Defense Technology & Military Forum

Defense Technology & Military Forum (http://www.defencetalk.com/forums/)
-   Navy & Maritime (http://www.defencetalk.com/forums/navy-maritime/)
-   -   Indonesia: 'green water navy' (http://www.defencetalk.com/forums/navy-maritime/indonesia-green-water-navy-3897/)

Supe June 28th, 2005 10:12 AM

Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
After reading this (quite interesting) thread on Indonesian aspirations for a 'green water navy' , it left me wondering about the capabilities of the Indonesian Navy as it stands now and the direction it wants to take. World Navies today website lists quite a few assets, particularly of amphibious ships. It looks like they have a decent amphibious capability but the combatant fleet appears quite dated.

Does anyone expect there to be regional friction due to this announcement? Will it be seen as a natural process of a modernisation programme to make the TNI Navy more relevant or as Indonesia wanting to become more of a player in the region?

gf0012-aust June 28th, 2005 06:00 PM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Supe
After reading this (quite interesting) thread on Indonesian aspirations for a 'green water navy' , it left me wondering about the capabilities of the Indonesian Navy as it stands now and the direction it wants to take. World Navies today website lists quite a few assets, particularly of amphibious ships. It looks like they have a decent amphibious capability but the combatant fleet appears quite dated.

Does anyone expect there to be regional friction due to this announcement? Will it be seen as a natural process of a modernisation programme to make the TNI Navy more relevant or as Indonesia wanting to become more of a player in the region?

The IN has actually asked the RAN for assistance in this. We're being asked to assess what capability they need and to provide training.

Amazing change of heart when you consider that 6 years ago we were a bees dick away from going to war against each other

Aussie Digger June 29th, 2005 04:41 AM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
This will be quite a feat considering Indonesia is finding it almost impossible to find the funds to arm it's 4 Sukhoi's with ANY weapons, acquire sufficient funding or aid to get it's 8 odd Hercules flying and generally modernise any aspect of it's defence forces...

The RAN might advise that all Indonesian warships should be painted Brilliant white with a VERY large round red circle, painted right in the middle of them :D

It might make things a bit easier for them (the RAN that is) one day... :mad:

Supe June 29th, 2005 04:44 AM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gf0012-aust
The IN has actually asked the RAN for assistance in this. We're being asked to assess what capability they need and to provide training.

Yes, I spotted that point in the 'other' forum. It's odd that after all these years since they achieved independence, they still require 'outside' assistance to identify solutions to their policy objectives. I would have thought it would be something they could easily do by themselves.

OT: Are the Subs the indonesians employ, operational?

gf0012-aust June 29th, 2005 04:51 AM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Aussie Digger
This will be quite a feat considering Indonesia is finding it almost impossible to find the funds to arm it's 4 Sukhoi's with ANY weapons, acquire sufficient funding or aid to get it's 8 odd Hercules flying and generally modernise any aspect of it's defence forces...

The main issue is that if they want a green water navy to deal with piracy, then they're going to have to start court martialling some of their officers.

They know it, but they're trying to work out how to resolve it.

gf0012-aust June 29th, 2005 04:53 AM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Supe
OT: Are the Subs the indonesians employ, operational?

barely. no funds available. short on flying time, short on sea time and no money for weapons fits for their airforce.

pasukangeraktjepat June 29th, 2005 05:30 AM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gf0012-aust
barely. no funds available. short on flying time, short on sea time and no money for weapons fits for their airforce.

:(Sadly what you say is quite correct Gf, our defence minister say that Indonesian AF only has 40% of its assets ready to fly.The Sukhois only use in training right now.And now we try to take back our F-5 in south korea, the tiger was sent there to maintanance, but after it maintained US Govt told the Korean to not give it back for our AF, perhaps because the military ban.
The army still work hard to get the Mi-16 helos, there was a financing problem to get that helo, so they start to talk agremeent with the Russian again.
Latest news about the navy, two of the Sigma-class corvette will be built in Surabaya,Indonesia ; and the other will be ready to operate circa 2006-2007.About the aging subs, some news said one of the two is still operate, but i can't confirm that news.We stil wait the subs from Daewoo for its replacement.Also we will get another new LPD, beside KRI Tanjung Dalpele.
The keyword of Indonesian army problem, beside the human-right problem, is the lack of money.So many problem in Indonesia nowaday and we must use the money to deal with that.
And last, maybe it is quite out of context, back when Indonesia still struggle for its independence from dutch in 1945-1950, i think australian has backed us.Some australian labour make a demonstration to show their support for our independence, i read this in article some years ago.So when i remember the australian support for East Timor independence, i can't blame the australian for that.They just make their choice, anyway i hope we can start a new relationship.:)

pasukangeraktjepat June 29th, 2005 05:39 AM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Supe

Does anyone expect there to be regional friction due to this announcement? Will it be seen as a natural process of a modernisation programme to make the TNI Navy more relevant or as Indonesia wanting to become more of a player in the region?

Well i don't think we want to become player like what you said.Back in 60's went the late Mr.Soekarno still in charge, Indonesia maybe can considered as one of the player in Southeast Asia, we have a fleet of Mig-21,Tupolev bomber; an armada of one cruiser, 6-7 destroyer ad several frigates; and a large number of soldier.But it only bring our people in poverty.
We only want to guard our area, so our people can enjoy what become our rights.
Edited : i can't find a story from Indonesian KRI's commander but i find a quite interesting story from Indonesian pilot.Read it in http://www.angkasa-online.com/10/06/...h/english1.htm

gf0012-aust June 29th, 2005 05:54 AM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pasukangeraktjepat
anyway i hope we can start a new relationship.:)

I think we're on the way to having a far more normal relationship. Certainly the relationship between the two navies is quite strong. :D

pasukangeraktjepat June 29th, 2005 11:22 AM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gf0012-aust
The IN has actually asked the RAN for assistance in this. We're being asked to assess what capability they need and to provide training.

