Go Back   Defense Technology & Military Forum > Global Defense & Military > Missiles & WMDs
Forgot Password? Join Us! Its's free!

Defense News
Land, Air & Naval Forces






Military Photos
Latest Military Pictures

ExPB14_JAS-39_Gripen.jpg

ExPB14_Mirage2000.jpg

6_EXPB14_20140729_088_3_RSAF_F16s.jpg

5_EXPB14_20140729_143_3_RSAF_F-15SGs.jpg
Defense Reports
Aerospace & Defence







Recent Photos - DefenceTalk Military Gallery





Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

This is a discussion on Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program within the Missiles & WMDs forum, part of the Global Defense & Military category; Israel's involvement with nuclear technology literally extends back to the founding of the country in 1948. A host of talented ...


Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Rate Thread
Old September 11th, 2004   #1
Defense Aficionado
General
No Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Islamabad
Posts: 4,886
Threads:
Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

Israel's involvement with nuclear technology literally extends back to the founding of the country in 1948. A host of talented scientists emigrated to Palestine during the thirties and forties, particularly one Ernst David Bergmann - later the director of the Israeli Atomic Energy Commission and the founder of Israel's efforts to develop nuclear weapons. The Weizmann Institute of Science actively supported nuclear research by 1949, with Bergmann heading its chemistry division. Also in 1949, Francis Perrin - French nuclear physicist, atomic energy commissioner, and personal friend of Bergmann's - visited the Weizmann Institute, after which Israeli scientists were invited to the newly established French nuclear research facility at Saclay. A joint research effort was subsequently set up between the two nations.

At this time France's nuclear research capability was quite limited. France had been a leading research center in nuclear physics before the war, but had fallen far behind developments in the US, the USSR, Britain, and even Canada. Israel and France were thus at a similar levels of expertise at the time, and it was possible for Israeli scientists to make valuable contributions. Consequently the development of nuclear science and technology in France and Israel remained closely linked in the early fifties, for example Israeli scientists were involved in the construction of the G-1 plutonium production reactor and UP1 reprocessing plant at Marcoule.

In the 1950s and early 1960s, France and Israel had very close relations. France was Israel's principal arms supplier, and as instability spread in France's colonies in North Africa, Israel provided valuable intelligence obtained from its contacts with sephardic Jews in those countries. The two nations even collaborated (along with Britain) in planning and staging the joint Suez-Sinai operation against Egypt in October 1956. The Suez Crisis, as it became known, proved to be the genesis of Israel's nuclear weapons production program.

Six weeks before the operation Israel felt the time was right to approach France for assistance in building a nuclear reactor. Canada had set a precedent a year earlier when it had agreed to build the 40 MW CIRUS reactor in India. Shimon Peres, a key aide to Prime Minister (and Defense Minister) David Ben Gurion, and Bergmann met with members of the CEA (France's Atomic Energy Commission). An initial understanding to provide a research reactor appears to have been reached during September.

On the whole the Suez operation, launched on 29 October was a disaster. Although Israel's part of the operation was a stunning success, allowing it to occupy the entire Sinai peninsula by 4 November, the French and British invasion on 6 November was a failure. The attempt to advance along the Suez canal bogged down and then collapsed under fierce US and Soviet pressure. Both European nations pulled out, leaving Israel to face the pressure from the two superpowers alone. Soviet premier Bulganin issued an implicit threat of nuclear attack if Israel did not withdraw from the Sinai.

On 7 November 1956, a secret meeting was held between foreign minister Golda Meir, Peres, and French foreign and defense ministers Mssrs. Christian Pineau and Maurice Bourges-Manoury. The French officials were deeply chagrined by France's failure to support its ally in the operation, and the Israelis were very concerned about the Soviet threat. In this meeting the initial understanding about a research reactor may have been substantially modified, and Peres seems to have secured an agreement to assist Israel in developing a nuclear deterrent.

After some further months of negotiation, the initial agreement for assistance took the form of an 18 MW (thermal) research reactor of the EL-3 type, along with plutonium separation technology. At some point this was officially upgraded to 24 MW, but the actual specifications issued to engineers provided for core cooling ducts sufficient for up to three times this power level, along with a plutonium plant of similar capacity. How this upgrade came about remains unknown.

The reactor was secretly built underground at Dimona, in the Negev desert of southern Israel near Beersheba. Hundreds of French engineers and technicians filled Beersheba which, although it was the biggest town in the Negev, was still a small town. Many of the same contractors who built Marcoule were involved, for example the plutonium separation plants in both France and Israel were built by SGN. The Ground was broken for the EL-102 reactor (as it was known to France) in early 1958. The heavy water for the reactor was purchased from Norway, which sold 20 tons to Israel in 1959 allegedly for use in an experimental power reactor Norway insisted on the right to inspect the heavy water for peaceful use for 32 years, but was permitted to do so only once, in April 1961, prior to it being loaded into the Dimona reactor tank.

