The fleet review will be in 2013 to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the entry of HMAS Australia into Sydney for the first time.
With Hmas Canberra coming into Sydney Harbour for the first time (in oct)? Are they ahead of schedule with the build, the timing will be close!? That would be one hell of a fleet review centre piece. (and just further makes me want them called the Australia class).
Don't count on it - have you ever known a multi-billion dollar defence project to stick to the schedule?
With Hmas Canberra coming into Sydney Harbour for the first time (in oct)? Are they ahead of schedule with the build, the timing will be close!? That would be one hell of a fleet review centre piece. (and just further makes me want them called the Australia class).
I don't see GI going anywhere. Developing naval bases esp. old ones is a bad idea. HMAS platypus is still being redeveloped, last I heard they were just going to pour concrete all over the site.. I miss seeing the subs moving in Sydney harbour. I though the LHD's will actually be tied up at GI most of the time when they are in port?
Neither the RAN or RAAF have any Mk 54 LWT on inventory. Your blogger would appear to have confused the DSCA potential FMS announcement with an order:
http://www.dsca.mil/PressReleases/36-b/2010/Australia_10-55.pdf
This was an FMS offer solicited as part of consideration of the MH-60R acquired under FMS for the Navy's new combat helicopter. The MH-60R FMS package including the Mk 54 has been chosen by Government but still there has been no contracts signed. So it will be some time before these torpedoes are actually ordered and delivered.
The ADF does have Mk 46 Mod 5 (SW) LWTs in service. The Mk 54 is generally considered an update of the Mk 46 as it combines the vehicle system of this torpedo with the mission system of the Mk 50.
Is the MU-90 currently in service with RAN? I know some have been lobbed overboard from some of the Anzacs for trials, but if it came to actually needing to use them, is the RAN in a position to do so now?
Are they regarded as an effective torpedo? My understanding of the issues the RAN has with them stems more from being able to launch them, than from the actual performance once they are in the water.
One site mentions potential deficiencies with the MK-54
MK-54 Lightweight Hybrid Torpedo
Is this really an issue?
No the FAS webpage mentions deficiencies with the Mk 46 torpedo the Mk 54 is replacing. The Mk 54 combines a comparable (if not better) mission system to the MU90 with advanced digital processors, programmable counter decoy capability, direct energy warheads, etc with the cheap to buy/maintain and high reliability vehicle system of the Otto fuel engine.
The key difference is the Mk 50 and MU90 were conceived during the Cold War where the threat of high speed Soviet submarines (Alfa class) was still a reality. So they have >50 knot speeds so they can chase down one of these very fast boats. The Mk 54 makes do with the ~40 knot speed of the Mk 46 LWT because this is more than adequate for taking out much slower diesel eclectic submarines in the littorals and ~30 knot nuke boats.
Interestingly the default combination of the very fast frigate LWT (MU90) and slower air dropped (MH-60R, P-8A) LWT (Mk 54) that is emerging for the ADF will provide tailored speed solutions. The air dropped torpedo is likely to be launched much closer to the target than the frigate weapon so in less need of a speed advantage to chase down the sub but the higher speed frigate LWT enables the ship to engage the submarine at a distance to keep it away and under threat to avoid being shot in return.
Hi all, there's a blog spot run by a certain F-35 detractor (amongst other things).
This person asserts that in October 2010 Australia purchased '200 more' MK-54 LWTs.
That suggests that Australia already had MK-54's - which would be news to me.
Just in case I'm wrong (has been known to happen) can someone confirm or deny this story?
This would h-ELP put my mind at ease!
cheers
rb
Abe, please correct me if I have this wrong. The impression I had, was that the MU90 and Mk 50 LWT programmes were essentially 'the same' in that they were US and Euro solutions to a North Atlantic Soviet sub hunt.
Given the end of the Cold War, as well as the decline of the Soviet fast sub fleet, the US no longer wanted to keep purchasing the as already mentioned fast and therefore expensive, Mk 50 LWT. Hence the development of the Mk 54, which as I understood it, was basically a Mk 46 LWT casing and powerplant, but fitted with a Mk 50 warhead, sonar and processors.
Also I understand it, part of the RAN interesting in the Mk 54, apart from it already being integrated onto the MH-60R 'Romeo' is that it is significantly cheaper than an MU90 for comparable performance in all areas except for speed. This is why the Hobart-class AWD appears likely to be fitted with the Mk 54 instead of the MU90.
In addition, I have heard a rumour that the USN was looking at updating the ASROC to deliver a Mk 54 torpedoe in place of the current Mk 46, and with that possibility, the RAN was looking at having some VLS cells aboard the AWD and/or the follow-on to the ANZAC-class FFH fitted with ASROC. With something like that in service to assist naval helicopters conducting ASW, the difference in speed between the MU90 and the Mk 54 would (IMO at least) become less important.
"The Mk 54 is much cheaper than the MU90 because of the USD - AUD exchange, US FMS purchasing and the Otto fuel engine".
Could Australia's and for that matter New Zealands' mark 46 lwts stocks be upgraded/re-enginered to mark 54 lwts,with consideralbe cost savings, for both Countries?
An ex-photographer and now APA acolyte got something wrong about defence?
No!!! How could he? He clearly knows all. All that time spent taking staged happy snaps of military bases means he knows exactly how obsolete F-35 is to "the threat" and how corrupt and incompetent everyone except him and his clown club buddies are...
He got upset a few years ago when I called him a wanker because of his stated opinions and attitude back then. My goodness his feelings would be hurt if we communicated today...
![]()
BystanderAgain Why the continuing personal insults.
I thought relevant informed discussion was the aim?
Also I understand it, part of the RAN interesting in the Mk 54, apart from it already being integrated onto the MH-60R 'Romeo' is that it is significantly cheaper than an MU90 for comparable performance in all areas except for speed. This is why the Hobart-class AWD appears likely to be fitted with the Mk 54 instead of the MU90.
As far as I am aware the MU90 is still being fitted to the AWDs. The systems have already been ordered and there would be cost and schedule implications to change now.
Out of curiousity, does anyone know what the Spanish navy uses aboard their F-100's as a LWT?
Really? I was aware that the MU90 had been tested and certified for use aboard the Anzac-class FFH and that they had been ordered as replacements for the Mk 46 LWT currently in use. I had not been aware that they had already been chosen as the LWT for use aboard the Hobart-class AWD. I had thought a decision on that was still pending.
Out of curiousity, does anyone know what the Spanish navy uses aboard their F-100's as a LWT?
-Cheers