Amazing change of heart when you consider that 6 years ago we were a bees dick away from going to war against each other

Gf, can you tell me the advise that has been given for our navy from your navy?
Is it about what kind of ship that we should possess or about navy tactic ?
Some months ago, i read an interview with Admiral (ret) Bernard Sondakh, an ex TNI AL chief, he said that in future Indonesian Navy ship will consist of 4 subs, 8 frigat/corvette with guided missile, 8 fast-attack craft with rocket, 2 fast-attack craft with torpedo and 4 mine-sweeper ship.All of that ships will be the main strike force of the navy.For routine patrol, navy will made 42 patrol ships.
He said hopefully in 2013 the navy can posses this as minimum requirements.

pasukangeraktjepat June 29th, 2005 11:26 AM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Aussie Digger

The RAN might advise that all Indonesian warships should be painted Brilliant white with a VERY large round red circle, painted right in the middle of them :D

Even nowadays you can see the KRI's quite easily, our ships was painted with tiger-style paint, a combine color of blue,white and black. :)

Paxter June 29th, 2005 12:43 PM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pasukangeraktjepat
Gf, can you tell me the advise that has been given for our navy from your navy?
Is it about what kind of ship that we should possess or about navy tactic ?
Some months ago, i read an interview with Admiral (ret) Bernard Sondakh, an ex TNI AL chief, he said that in future Indonesian Navy ship will consist of 4 subs, 8 frigat/corvette with guided missile, 8 fast-attack craft with rocket, 2 fast-attack craft with torpedo and 4 mine-sweeper ship.All of that ships will be the main strike force of the navy.For routine patrol, navy will made 42 patrol ships.
He said hopefully in 2013 the navy can posses this as minimum requirements.



thats a really small navy considering they have over 5000 islands to secure... funny... 2 months ago they want to pick a fight with malaysia....

gf0012-aust June 29th, 2005 08:17 PM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pasukangeraktjepat
Gf, can you tell me the advise that has been given for our navy from your navy?

No, all I know is that there are discussions under way between senior ranks about forward planning and development issues.

Quote:

Originally Posted by pasukangeraktjepat
Is it about what kind of ship that we should possess or about navy tactic ?

Ships and basic procedural issues. Indonesias problems lie in the fact that she has an enormous amount of small islands and islets that need policing. That is the province of smaller faster suitably armed vessels. If you are going to control piracy, then you need the capacity to harass. after all, if a prirate decides to take on a smaller naval vessel, they can guarantee that they will invite larger destruction for being impertinent.

Quote:

Originally Posted by pasukangeraktjepat
Some months ago, i read an interview with Admiral (ret) Bernard Sondakh, an ex TNI AL chief, he said that in future Indonesian Navy ship will consist of 4 subs, 8 frigat/corvette with guided missile, 8 fast-attack craft with rocket, 2 fast-attack craft with torpedo and 4 mine-sweeper ship.All of that ships will be the main strike force of the navy.For routine patrol, navy will made 42 patrol ships.
He said hopefully in 2013 the navy can posses this as minimum requirements.

I think he's being incredibly optimistic.

pasukangeraktjepat June 29th, 2005 11:09 PM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gf0012-aust
I think he's being incredibly optimistic.

I don't see it being optimistic Gf, i heard that it was a very very minimum force that we must have, first the navy want to have around 190 warships, to secure indonesian ocean.But our goverment can't afford, so they ask for around 171 warships, still our govt can't afford.So after a long debate that was left for our navy.
Another reason of why our navy was so small, is because the defence vision of our leader.When Soeharto became a president, Indonesian Armed Forces was concentrating on the Army.He made an Army so strong, in the term of number and equipment.Our defence vision on that moment is 'pertahanan rakyat semesta (people-total defence)', it was a guerilla-based defence system.Our govt.argue that we can gain our independence from dutch with that, so we can defend against any agressor with that again.It was so naive ;), but that 'old-school' mindset still grow until now.
Only after Mr Abdurrahman Wahid became president, we give our attention back to our navy.

Supe June 30th, 2005 02:19 AM

Re: Indonesia: 'green water navy'
 
I wouldn't be surprised if the IN was looking at obtaining an LHD. If they aren't perhaps they should. It would be a tremendous asset to have at their disposal. IN would be able to operate Helicopters and fast attack craft from an LHD which could be used as a centre of operations against piracy. It could also be deployed in areas affected by natural disasters as well as minor power projection as heavy lift for the army. Such an LHD could be outfitted as a Navy flagship with all the comms gear necessary to co-ordinate the duties it has been directed to undertake. As a flagship it could co-ordinate efforts with other foreign navies (Malaysia/Singapore) to interdict suspected criminal traffic. The flow on benefits of closer ties in the region would reward an IN acquistion of such a ship tenfold.

I don't how cheap you could go with such an LHD though. I don't think the ships Australia are considering would be within the limits of an Indonesian defence budget but perhaps there are smaller LHD designs floating around that are cheaper but suitable for the tasks mentioned previously. It might be time for the IN to think big.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:21 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2003-2011 DefenceTalk.com. All Rights Reserved.