Grand Danois
Entertainer
There seems to be some disagreement over Patriot effectiveness vs ballistic missiles. So lets gather some sources and have that discussion.
Discussion points:
I'll open up with the latter.
The data sheet from Raytheon for a quick primer. Yes it is a presentation as the producer wants you to see it.
http://www.raytheon.com/businesses/stellent/groups/public/documents/legacy_site/cms01_048575.pdf
Something more tangible:
Successful Test Flight for Patriot Guidance Enhanced Missiles
The Patriot Air and Missile Defense System is the world's most advanced ground-based air defense system and is a cornerstone of the U.S. Army's integrated air defense system.
by Staff Writers
Tewksbury MA (SPX) Jun 07, 2006
Raytheon's Patriot Guidance Enhanced Missiles (GEM) destroyed two surrogate ballistic missile targets highlighting a successful test flight at White Sands Missile Range, N.M.
The test is the first of four development flight tests to be conducted by the Army's Patriot Lower Tier Project Office using Raytheon's newly developed Patriot system post deployment build-6 (PDB-6) software.
"This flight test is another significant achievement in evolving and enhancing the capabilities of the Patriot system as the combat-proven, premier air defense solution for our warfighters," said Rick Yuse, Raytheon Integrated Defense Systems (IDS) vice president of Integrated Air Defense.
"Without a doubt, this test demonstrated the Configuration-3/PDB-6 system's capability to search, detect, track, classify, engage and kill two surrogate full-body tactical ballistic missile (TBM) targets."
Three Patriot fire units deployed in a battalion configuration supported the evaluation of this mission's objectives. Two GEMs were ripple-fired at an incoming tactical ballistic missile, and as the intercept occurred, the Patriot Configuration-3 radar successfully detected, tracked and engaged a second target.
A third GEM successfully intercepted the second incoming TBM while managing the first intercept. The capabilities incorporated into PDB-6 are the next step in the evolving growth for Patriot. This update is composed of user-requested improvements, planned performance improvements, and improvements that had resulted out of lessons learned from Operation Iraqi Freedom.
Patriot fire units, consisting of the Patriot launchers, engagement control stations and Patriot radar systems, provided the battle management, command, control and communications to ensure the Configuration-3 system achieved test objectives.
The targets for the mission were Patriot-as-a-Target, a Patriot legacy missile modified to represent a short-range ballistic missile target. Test data indicated that seamless communication and data transfer between the Patriot radar, engagement control station, and Patriot launcher enabled the GEMs to destroy both targets.
All tactical hardware for the missions were manned and operated by soldiers of the 1st Battalion of the 7th Air Defense Artillery, Fort Bliss, Texas.
Raytheon IDS is the prime contractor for the Patriot system and the system integrator for the Configuration-3 system that includes the GEM missile. As the system integrator, Raytheon IDS ensures that all Patriot system components provide the warfighter a reliable and lethal capability to defeat the threats in current and future combat environments.
The Patriot Air and Missile Defense System is the world's most advanced ground-based air defense system and is a cornerstone of the U.S. Army's integrated air defense system. Patriot is a long-range, high-altitude, all-weather system designed to defeat advanced threats, including aircraft, tactical ballistic missiles, and cruise missiles.
Combat proven during Operations Desert Storm and Iraqi Freedom, Patriot can simultaneously engage multiple targets under the most severe electronic countermeasure conditions.
Integrated Defense Systems is Raytheon's leader in Joint Battlespace Integration providing affordable, integrated solutions to a strong international and domestic customer base, including the U.S. Missile Defense Agency and the U.S. armed forces.
http://www.spacewar.com/reports/Successful_Test_Flight_for_Patriot_Guidance_Enhanced_Missiles.html
Discussion points:
- Performance during Desert Storm
- Performance OIF
http://www.globalsecurity.org/space/ops/oif-patriot.htm
- Track record did the upgrades work?
http://www.spacewar.com/reports/Successful_Test_Flight_for_Patriot_Guidance_Enhanced_Missiles.html
I'll open up with the latter.
The data sheet from Raytheon for a quick primer. Yes it is a presentation as the producer wants you to see it.
http://www.raytheon.com/businesses/stellent/groups/public/documents/legacy_site/cms01_048575.pdf
Something more tangible:
Successful Test Flight for Patriot Guidance Enhanced Missiles
The Patriot Air and Missile Defense System is the world's most advanced ground-based air defense system and is a cornerstone of the U.S. Army's integrated air defense system.
by Staff Writers
Tewksbury MA (SPX) Jun 07, 2006
Raytheon's Patriot Guidance Enhanced Missiles (GEM) destroyed two surrogate ballistic missile targets highlighting a successful test flight at White Sands Missile Range, N.M.
The test is the first of four development flight tests to be conducted by the Army's Patriot Lower Tier Project Office using Raytheon's newly developed Patriot system post deployment build-6 (PDB-6) software.
"This flight test is another significant achievement in evolving and enhancing the capabilities of the Patriot system as the combat-proven, premier air defense solution for our warfighters," said Rick Yuse, Raytheon Integrated Defense Systems (IDS) vice president of Integrated Air Defense.
"Without a doubt, this test demonstrated the Configuration-3/PDB-6 system's capability to search, detect, track, classify, engage and kill two surrogate full-body tactical ballistic missile (TBM) targets."
Three Patriot fire units deployed in a battalion configuration supported the evaluation of this mission's objectives. Two GEMs were ripple-fired at an incoming tactical ballistic missile, and as the intercept occurred, the Patriot Configuration-3 radar successfully detected, tracked and engaged a second target.
A third GEM successfully intercepted the second incoming TBM while managing the first intercept. The capabilities incorporated into PDB-6 are the next step in the evolving growth for Patriot. This update is composed of user-requested improvements, planned performance improvements, and improvements that had resulted out of lessons learned from Operation Iraqi Freedom.
Patriot fire units, consisting of the Patriot launchers, engagement control stations and Patriot radar systems, provided the battle management, command, control and communications to ensure the Configuration-3 system achieved test objectives.
The targets for the mission were Patriot-as-a-Target, a Patriot legacy missile modified to represent a short-range ballistic missile target. Test data indicated that seamless communication and data transfer between the Patriot radar, engagement control station, and Patriot launcher enabled the GEMs to destroy both targets.
All tactical hardware for the missions were manned and operated by soldiers of the 1st Battalion of the 7th Air Defense Artillery, Fort Bliss, Texas.
Raytheon IDS is the prime contractor for the Patriot system and the system integrator for the Configuration-3 system that includes the GEM missile. As the system integrator, Raytheon IDS ensures that all Patriot system components provide the warfighter a reliable and lethal capability to defeat the threats in current and future combat environments.
The Patriot Air and Missile Defense System is the world's most advanced ground-based air defense system and is a cornerstone of the U.S. Army's integrated air defense system. Patriot is a long-range, high-altitude, all-weather system designed to defeat advanced threats, including aircraft, tactical ballistic missiles, and cruise missiles.
Combat proven during Operations Desert Storm and Iraqi Freedom, Patriot can simultaneously engage multiple targets under the most severe electronic countermeasure conditions.
Integrated Defense Systems is Raytheon's leader in Joint Battlespace Integration providing affordable, integrated solutions to a strong international and domestic customer base, including the U.S. Missile Defense Agency and the U.S. armed forces.
http://www.spacewar.com/reports/Successful_Test_Flight_for_Patriot_Guidance_Enhanced_Missiles.html
Last edited: