Airbus yes but RJ100 would have caused more heart ache than the MR4, it was not that good an aircraft to start with and would have cost squillions to bring it to the capability of the MR2 let alone the MR4 or P-8.
The thing with the MR4 is it had the potential, had they gone for a new fuselage as well, to have beaten the P-8 into service by over a decade while providing greater capability than the P-3 or Atlantic. Infact a new fuselage could have permitted the easy integration of systems that were never considered for the refurbished option, or for that matter the P-8 or notional A319/320/321 due to structual arrangement limitiations of using an existing airliner based design.
Yes MOTS or an adapted COTS platform can be cheaper and less risky but the UK decided to go for the MR4; I just think it is a shame they didn't take it just one step further and replace the fuselage too, once they realised the issues with the existing airframes, whic I believe was very early on in the project.