in the last century (not remotely similar degree of difference between the two though). USSR was the actual competitor and a superpower. Today it is China (though not a superpower, hence the difference). China used to be secondary, which made it the primary American “partner”. Today, Russia is secondary, which makes it the primary “partner” for the US.

I know people see what they want to see, the views shaped by the nonstop disinformation/influence campaign, but the reality is that Russia has a lot of agency and geopolitical influence. We have been observing the proof for the entire duration of the war.

Trump and Xi divide and rule the world is not accurate at all. An easy counterpoint is European politics, where Russia has a lot more influence than either the US and China - they are basically shaped by Russia today (not to be confused with what Russia wants). This is trivial stuff. The “Yalta 2.0” narrative someone came up with and then assigned it a designation of “Putin’s propaganda” is also rubbish. The meeting was never about dividing anything. The world is not binary (or unipolar). Others have agency, but not as much influence. See the Euros again as a primary example, which is only true when they are united, by the way - there is a lot less of both agency and influence when they are not.
 
{somewhat O/T} Only Russia's nuclear arsenal gives Putin a chair at the table...even if it a smaller table. without Trump and Xi. China's much smaller nuclear arsenal (especially wrt Russia) is why any future nuclear arms control is going to be very difficult. Xi certainly knows the mutts running Russia are potentially a much greater threat than the US. so he wants a big increase in nuclear inventory.
Disagree. Like I said in the other post, Russia has agency and influence. Partially due to the nuclear arsenal. But also due to the seat at the security council, its resources, it’s “anti-American” alliance, etc. I would also say that the table is the same and so is the chair.

Agree that it will be difficult to find common ground in nuclear arms control talks. This has been a problem for China, and by extension for the US and Russia, for a long time. It is in everyone’s interest to find that common ground though. I don’t think it is impossible.
 
Have you been inside? I am just wondering because so much confidence and I would be interested in knowing the base for that degree of confidence
Did you see the pictures, the news? Trump were greeted by Xi himself. Even a arm hug (not common in Chinese behavior). Putin were gretted by a state secretary. This Chinese official was more than a head taller than Putin, so Putin had to look upwardsm the Chinese downward.

For the "familiy picture" Trump stood right to Xi, when Putin tried to get on the left he was lead to the left side of Xi´s wife.
During the Dinner Trump sat on the center table next to Xi, Putin at a secondary table.

You know diplomatic symbolism? You think, that Putin was on the same level than Trump and Xi? Really?
 
Did you see the pictures, the news? Trump were greeted by Xi himself. Even a arm hug (not common in Chinese behavior). Putin were gretted by a state secretary. This Chinese official was more than a head taller than Putin, so Putin had to look upwardsm the Chinese downward.

For the "familiy picture" Trump stood right to Xi, when Putin tried to get on the left he was lead to the left side of Xi´s wife.
During the Dinner Trump sat on the center table next to Xi, Putin at a secondary table.

You know diplomatic symbolism? You think, that Putin was on the same level than Trump and Xi? Really?
He did not sit at a separate table, lol.

I know diplomatic symbolism and specifically provided opinions of those who know it undeniably better than me and you put together, not just randos on the web.

There is doubt they were all on the same level, lol. By design.

You basically have not read my post. It is impossible to have a productive debate this way.

Your reply also proves what I wrote in regard to only seeing what you want to see. Not the first time though.
 
.. . Russia Day (what they call Independence Day in the West),
The USA is not "the West". Neither is, for example, Myanmar. The UK, Germany, France, Spain, Denmark, Sweden, Italy, the Netherlands etc. don't have an independence day. They were independent long before there were such things. Portugal has a "Restoration of Independence Day", but it wasn't instituted until 183 years after the split from its relatively short-lived (60 years, out of almost 900 since the kingdom of Portugal was declared) union with Spain.
 
The USA is not "the West". Neither is, for example, Myanmar. The UK, Germany, France, Spain, Denmark, Sweden, Italy, the Netherlands etc. don't have an independence day. They were independent long before there were such things. Portugal has a "Restoration of Independence Day", but it wasn't instituted until 183 years after the split from its relatively short-lived (60 years, out of almost 900 since the kingdom of Portugal was declared) union with Spain.
Tricky, specially regarding language.
I would say that in France (what is celebrated in Quebec?), the "Fête nationale", even if has nothing to do with independence, is the equivalent of the Independence Day. In Spain, they call "The Peninsular War" The War of Independence and they have (had) their "Dos de Mayo". They also have the "Fiesta Nacional de España"; again, nothing to do with independence.
"What they call" meaning "the equivalent of", would be my guess.
 