Israel used a variety of subterfuges to explain away the activity at Dimona - calling it a "manganese plant" among other things (although apparently not a "textile plant" as most accounts claim). US intelligence became aware of the project before the end of 1958, took picture of the project from U-2 spy planes, and identified the site as a probable reactor complex. The concentration of Frenchmen was certainly impossible to hide.

In 1960, before the reactor was operating, France, now under the leadership of de Gaulle, reconsidered the deal and decided to suspend the project. After several months of negotiation, an agreement was reached in November that allowed the reactor to proceed if Israel promised not the make weapons and announced the project to the world, work on the plutonium plant halted.

On 2 December 1960, before Israel could make the announcement, the US State Department issued a determination that Israel had a secret nuclear installation. By 16 December this became public knowledge with its appearance in the New York Times. On 21 December Ben Gurion announced that Israel was building a 24 MW reactor "for peaceful purposes".

Over the next year the relationship between the US and Israel was strained over the issue. The US accepted Israel's claims at face value in public, but exerted pressure privately. Although Israel did allow a cursory inspection by physicists Eugene Wigner and I.I. Rabi, PM Ben Gurion consistently refused to allow international inspections. The final resolution was a commitment from Israel to use the facility for peaceful purposes, and an agreement to admit a US inspection team once a year. These inspections, begun in 1962 and continued until 1969, were only shown the above-ground part of the buildings, which continued down many levels underground. The above ground areas had simulated control rooms, and access to the underground areas was kept bricked up while the inspectors where present. The most favorable interpretation that can be given to adherence to the pledge is that it has apparently been interpreted by Israel to mean that nuclear weapon development is not excluded if the are used strictly for defensive, and not aggressive purposes. It should be remembered though that Israel's security position in the late fifties and early sixties when the nuclear program was taking shape was far more precarious than it subsequently became after the Six Day War, the establishment of a robust domestic arms industry, and a reliable defense supply line from the US. During the fifties and early sixties a number of attempts by Israel to obtain security guarantees from the US, thus effectively placing Israel under the US nuclear umbrella in a manner similar to NATO or Japan, were rebuffed. If an active policy to restrain Israel's proliferation had been undertaken, along with a secure defense agreement, the development of a nuclear arsenal might have been preventable.

In 1962 the Dimona reactor went critical, and the French resumed work on the plutonium plant, believed to have been completed in 1964 or 1965. The acquisition of this reactor and related technologies was clearly intended for military purposes from the outset (not "dual use") as the reactor has no other function. The security at Dimona (officially the Negev Nuclear Research Center) is stringent, an IAF Mirage was actually shot down in 1967 for straying into Dimona's airspace. There is little doubt then, that some time in the late sixties Israel became the sixth nation to manufacture nuclear weapons.

According to Seymour Hersh, PM Levi Eshkol delayed starting nuclear weapons production even after the Dimona facility was finished. The reactor remained in operation so the plutonium continued to collect, whether it was separated or not. It is generally believed that the first extraction of plutonium occurred in 1965, and that enough plutonium was on hand for one weapon during the Six Day War in 1967 although whether a prototype weapon actually existed or not is unknown. Hersh relates that Moshe Dayan gave the go ahead for starting weapon production in early 1968, which is when the plutonium separation plant presumably went into full operation. After this Israel began producing three to five bombs a year. William Burroms and Robert Windrem, on the other hand, assert in Critical Mass that Israel actually had two bombs available for use in 1967, and that Eshkol actually ordered them armed in Israel's first nuclear alert during the Six Day War.

Israel began purchasing Krytrons in 1971. These are ultra high speed electronic switching tubes that are "dual use", having both industrial and nuclear weapons applications.

At 2 p.m. (local) on 6 October 1973 Egypt and Syria attacked Israel in a coordinated surprise attack, starting the Yom Kippur War. Caught with only their standing forces on duty, and these at a low level of readiness, the Israeli front lines were overrun. By early afternoon on 7 October no defensive forces were left in the southern Golan Heights and Syrian forces had reached the edge of the plateau, within sight of the Jordan River. It has been widely reported that this crisis brought Israel to its first nuclear alert. Hersh reports that the decision was made by PM Golda Meir and her "kitchen cabinet" on the night of 8 October. This resulted in the Jericho missiles at Hirbat Zachariah and the nuclear strike F-4s at Tel Nof being armed and prepared for action against Syrian and Egyptian targets. US Sec. of State Henry Kissinger was apparently notified of this alert several hours later on the morning of 9 October, which helped motivate a US decision to promptly open a resupply pipeline to Israel (Israeli aircraft began picking up supplies that day, the first US flights arrived on 14 October).

