As outlined in posts #1609 and #1611, I think a good case could be made for adding a multi-role corvette such as Austal's design to the RAN.
I refute the suggestion that proposing such vessels and their flexible capabilities, is based on the simplistic notion that only local defence is being considered in denial of global realities.
Quite the opposite really, if the the big boys are off fulfilling 'global' responsibilities what are we left with? The Armidales?
The MPCs could fulfill many roles [as per those listed posts] and much more, very economically and effectively. If required they also have the range and the speed to join the 'fleet' adding for example ASW, MCM, SAR, or transport capacity.
They have the capacity to replace more than one class of ship, with a little thought and fill a capability gap [in the present lineup] between the Armidales and the FFHs.
If these functions are considered a "waste of money", a more reasoned argument rather than a blunt statement would be appreciated so as to illuminate their shortcomings.
Clearly I do feel the multi-role capability a "must have" if we are to extend our presence, especially humanitarian, throughout our 'areas of interest', especially the Pacific, near north and north-west while retaining the capability to perform survey, MCM, SAR, ASW patrol or escort duties nearer home if ever required.
In a [desirable] two fleet scenario as StingrayOz proposes, they would be even more valuable, releasing larger units for fleet duties.
Cheers,
Mac
As outlined in posts #1609 and #1611, I think a good case could be made for adding a multi-role corvette such as Austal's design to the RAN.
I refute the suggestion that proposing such vessels and their flexible capabilities, is based on the simplistic notion that only local defence is being considered in denial of global realities.
Quite the opposite really, if the the big boys are off fulfilling 'global' responsibilities what are we left with? The Armidales?
The MPCs could fulfill many roles [as per those listed posts] and much more, very economically and effectively.
If required they also have the range and the speed to join the 'fleet' adding for example ASW, MCM, SAR, or transport capacity.
They have the capacity to replace more than one class of ship, with a little thought and fill a capability gap [in the present lineup] between the Armidales and the FFHs.
If these functions are considered a "waste of money", a more reasoned argument rather than a blunt statement would be appreciated so as to illuminate their shortcomings..
Clearly I do feel the multi-role capability a "must have" if we are to extend our presence, especially humanitarian, throughout our 'areas of interest', especially the Pacific, near north and north-west while retaining the capability to perform survey, MCM, SAR, ASW patrol or escort duties nearer home if ever required.
In a [desirable] two fleet scenario as StingrayOz proposes, they would be even more valuable, releasing larger units for fleet duties.
Cheers,
Mac
Todjaeger and Alexsa,
Very interesting responses, however some are somewhat limited to the 'brochure size' of Austal's MPV, please note that I said in post #1611 "It is the inherent versatility in the design concept which attracts me although I think a slightly larger version, say 500 tons,...."
I am not suggesting a 360 DWT vessel but was suggesting the design concept be used in a size [LWL etc] more suitable to addressing many of the issues you both raised, say even up to 1000 dwt for discussion purposes.
I am aware that increasing speed uses more fuel but I believe that applies to across the board and isn't this hull form supposed to be more economical than traditional monohulls across most sea-states?.
After all the Anzac's 6000nm range is only nominal and assumes a cruising speed of 10k. What max. sea-state can they operate helos etc in? ?.
Compared with the Anzacs at app. 3600 DWT and a crew of app. 170, I thought that a ship of <1000 DWT, with a crew of 40-70 would be a lot more economical to operate, this is the only "evidence" on running costs I can offer at this point.?.
As far as the number of roles the design can accommodate, I confess I have only the MPV and LCS data to offer.
All the remarks re. sea states and cyclones etc are all valid but perhaps are coloured by the belief I was proposing the 360 ton Austal MRV per se.
Isn't it still Navy policy to avoid sailing into cyclones where possible or can the Armidales etc. do it?.
If a tri-hull was ever considered, one would hope for sea-worthiness equal to, or greater than, conditions it could reasonably expect to encounter offshore. I expect Austal still have the skill to design for blue water capability.?.
