Tireless has endurance - it's an SSN, it can roam at will submerged and it has a pretty hefty TSA that I believe the Collins doesn't have.
WE were watching the news last night and saw that the RN were sending a sub to help search for the missing flight MH370. My girlfriend's 14 year old, asked why one of our subs wasn't being sent and I said that they might have more specialized equipment onboard (a guess)?
So I thought I'd throw the question here.
Are all our subs deployed/ in maintenance and cannot assist?
Does the RN sub have sonar that we don't?
Don't use MH370 for any justification of proposing SSNs for the RAN. It is highly disrespectful to the families of the victims and in very poor taste. This post of yours is idiotic and offensive.It is a horrible situation for the families of pax and crew of MH370.
The resources needed for this search have been extensive, and the requirement of course came without warning. Makes it hard to imagine being able to respond adequately with 8 MR airframes, so the possible increase in P-8 order to 12 would seem to be emphasised by this tragic event. The BAMS equipment would be of limited use in supplementing the manned MR in this situation.
Similarly, a unique capability and value of us having a nuclear submarine capability is again emphasised, and is again seen, by me at least, as relevant to our Australian future. Hope that polies and defence bureaucrats can push it.
Without wishing to be too negative, our reported fleet management practices for Collins don't exactly seem to focus on short notice tasking...
It appears as an outsider that all activities involving Collins require very extensive planning and preparation before they can be executed.
Good and capable boats no doubt, but they appear to be a little on the 'fragile' side and not best suited to rapid redeployment on differing operations...
Could it be the fleet is too small and their is nothing left for contingencies? I know numbers aren't everything but when you look at what we used to have (that was considered insufficient at the time) and compare it to now there isn't much, if any, fat left.
Out of interest, what are the numbers? To my understanding, the fleet hasn't shrunk much at all
Nominally, there are 12 x escorts, 4 x OHP's and 8 x Anzacs but;
ANZAC, ARUNTA and TOOWOOMBA are out of commission in varying stages of the ASMD refit (Arunta nearly there) and PERTH is in refit.
DARWIN is on OP Resolute, MELBOURNE is just home and presumably on leave, NEWCASTLE is in refit, and I don't know about SYDNEY
That leaves STUART and BALLARAT who have just been in Darwin supporting OP Resolute and PARRAMATTA I don't know about her.
So from the above you can see that "thin on ground is an understatement given that ships need to be working up for deployment and committing to international exercises. Clearly not enough especially as escorts are soon to be needed for our ARE (Amphib Ready Group).
In my view, the FFG's (at least the Melbourne and Newcastle) should remain in commission until the first 4 future frigates commission.
Nominally, there are 12 x escorts, 4 x OHP's and 8 x Anzacs but;
ANZAC, ARUNTA and TOOWOOMBA are out of commission in varying stages of the ASMD refit (Arunta nearly there) and PERTH is in refit.
DARWIN is on OP Resolute, MELBOURNE is just home and presumably on leave, NEWCASTLE is in refit, and I don't know about SYDNEY
That leaves STUART and BALLARAT who have just been in Darwin supporting OP Resolute and PARRAMATTA I don't know about her.
So from the above you can see that "thin on ground is an understatement given that ships need to be working up for deployment and committing to international exercises. Clearly not enough especially as escorts are soon to be needed for our ARE (Amphib Ready Group).
In my view, the FFG's (at least the Melbourne and Newcastle) should remain in commission until the first 4 future frigates commission.
When is Canberra due to set sail again from Sydney Harbour?
I have an itchy camera finger
Out of interest, what are the numbers? To my understanding, the fleet hasn't shrunk much at all
Toowoomba is hardly out of commission, since it is currently out searching for flight MH370.
Anyway, as detailed as your answer is, it doesn't really answer my question. How is what we have now (numbers wise) significantly different from what he had in the past? Which was Volkodav's point.
I probably should not have referred to numbers as it is a lot more complex than that.
Part of the issue is over the last decade or more we have chosen to life extend, upgrade and modernise existing assets rather than replacing them. This has had the effect of removing a significant proportion of the normally available hulls from service for extended periods. It has also left the RAN with a lot of older platforms requiring more maintenance to keep them in service than newer platforms would require.
End result, as Assail described much better than I, the nominal fleet size verses what is available for deployment is quite different. Add in cheap an nasty options like the Armidale Class PBs failing to perform requiring other assets to take up the slack you can see the RAN is quite stretched.
In the mid 90s we had 3 DDGs, 6 FFGs and usually 3 or more DEs with the ANZACs coming on line, there was also a fleet of about a dozen corvettes planned to replace the Fremantle class PBs. So basically about a dozen primary surface combatants with a recognised need for more or at least something more robust on the lower end to support the higher end in lower threat environments. The story has been very similar for decades, we have about a dozen destroyers and frigates at any given point and there is a recognised need for several more, i.e. up to twenty total or at least something more capable than patrol boats at the lower end.
I suppose one way to look at it is to equate a major fleet unit to an Infantry Battalion or an Armoured or Cavalry Regiment, below certain numbers and beyond a certain operational tempo raise, train and sustain goes from difficult to impossible and then when the government starts disbanding battalions or regiments (thank god they haven't!) as a cost saving force planning just goes out the window. Army has to live with hollow units as a result of cost savings that RAN just loses their units all together.
So in other words, numbers haven't dropped at all, although serviceability may have taken a bit of a hit.
I dare say if you went back 20 years no one would be complaining about taking ships out of service for a few years to upgrade them with state of the art radar systems or upgraded weapons. It was hardly all rosy back then.
If you look around at how other Western nations have shrunk since the end of the cold war, the RAN has done pretty well. It is hardly all doom and gloom.