Certainly the problem was the age of the ships; but these suggestions are off the mark. In 1993/4 when we did the procurement the assessment team contained (and, if memory serves, was led by) one of the most competent marine engineers ever to wear our uniform. However, they were only given limited access to the ships while they were in USN service; it was these ships or nothing. And we had to make a quick decision if we wanted them. A year or so before we had had our proposals for a specially built Training and Helicopter Support Ship killed. We knew they weren't in the greatest of nicks, and, although we didn't understand the full ramifications, we accepted that and the acquisition price reflected that. Get the files out of Queanbeyan and have a look at where we were then.
:duel