Though stockpile depletion remained a concern, the military situation stabilized on October 8 and 9 as Israeli reserves poured into the battle and disaster was averted. Well before significant resupply had reached Israeli forces, the Israelis counterattacked and turned the tide on both fronts. On 11 October a counterattack on the Golan broke the back of Syria's offensive, and on October 15 and 16 Israel launched a surprise crossing of the Suez Canal. Soon the Egyptian Third Army was faced with encirclement and annihilation, with no protective forces remaining between the Israeli Army and Cairo. This prompted Leonid Brezhnev to threaten, on 24 October, to airlift Soviet troops to reinforce the Egyptians. Pres. Nixon's response was to bring the US to world-wide nuclear alert the next day, whereupon Israel went to nuclear alert a second time (according to Hersh, Burrows and Windrem do not recognize this alert). This sudden crisis quickly faded as PM Meir agreed to a ceasefire, relieving the pressure on the Egyptians.

Considerable nuclear collaboration between Israel and South Africa seems to have developed around 1967 and continued through the 70s and 80s. During this period SA was Israel's primary supplier of uranium for Dimona. An open question remains regarding what role Israel had (if any) in the 22 September 1979 nuclear explosion in the south Indian Ocean which is widely believed to be a SA-Israel joint test. This relationship is discussed more fully in the section on South Africa.

Hersh relates extensive (and highly successful) efforts by Israel to obtain targeting data from US intelligence. Much satellite imaging data of the Soviet Union was obtained through the American spy Jonathan Pollard, apparently indicating Israel's intention to use its nuclear arsenal as a deterrent, political lever, or retaliatory capability against the Soviet Union itself.

Satellite imagery from a US KH-11 satellite for example was used to plan the 7 June 1981 attack on the Tammuz-1 reactor at Osiraq, Iraq. This attack, carried out by 8 F-16s accompanied by 6 F-15s punched a hole in the concrete reactor dome before the reactor began operation (and just days before an Israeli election) and delivered 15 delay-fuzed 2000 lb bombs deep into the reactor structure (the 16th bomb hit a nearby hall). The blasts shredded the reactor and blew out the dome foundations, causing it to collapse on the rubble. This was the world's first attack on a nuclear reactor.

Since 19 September 1988 Israel has had its own satellite reconnaissance system and thus no longer needs to rely on US sources. On that day the Offeq-1 satellite was launched on the Shavit booster, a system closely related to the Jericho-2 missile. Offeq-2 went up on 3 April 1990. The launch of the Offeq-3 failed on its first attempton 15 September 1994, but was retried successfully 05 April 1995.

Both Hersh and Burrows and Windrem agree that Israel went on full scale nuclear alert again on the first day of Desert Storm, 18 January 1991, when 7 Scud missiles were fired against the cities of Tel Aviv and Haifa by Iraq (only 2 actually hit Tel Aviv and 1 hit Haifa). This alert apparently lasted for the duration of the war (43 days). Threats of retaliation by the Shamir government if the Iraqis used chemical warheads are interpreted to mean that Israel intended to launch a nuclear strike if gas attacks occurred.
________________
www.pakpasban.com
yasin_khan is offline   Reply With Quote
Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Past History - Australia's Bid for the Atomic Bomb. gf0012-aust Missiles & WMDs 79 January 8th, 2011 03:46 AM
Time to check Israel's nuclear arms The Watcher Missiles & WMDs 3 January 10th, 2004 01:54 PM
''Tehran Outmaneuvers Washington For Now'' The Watcher Missiles & WMDs 0 December 4th, 2003 11:16 AM

Old December 15th, 2004   #2
Banned Member
Lieutenant
kashifshahzad's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: islamabad.pakistan
Posts: 521
Threads:
yeah the america can do any thing to save isreal there are a lot of intrests for the america in isreal
kashifshahzad is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 15th, 2004   #3
Senior Member
Lieutenant Colonel
highsea's Avatar
Join Date: May 2004
Location: BFI Seattle
Posts: 1,091
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

kashifshahzad, how does that relate to the article? It talks about Israel's nuclear program, a product of France and South Africa. The US has never aided Israel's nuclear program. The article details how Israel deceived the US on inspections, and how the US rejected Israel's attempts to "take her under the umbrella".

