AUKUS

I think 2.3 was the required target for AUKUS. 2 for US and the 0.3 for Australia.
Open question:

Can the ADF expand RAN submarine force personal out to 3000 or a 2:1 ratio of 24 active submariners across both west and eastern seaboards?
 
There is the SLEP program for the later vairants of the 688i's . USS Cheyenne underwent this process. It may yet allow the transfer of these subs without meeting the production target specifically. 5 or 6 further boats were identified for the SLEP program. Which is pretty much our allocation of Virginia's (up to 5). It gives them an additional 10 to 15 yesrs of life.
 
Last edited:
Will the Peter Garrett lead public equirey into AUKUS have any impact? I think it wont have any at all except create some click bait, lots of ill informed opinions, and a heap of experts coming out of retirement, a bit like the F111 advocates.
 
Will the Peter Garrett lead public equirey into AUKUS have any impact? I think it wont have any at all except create some click bait, lots of ill informed opinions, and a heap of experts coming out of retirement, a bit like the F111 advocates.
It’s an interesting question and I for one confess to have some reservations and concerns about AUKUS on many levels.

In reality I feel the public Enquiry will most likely probably not gain a great deal of momentum short term.
Most folk are dealing with their own economic world with defence issues being somewhat a low priority for most.
It would be an interesting survey to see what people understand of what AUKUS is all about.
The result may enlighten the politicians.

Suggest most would not have a clue and as such the Public Enquiry will go quiet.

I’d suggest longer term when US basing of personal ramps up and we get to that stage of dealing with our own nuclear waste things will get interesting!!

Of note the enquiry made quite a thing about the difference between high and low level uranium.
Admiral Peter Briggs presentation to the enquiry is well worth a look.

All for LEU , submarines and a look at the French.

Interesting times

Cheers S
 
It’s an interesting question and I for one confess to have some reservations and concerns about AUKUS on many levels.

In reality I feel the public Enquiry will most likely probably not gain a great deal of momentum short term.
Most folk are dealing with their own economic world with defence issues being somewhat a low priority for most.
It would be an interesting survey to see what people understand of what AUKUS is all about.
The result may enlighten the politicians.

Suggest most would not have a clue and as such the Public Enquiry will go quiet.

I’d suggest longer term when US basing of personal ramps up and we get to that stage of dealing with our own nuclear waste things will get interesting!!

Of note the enquiry made quite a thing about the difference between high and low level uranium.
Admiral Peter Briggs presentation to the enquiry is well worth a look.

All for LEU , submarines and a look at the French.

Interesting times

Cheers S
I believe the French LEU requirement is upwards of 20% U-235 and refuelling is required every 10 years or less depending on use so the waste issue remains and a decision would be required on whether to refuel in France or Australia. An advanced CANDU reactor for power generation on land can use mixed oxide waste from light water reactors as a fuel so it could be a partial solution for nuclear waste.
 
Should have added that a waste burning advanced CANDU reactor would be an expensive option considering Australia's wind , solar and NG alternatives.
 
Will the Peter Garrett lead public equirey into AUKUS have any impact? I think it wont have any at all except create some click bait, lots of ill informed opinions, and a heap of experts coming out of retirement, a bit like the F111 advocates.
I think you've knocked the nail on the head there. I can't see how it will change anything.

Australia's submarine forces are like the UK with the surface fleet - a lot of can-kicking has destroyed the can and left both countries in a situation that cannot now be remedied except to stay the course. Australia has a submarine gap and the UK has an escort gap, albeit they're at different stages.

Cancelling AUKUS means another decade of delay and the Collins boats possibly ending up like the Type 23s that have had to be decommissioned because they're falling apart.
 
I think you've knocked the nail on the head there. I can't see how it will change anything.

Australia's submarine forces are like the UK with the surface fleet - a lot of can-kicking has destroyed the can and left both countries in a situation that cannot now be remedied except to stay the course. Australia has a submarine gap and the UK has an escort gap, albeit they're at different stages.

