The best ship in the world is useless if it can't interoperable with your fleet or you can't maintain it (Collins and Armidale are good examples here).
I'm not sure why you single out Collins and ACPB's? Your statement is correct for all ships if they are not maintained, period. Both Collins and Armidales are perfectly capable of operating with our fleet and with others which they have done well since their commissioning.
What the RAN has not done well is to keep its engineering standard to that of the past. All the fashionable glib speak bs that "reformers" have tried in sustainment have failed gloriously. The failure has effected all our fleet to varying degrees.
This has little to do with selection of capability.