I'm confused, how can it be "ADF's civil service at war approach" when the suits have no involvement with determining force composition or command structure??
We are talking cross purposes. I was trying to rationalise why the RAN wouldn’t have an escort task group command as part of the amphibious task force as you appear to be suggesting. Therefore alluding to the ‘civil servicisation’ of the uniforms’ approach to command management seen throughout the ADF. Where traditional and contemporary military structures are replaced by bloated and centralised ‘risk free’ structures.
I'm not sure how anyone can argue that the RAN is signed up to USN task force structures when its pretty apparent what roles they're defining for the LHnn's.
It’s not about the LHD. The RAN follows the US guide in basic naval warfighting since 1951. As does the rest of the NATO aligned world. Part of this is the TF/TG construct where a task force is given an area of responsibility (ie mission) and certain forces and then divides them up into role/mission specific task groups.
if they're (LHA) in the force mix, they will be the command asset - not the smaller skimmers.
MEAO TF structures were the anomaly with small skimmers leading in the sense that they led when no big assets were avail.
And a task group as part of a TF isn’t really a command element. For example in a carrier strike group the “commodore” (senior Captain, the USN doesn’t’ have this rank) is in charge of the ‘destroyer squadron’ and sits onboard the lead AEGIS ship. He reports to the Rear Admiral in charge of the CSG onboard the carrier but has responsibility for air defence (ASuW is taken care of by the air wing and ASW by the escorting submarine). When the CSG is formed into a TF the destroyer squadron becomes one or more TGs.