Cancelling AUKUS means another decade of delay and the Collins boats possibly ending up like the Type 23s that have had to be decommissioned because they're falling apart.
One has to wonder which is worse, a submarine or escort gap? Both gaps are not good but submarines at least are less vulernable. Better and less expensive anti-missile/drone solutions can hopefully rectify this.
 
Will the Peter Garrett lead public equirey into AUKUS have any impact? I think it wont have any at all except create some click bait, lots of ill informed opinions, and a heap of experts coming out of retirement, a bit like the F111 advocates.
The enquiry led by Peter Garrett will be a lot of smoke and mirrors, with often self-proclaimed experts pushing their own particular hobby horse (and that includes Peter Garrett). Peter Garrett is just like all of the other former PMs etc, who have secured their golden parachute pension, and now want to get their snouts in the public funded trough as well as try and have some relevance. The time to have the enquiry, led by truly independent and impartial chairs, is long past. The decision to procure nuclear submarines has been made and needs to be followed through for better or worse.
 
I think you've knocked the nail on the head there. I can't see how it will change anything.

Australia's submarine forces are like the UK with the surface fleet - a lot of can-kicking has destroyed the can and left both countries in a situation that cannot now be remedied except to stay the course. Australia has a submarine gap and the UK has an escort gap, albeit they're at different stages.

Cancelling AUKUS means another decade of delay and the Collins boats possibly ending up like the Type 23s that have had to be decommissioned because they're falling apart.
I remember being surprised by the length of time the T23's lives were to be extended, given what I'd read about the designed hull lives - & then three things happened: the T26 ASW replacements were delayed past the planned in service date, the quick GP replacement (T31) was delayed even more, & T23s started falling apart before the end of the planned life extension period.

Total fuck-up, mostly by the Tories from 2010 to 2024, but Labour hasn't done much to put it right in the last two years.
 
I remember being surprised by the length of time the T23's lives were to be extended, given what I'd read about the designed hull lives - & then three things happened: the T26 ASW replacements were delayed past the planned in service date, the quick GP replacement (T31) was delayed even more, & T23s started falling apart before the end of the planned life extension period.

Total fuck-up, mostly by the Tories from 2010 to 2024, but Labour hasn't done much to put it right in the last two years.
With a less than 20 year design life, the replacements should have been ordered in the early 2000s. By 2010 there wasn't even an agreed design. The Tories didn't help by dragging their feet, but as much as I'd rather not defend them it was New Labour kicking the can that caused the real problem.
 
As much as I believe the AUKUS submarine being built in first U.K then Australia is likely to be impressive ,I could be guessing to suggest that there patrol patterns would be different to the Collins class being to almost two and a half times the size ,Perhaps the deep waters below thermoclines maybe the main operating area I cant see it in shallow waters leaving that to Ghost Shark and other small vessels
 
With a less than 20 year design life, the replacements should have been ordered in the early 2000s. By 2010 there wasn't even an agreed design. The Tories didn't help by dragging their feet, but as much as I'd rather not defend them it was New Labour kicking the can that caused the real problem.
I think we can agree that they share the guilt for the current mess.
 
Were the type 45,s an example of this malaise ,by the time everything was finished to bring the destoyer to its full potential they need to replace it
 
Were the type 45,s an example of this malaise ,by the time everything was finished to bring the destoyer to its full potential they need to replace it
If you back aways in the RN thread you can read about the consequences of improper testing of the Type 45’s IEP so it is political and technological malaise.
 
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/wo...e/news-story/9fde971b1a6d1fc751a7d88cc22456d9

Folks, sorry its a paywall, however it relates to Cao's senate questioning on submarine building.

It provides an insight into improvements with resourcing. He stated that to meet the cadence for 1 Columbia and 2 Virginias the yards require 70,000 labour hours a week (40,000 for the Columbia alone), and they are very close to it.

One of the mechanisms has been to move out all work that does not require a security clearence to other yards, enabling the submarine yards to just concentrate on what they specifically need to. Apparently this is proving effective, with upwards of 5,000 hours a week already moved.

The target of actually receiving 2 SSNs per year however has moved from 2028 to 2032.

The article also talks about the recent suicides on the Lincoln, with the startling comment tgat suicides are normal on all deployments
 
Last edited:
Back
Top