I wish it was April 1st, so I didn't have to take that seriously. It makes me feel very sad.
This forum needs a like button. Agreed.
Seems a pointless change, especially since those names have probably been in use for quite a while, whats wrong with tradition?
Totally agree. Tradition is important in a Navy and this smacks of a business practice of creating impressive sounding titles that in reality mean nothing apart from the fact that one may be a writer, or cook, or stores accountant, etc., which are an accurate title of ones trade or branch. I think in this case the tradition should be kept.
I
3. How does the Perth Class compare to the River Class DE in ASW capability?
There are others on this forum that would have access to strategic decision processes and financial information regarding the DDG's but I have a very well informed opinion of how they compare with the Rivers having been the ASW Officer/PWO in both classes.
Let me start by stating that the DE's were fine ASW escorts. They had a magnificent hull design, high cavitation inception speed and were adequately equipped for escort duty.
I don't have a link but I can distincly remember an RAN official photo shoot showing an aerial shot of Perth and Derwent abreast travelling at about 15 kts and the wake disturbance comparison is compelling, not a ripple for Derwent and white water everywhere for Perth.
Their range was paltry, about 2,500 IIRC and their point defence AAW capability was fair compared with the standards of the day (Derwent was trumpeted as being the first missile ship in the RAN).
As far as weapons were concerned(original) both ships had Ikara but the DDG's had double magazine capacity (approx 35 missiles per side IIRC) which was probably overkill.
Close range difference was the triple tubes/Mk 44,46 cf Mortar Mk 10 in the DE's.
Even so, I though the Limbo was a pretty useful weapon at very close range.
The sonar was the big difference. Rivers had Types 177/170 in hull outfits. These were both searchlight sonars with a practical max range of 10k yds.(177). A searchlight pattern/ trainable transducer was cumbersome and could cause contacts to be easily lost in a tight situation unless the command team were experienced. 177 was only a medium powered set thus the limited range.
I never worked with Mulloka.
The DDG's SQS 23 was a fantastic set and for those of us who had worked with 177 it was like a Roller compared to a mini. High power, electronic scanning etc etc, features which are taken for granted today however, there still needed to be a skilled operator with headphones because computor interpretation did not exist as we now know it.
(as an aside, I always was so impressed when visiting the main computor room, a compartment about 5metres square with a monster rack which had less power than this ancient laptop I use)
You mentioned helos, but the context of the time (1968) was that LAMPS was in its infancy and being first sorted in the Knox class DE's although there were some earlier only reasonably successful attempts in the FRAM II's, MATCH was just being introduced to the RN and both the RAN and the USN in the Pacific had a dozen or so CVS's to cover the role.
In summary, I think the DE's were good escorts for the role for which they were planned. On ther other hand, the DDG's were the vehicle which opened our eyes to the potency of US systems and weapons and once tried we realized, or should have, that returning to the old world was not an option despite some fierce resistance from the Brit trained traditionalists.
My time in DDG's certainly shaped my bias and sadly, every time our leaders divert elsewhere we seem to get multiple problems.
Cheers
I was flipping through a book on the RAN's involvement in Vietnam when an old thought re-occured to me, why didn't Australia buy or even build additional CFA/Perth Class DDGs? Of couse I suspect the reasons are along the lines of cost, too hard, would interfere with the DDL project etc.
I was imagining an all DDG fleet going into the 80s with say 5 or 6 Perths and 4 or 5 batch 2 DDGs (either evolved Perths or DDLs) with helos for a total of 10 ships verses the 3 Perths, 2 Darings, 6 Rivers shifting to 3 Perths, 2-4 Adelaides (OHP FFG7s), 4-2 Rivers we did have during that time.
Just looked through some of my sources and there was a second RAN plan to acquire a fourth DDG in late 1966. This was a compromise as part of the Daring class DD upgrade. The RAN had wanted Vendetta and Vampire to be rebuilt with Tartar but was willing to accept cheaper Ikara in place of Tartar only if they could acquire a fourth “comprehensive” escort or DDG. Such a ship could have followed Brisbane from Dafoe around the same time three Adams class were built for West Germany. At this, still pre DDL, time the RAN was planning on building a new common RN/RAN frigate hull in Australia after Swan and Torrens. The common frigate became Type 21 after the RAN pulled out. The RAN Type 21 would have been a nice ship with mostly American weapons (5”, Sea Sparrow (32 missiles), EDO sonar and Huey helicopter) and compared to the T21 a reinforced hull for >36 knot sprint speeds. So the RAN would have ended up in the mid 1970s with four Adams DDGs, two Daring Ikara, six Type 12 with Ikara and four Type 21 with US weapons, strong hull and high speed sprint.
Quite ironic, during the 70's many RAN Submariners pegged an updated Barbel as being the best option to replace the Oberons and thats exactly what the Walrus is, an updated Barbel.
Now this is interesting, Treasury recommended the Walrus Class instead of the Kockums due to it being a real vs paper design with a real vs paper combat system. Why oh why didn't cabinet listen?
This issue was comprehensively covered in the excellent book by Yule and Woolner: “The Collins Class Submarine Story: Steel, Spies and Spin”. Basically the money for the Collins class was being wringed out of Cabinet to modernise Australian industry by Peter Button not for defence needs by Kim Beazley. So while the Dutch offer best meet Defence’s needs it was still built up from the keel with chalk ups on steel. The Swedish offer included modular construction and computer aided design which Button wanted to introduce into Australian industry. Therefore the Swede offer won. On the combat system side it was actually the RAN that wanted a distributed computer network versus a big central computer because of their very positive experience from the Oberon class upgrade. This all fell down in the detail phase via poor contracting.