I have made a few transits to NZ, nearer Pacific and Melanesian destinations in both mono-hulls and multi-hulls in a variety of weather conditions and I know which is the more stable and fastest hullform, they weren't warships though.![]()
Alexsa, point taken on probable costs, I haven't heard of anything being bought for the the Navy that's not expensive but I am attempting to explore the gap between the Anzacs and the Armidales for a future RAN, so cannot offer a cost/value estimate for comparison to an existing platform. I can only suggest a lot less than an FFH and a lot more than an Armidale for a lot more flexibility in a single hull form.
Time out, 2yo needs a hose down, gotta go!:shudder
Cheers,
Mac
Was wondering if anyone knows when they are going to start construction of the RANs LHD's or If they have, knows where they are up to in the construction?
The Link to the project page at the Defense Material Organisation can be found hereForward Milestones
* Sep 2008 - First steel cut
* July 2009 - Whole-of-ship design reviews complete
* 2010 - Tenders called for initial in-service support contract.
* Mid – 2012 - LHD 1 hull arrives Williamstown
* Early 2014 - Defence accepts delivery of LHD 1
* Feb 2014 - LHD 2 hull arrives Williamstown
* Mid 2015 - Defence accepts delivery of LHD 2
I think it was 33 months from first steel cut to launch of Juan Carlos 1, 5 years from order to launch. Dokdo was quicker - 3 1/2 years from order to launch. But that's for a smaller & simpler ship.4 years to build a hull! It's know wonder the Koreans are kicking butt.
I think it was 33 months from first steel cut to launch of Juan Carlos 1, 5 years from order to launch. Dokdo was quicker - 3 1/2 years from order to launch. But that's for a smaller & simpler ship.
I believe the Australians chosen build method imposes a delay. Quicker if they were completed in Spain.
StevoJH said:DMO Website lists the cutting of first steel to have occured last month (Sep 08'). It wasnt on the News or anything though, so i assume that time table is now out of date due to changes or delays.
Navantia said:NAVANTIA CUTS STEEL FOR THE FIRST LHD FOR THE AUSTRALIAN NAVY
9/23/2008
The shipyard cuts the first 2 pieces of steel, with a total weight of 5.37 tones
Navantia's Fene-Ferrol shipyard has officially started the construction of the first of two LHDS for the Australian Navy, cutting the steel for two blocks, 1.87 tones and 3.5 tones weight.
This contract was signed on 9th. October 2007 in Melbourne and includes the design and construction of 2 LHD's, as well as some equipments on board, similar to the LHD "Juan Carlos I" built by Navantia for the Spanish Navy. Navantia will collaborate with Tenix to this construction, in aprox. 80% of the construction.
Ermm no.
Navantia is on schleude atm.
The first two steel plates of the ALHD-1 were cut the past 23 of September at 11:00 by Navantia, in her Ferrol shipyard.
Complete Press Release - Navantia
Do you think the Labour government is not making it a high media story because it would lead back to a Liberal government success story?My only comment was that i don't remember seeing it in the news here in Australia at all, you'd think that there would be at least some sort of mention.
My only comment was that i don't remember seeing it in the news here in Australia at all, you'd think that there would be at least some sort of mention.
I picked up the latest copy of The NAVY it has an interesting story on sea 1000 Collins replacement.
To cut a long story short the article suggests we go with a conventionally powered VIRGINIA class submarine.
http://www.fas.org/man/dod-101/sys/ship/docs/990100-nssn.htm
It offers a low risk path and we could possibly piggy back further improvement in future upgrades with the USN
The RN also has a design that came out in May 2008 the vidar 36 submarine
A lot of the advance technologies are currently available
http://www.naval-technology.com/contractors/warship/bmt-defence/press8.html
A lot of the article is over my head in terms in propulsion output, but I have a general idea on what it is trying to say, the article was written by Abraham Gubler it appears well written and for some people who might have more of an understanding in the complexities in design and engineering than me
I gave Abe some of the info on propulsion solutions a while back as I had some dealings with the tech.
Good article - but a small conventional Virginia won't happen. There are other better options on the table.