The USA is not "the West". Neither is, for example, Myanmar. The UK, Germany, France, Spain, Denmark, Sweden, Italy, the Netherlands etc. don't have an independence day. They were independent long before there were such things. Portugal has a "Restoration of Independence Day", but it wasn't instituted until 183 years after the split from its relatively short-lived (60 years, out of almost 900 since the kingdom of Portugal was declared) union with Spain.
Yeah, Canada also has Canada Day. What I meant, however, and probably was not clear, was that media in the West refers to Russia Day as Russian Independence Day more often than not. No idea why.

@rsemmes, Canada Day is a federal holiday, though many Quebecois are not overly enthusiastic about it.

Edit: It’s not only media, by the way. Some of those with inferiority complex make up some absurd shit about it too:

IMG_6938.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Ukraine is at war with Russia. Russia invaded, four years & three months ago. The Ukrainians have been saying, ever since, that a state of war exists between Ukraine & Russia. That is enough to satisfy the legal niceties. No need to deliver a formal declaration of war to someone whose armies have invaded you, & who is bombing your cities.

That's what international law says nowadays. Active military conflict is enough for a state of war to exist, formally & legally. Therefore, Ukraine has all the rights of a belligerent in a formally declared war. Russia's refusal to call it a war has no legal significance.

BTW, where is your question about under what international law is Russia bombing Ukraine, occupying Ukrainian territory, etc.? Why do you question Ukraine's completely legal actions, but give a pass to Russia's blatant crimes?
 
Last edited:
Ukraine is at war with Russia. Russia invaded, four years & three months ago. The Ukrainians have been saying, ever since, that a state of war exists between Ukraine & Russia. That is enough to satisfy the legal niceties. No need to deliver a formal declaration of war to someone whose armies have invaded you, & who is bombing your cities.

That's what international law says nowadays. Active military conflict is enough for a state of war to exist, formally & legally. Therefore, Ukraine has all the rights of a belligerent in a formally declared war. Russia's refusal to call it a war has no legal significance.

BTW, where is your question about under what international law is Russia bombing Ukraine, occupying Ukrainian territory, etc.? Why do you question Ukraine's completely legal actions, but give a pass to Russia's blatant crimes?
Stop quoting the law, we carry weapons.

You are making my first point, no legal niceties.
Russia started military operations, both countries are at war, both countries will carry out whatever action they deem necessary and every country is responsible for its own actions. No finger pointing, no high horses, just war. Still, anyone has declared unrestricted submarine warfare?

My second point is about those war reparations.
I posted before that the US got economic reparations from the British Empire for helping in the continuation of the ACW. The UK has announced that it will provide 1000 long range drone, Russia could very well demand war reparations from Ukraine, UK and NATO. That will be dealt in the treaty, in Abu Dhabi or in the next one.
We are interested in financing this war, maybe not that much in financing reconstruction, but we want our money back; also, we don't want a failed Ukraine. I mentioned before Zelenski thinking about the consequences of his decisions, Kursk. Does he thinks that he will join the EU in 20 years, in 50 or never? Reconstruction, how long is that going to take? Reconstruction with corruption, how long to take that to an EU-acceptable level? And then the PAC, they are going to love an agricultural Ukraine... Or is it going to be its missiles, satellites and data centres, its coal industry, maybe?

That leads me to my third point, with some imagination, I do agree.
Will NATO keep fighting "for Ukraine" (against Russia, actually) without Ukraine? If Ukraine finds itself forced to a peace agreement, will the EU force Ukraine to not accept it unless we get our money back? Is that kind of pressure impossible? Kallas keeps talking about our interests. Russia could counterattack with the reparation of the Kerch bridge, interests from its assets, oil not exported and Russian civilians killed.
Anyway, no legal niceties, no high horses, just real politik.

Someone could object to your "bombing your cities" and "completely legal actions".
 
Back
Top