We're suffering from the decision to build Ocean to a low standard to save money, & Albion & Bulwark with no hangars.
Operating the QEs with no more than half a dozen F-35C would make a mockery of having them. They'd be a worldwide standing joke.
The decisions that took us to a point where we had 3 Invincibles, 1 Ocean, 2 Albions, 4 Bays and a bunch of Point RoRos were fine. That's a well balanced force.
The problem is the way the transition to 2 QEs is being managed. Which is the gap between Harrier and F35C.
Regarding a QE with 6 F-35C's being a joke, it all depends on what the task is.
The QEs will be used as floating airfields not as strike carriers.
If the task at hand means 6 F35Cs plus a broad force of helicopters including Chinooks, EH101, some kind of ASAC, Apache and Wildcats, then so be it.
On the other hand if the task requires 24 F35Cs plus EH101 and ASAC then if that's possible from time to time then fine. That would be an air group with more capability than most air forces.
The QEs are not going to have a standing air group like the US carriers.
UK carriers have been deployed with flexible air groups for a long time now.
I agree that QE will initially be helicopter only, and PoW will be the first to operationally deploy cats and traps. Simply put, QE will be available long before the F35Cs, so QE may not even be be built with cats and traps. QE may get them later, once PoW is deployed.
In fact when you think about it, the UK has deployed aircraft carriers with air force numbers to boost core fleet air arm numbers since 1982 reasonably effectively, unlike any other country, and very efficiently. It actually seems to work in its own way...