Ty, will do
He He, you guys are funny !! have looked back at the threads on the LHD's and the F35B argument, and while it basically comes down to the government of the day, a lot of the argument as to the capability of the LHD seems to come down to personal opinion !! can ANYONE show me the specifications of the JC1 or the Canberra LHD's ??. I have done extensive searches and can't find this information. I can't find anywhere how much JP5, ammunition, workshop space, spare parts storage,etc, etc, etc, etc !! and it goes on, that these ships actually have !! all that you find on the net is basic specs (and that varies from site to site) all of which once again comes down to guessing and (I would assume maybe some educated) comparison to dedicated aircraft carriers, and to some extent the american wasp class.
Don't mean to sound cynical guys but im a factual person, show me some real, verifiable specifications on the JC1/Canbera LHD ! otherwise it is speculation, because if we don't know or understand the true spec's and capability's of the ship, the arguement of whether we will or will not get F35B any time in the future is mute !!
He He, you guys are funny !! have looked back at the threads on the LHD's and the F35B argument, and while it basically comes down to the government of the day, a lot of the argument as to the capability of the LHD seems to come down to personal opinion !! can ANYONE show me the specifications of the JC1 or the Canberra LHD's ??. I have done extensive searches and can't find this information. I can't find anywhere how much JP5, ammunition, workshop space, spare parts storage,etc, etc, etc, etc !! and it goes on, that these ships actually have !! all that you find on the net is basic specs (and that varies from site to site) all of which once again comes down to guessing and (I would assume maybe some educated) comparison to dedicated aircraft carriers, and to some extent the american wasp class.
Don't mean to sound cynical guys but im a factual person, show me some real, verifiable specifications on the JC1/Canbera LHD ! otherwise it is speculation, because if we don't know or understand the true spec's and capability's of the ship, the arguement of whether we will or will not get F35B any time in the future is mute !!
I think you are right, the NFH 90 version would be hard to pass up by the government, but as you said we need them now. Which american chopper do you think would suit the bill ?? they have several to choose from ?
I have also noted while catching up on the thread the discussion on the replacement LCH. I must admit it is something I have not given much thought to ! It is amazing the variations available, does anyone have any thoughts on what style would operate best with the LDH's and potential new sealift ship, would they also have to take into consideration what form the new OCV will take ? as this multi role ship could potentially have numerous capability's
todjaeger said:Incidentally, AFAIK the -R in the MH-60R designation stands for "Re-manufactured" and Sikorsky has been scrambling somewhat the get their hands on used Seahawk airframes to put through the re-manufacture process to fufil USN orders for the MH-60R. This makes me think that even if the NFH-90 does get chosen as the Future Naval Helicopter now or at a latter date, the current Seahawks will be kept in service for some time by someone, even if not the RAN.
-Cheers
I thought the -R was just the next letter in the alphabet after the latest varient of the Blackhawk/Seahawk.
If they are remanufactured airframes, with available airframes probably already claimed by the USN, that just makes the NFH-90 more attractive as a proposition in my opinion.
Good points, the "RE-MANUFACTURED" part of that does make me cringe though ! the word "Sea Sprite" comes to mind, and I think would be something the current government may be very hesitant to do after all the political point scoring they gained with the doomed project. If we did go that way though, if the USN are in dire need of old airframes, I would not think we would be high on the priority list when it comes to upgrading our fleet ? which may leave us with the same problem of lead in time and not having a gap in capability ?
I thought the -R was just the next letter in the alphabet after the latest varient of the Blackhawk/Seahawk.
If they are remanufactured airframes, with available airframes probably already claimed by the USN, that just makes the NFH-90 more attractive as a proposition in my opinion.
Does anyone follow the RAN Flickr feed? There are some great historical shots. Some great ones of AE2 and the Melbourne too.
Flickr: Royal Australian Navy's Photostream
I liked them anyway.
Here is a new computer graphic video of the new Canberra class LHDs. Enjoy the 32 seconds. NH-90s, Tigers, and Chinooks on the flight deck...
Canberra Class - Royal Australian Navy
Good points, the "RE-MANUFACTURED" part of that does make me cringe though ! the word "Sea Sprite" comes to mind, and I think would be something the current government may be very hesitant to do after all the political point scoring they gained with the doomed project. If we did go that way though, if the USN are in dire need of old airframes, I would not think we would be high on the priority list when it comes to upgrading our fleet ? which may leave us with the same problem of lead in time and not having a gap in capability ?
I thought the -R was just the next letter in the alphabet after the latest varient of the Blackhawk/Seahawk.
If they are remanufactured airframes, with available airframes probably already claimed by the USN, that just makes the NFH-90 more attractive as a proposition in my opinion.