Sri Lankas Radar Dilemma

Jade

New Member
The Indians supplied Sri Lanka Indra II radars but the LTTE's planes micro light aircraft penetrated them.

Then Sri Lanka wanted 3D radars from China.

India objected, as they could be spied upon.

So, India supplied something.

Could anybody in the know of these radars explain why India should objct to Chinese 3D radar's ?
 

ejaz007

New Member
I think these are similar type of radars supplied earlier. A copy of news article on Sri Lankan army web site is attached.
2007-08-07 02:26:07
AFTER A GAP OF A YEAR, India has sent more radars to Sri Lanka to help it ward off the threat of airborne attacks by the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), Indian Defence Ministry sources said.

India had resumed non-lethal military aid to Sri Lanka with the supply of two indigenous radars in 2005. This January it sent another military radar to Sri Lanka followed by the despatch of a similar radar in June.

The radars were sent on behalf of the Indian Air Force, the sources said. Both radars were sent from the Hindon military base on the outskirts of Delhi.

India first broke off its self-imposed embargo of nearly five years when it sent two Indra-II radars on the eve of President Mahinda Rajapaksa's first visit in 2005.

The radars, developed by the Defence Research & Development Organisation, can detect low-flying fighter aircraft. They were produced by the public sector Bharat Electronics Limited.

Sri Lanka operates naval fast attack craft supplied earlier by India but sources in the Indian Navy could not confirm whether boats, configured to chase and hunt down small ships generally operated by the LTTE Naval Tiger wing, had also been sent. They felt such a deal was unlikely because India itself was facing a shortage of these vessels.

Diplomatic sources here said India's supply of radars, said to be in the non-lethal category, in no way compromised its desire for a political solution to the LTTE issue.

The first lot of radars were sent after Sri Lanka, told the then External Affairs Minister Natwar Singh about its requirement and the willingness of other countries to supply them.

In March this year, LTTE aircraft had targeted a Sri Lanka Air Force base near Colombo leading to speculation that the radars supplied by India were defective. However, Sri Lanka later said the reports were wrong.
 

ejaz007

New Member
This article says some thing else.

Chinese arms, radar for Sri Lanka military

[TamilNet, Monday, 04 June 2007, 15:59 GMT]
Sri Lanka’s military has inked several significant defence agreements with China, including those for the supply of modern radar and large quantities of ammunition, press reports said. The deals with Beijing come amid public statements from India expressing discontent with Colombo’s military ties to China and Pakistan. An order for Chinese radars is being routed through a company owned by Sri Lanka’s defence secretary, Gotabaya Rajapakse, reports also said. Meanwhile, India could provide training, spares and servicing support for Sri Lanka’s soon to be acquired Mig 29 jets.

Britain's Jane's Defence Weekly reported recently that Sri Lanka had signed a classified $37.6 million deal with China's Poly Technologies in April to supply its defence forces with ammunition and ordnance for the army and navy.

Another company, China National Electronics Import Export Corp is to provide Sri Lanka a JY 11 3D radar for $5 million over the next few weeks once the site for its location near Colombo is ready, IANS reported quoting Jane’s.

Reports of the purchases come as India’s National Security Advisor M.K. Narayanan publicly insisted that Sri Lanka should not approach Pakistan or China for weapons.

''It is high time that Sri Lanka understood that India is the big power in the region and ought to refrain from going to Pakistan or China for weapons, as we are prepared to accommodate them within the framework of our foreign policy,'' Narayanan was quoted by Indian reports as saying last Thursday after a 45-minute meeting with Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M. Karunanidhi.

Gotabaya Rajapakse, Sri Lanka’s hardline defence secretary concluded the new contract for the Chinese radars, IANS reported.

The order is being routed through Lanka Logistics and Technologies Co Ltd that Gotabaya Rajapakse also heads, the report also said.

Colombo has declined to renew its long standing agreement with China's North Industries Corporation (Norinco) for defence equipment, opting instead for Poly Technologies, founded as a rival in 1984 by Beijing's military establishment.

IANS says there is speculation that the change from Norinco, which has maintained a bonded warehouse in the southern port city of Galle since 1993, was prompted by the debt of $200 million Sri Lanka owes the company.

The largest single order with Poly Technologies is for 120 mm mortar shells for the army, of which 70,000 rounds are priced at $10.4 million.

Other imports include 68,000 152 mm artillery shells ($20 million) and 50,000 81 mm high-explosive mortar bombs ( $3.7 million).

The Sri Lankan navy's requirement, valued at$ 2.7 million, includes a range of ammunition including 100,000 14.5 mm cartridges, 2,000 RPG-7 rockets and 500 81 mm airburst mortar shells.

There are also 50 Type 82 14.5 mm twin-barrel naval guns, 200 Type 85 12.7 mm heavy machine guns, 200 Type 80 7.62 mm multipurpose machine guns, 1,000 Type 56-2 7.62 mm submachine guns and 1,000 Type 56 7.62 mm submachine guns, Jane's reported.

Meanwhile, Jane’s is quoted as reporting that Sri Lanka’s director of Aeronautical Engineering, Air Vice Marshal Prashantha de Silva, is scheduled to visit Moscow to discuss the acquisition acquiring an unspecified number of MiG 29 fighters to boost Colombo’s power.

IANS quoted Indian defence sources as saying New Delhi, which also operates 60 odd MiG 29s, could play an 'important' role in Sri Lanka's proposed purchase of similar fighters by agreeing to provide training, spares, servicing and other logistic back-up.
 

Schumacher

New Member
The Indians supplied Sri Lanka Indra II radars but the LTTE's planes micro light aircraft penetrated them.

Then Sri Lanka wanted 3D radars from China.

India objected, as they could be spied upon.

So, India supplied something.

Could anybody in the know of these radars explain why India should objct to Chinese 3D radar's ?
India is the big guy in that part of the world and, like other big guys around the world, would prefer the little guys there, ie Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh etc, not get too close with other big guys, like China, from another part of the world.
 

Jade

New Member
  • Thread Starter Thread Starter
  • #5
India is the big guy in that part of the world and, like other big guys around the world, would prefer the little guys there, ie Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh etc, not get too close with other big guys, like China, from another part of the world.
India trying to be the bully still doesn't answer the technical advantage of a 3D radar over over a 2D radar.
 
Top