How does this translate into "saving" Israel?
highsea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 15th, 2004   #4
Senior Member
Brigadier General
P.A.F's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 1,748
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

all i can say is that isreals nuke arsenal is amongst the biggest in the world as there scientist revealed in germany, munich. He called out to the world to help stop isreals growing nuke program. when he got back to isreal he was jailed and killed.
P.A.F is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 15th, 2004   #5
Senior Member
Lieutenant Colonel
highsea's Avatar
Join Date: May 2004
Location: BFI Seattle
Posts: 1,091
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

Quote:
Originally Posted by P.A.F
...when he got back to isreal he was jailed and killed.
Who was that? I know Vanunu was jailed, but he was released. Who did they kill?
highsea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 15th, 2004   #6
Defense Enthusiast
Chief Warrant Officer
No Avatar
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Canada
Posts: 413
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

well i understand why israel needs a nuke capability when its in a neighbourhood filled with bloodthirsty jew-haters, but why that big??
highseas got an answer

ps i think america didn't do everything in its power to stop israel form acquiring nukes, well obviously i mean they got 13 million jews who drive their economy, and the israelis are highly resourceful and have a large number of their jewish brethren in the ranks of america's elite. (this is to all you jew-haters)
redsoulja is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 15th, 2004   #7
Defense Aficionado
General
mysterious's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 3,058
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

No body hates Jews redsoulja. Its the Israeli policies and acts in the region that nurture hatred towards Israel and some groups commit indescent acts ignoring humanity (but then again, Israeli forces' operations are just as inhuman). I wont indulge in this much with you as I see it as more of a emotion driven post and not practical. The rest is up to the Mods to edit your post.
________________
With passion and sacrifice, comes freedom!
mysterious is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 16th, 2004   #8
Senior Member
Lieutenant Colonel
highsea's Avatar
Join Date: May 2004
Location: BFI Seattle
Posts: 1,091
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

redsoulja, I don't have an answer to why Israel built up the arsenal that they did, that's something that the military planners decide. When the US determined that Israel was deceiving us, we weren't happy about it, but it was a fait accompli. There was nothing for us to stop, it was too late.

If we would have known what France and Israel were up to, we probably would have tried to intervene, but at the time France was Israel's biggest backer, not the US. I don't know if it would have even mattered. It wasn't until after the Six days War that the US began to really support Israel.



Now, as far as your comments, you need to read the rules again. If you wish to say that Israel has many hostile neighbors, fine. Calling them bloodthirsty jew-haters is not acceptable here. That is offensive to many of the members here, including myself. Whatever your personal prejudices, I am advising you to post with respect to all parties.

highsea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 16th, 2004   #9
Defense Enthusiast
Lieutenant
ajay_ijn's Avatar
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Hyderabad,India
Posts: 588
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

Quote:
all i can say is that isreals nuke arsenal is amongst the biggest in the world as there scientist revealed in germany, munich. He called out to the world to help stop isreals growing nuke program. when he got back to isreal he was jailed and killed.
of course he must be,Any guy revealing about Countries Top Secrets must not be spared.He betrayed his own country.

We cannot condemn the fact that isreal is slightly a militaristic Country.
At this position they don't need large nuclear stockpile.
What they need is better tactics,soliders and weapons to fight against guerialla warfare and terrorism
ajay_ijn is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 16th, 2004   #10
Super Moderator
Lieutenant General
SABRE's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,677
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

I think as long as Israel is not threatening any Arab Nation physicaly with its Nuke tech its safe. If it adobts the way Iraq did (officialy threatening to use Scuds with Bio & Chemical weapons against Israel & neighbours) as well as IRan & North Korea only than it can come under international pressure & US would be forced to act, even though Israel can be a bit careless with it. But than so r India & Pakistan but there is no international pressure or not much of it. Its cause both countries dont threaten to use it against each other & say is for defence purpose only not for offensive.

Its so simple that we point every thing to US. Although time we r bragging that US has given every thing to Israel & not to Arab Nations+Pakistan. We believe US has made Israel strong by giving it better war weapons, well think again. If US is giving F-16s to Israel than it has also sold F-15s to Saudis & F-16s to Egypt,Jordon & one of the best F-16s in the world to UAE. If they have kept their eyes shut on Israeli Nuke program than they havent been completely opening eyes of Pak's nuke Program infact when USSR attacked Afghansiatn US was saying go ahead defend ur self by any means (pointing to go ahead with Nukes). Pak has been target of change in US governments & its foregin policies. Republicans & Dems. Both have different policies for Pak other wise if we (Muslim Nations & Anti Israelis) come to think of what US has done for most of us & adopt possitive policies we might just get the same treatment.
& Yes Jews r not the only ones investing in US, Oil rich Arab nations r also doing so.
________________
"It is better to accept an end with a horror then face horror with no end." - Karl Von Clausewitz
SABRE is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 16th, 2004   #11
Senior Member
Lieutenant Colonel
highsea's Avatar
Join Date: May 2004
Location: BFI Seattle
Posts: 1,091
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

Very good points Sabre. People often overlook the fact that the US fixed aid to Egypt at 2/3 of whatever Israel gets. If Israel gets $3Bn., Egypt automatically gets $2bn. This was the price that the US was willing to pay for peace between Egypt and Israel.

Personally, I would like to see the entire ME denuclearized. One country gets them, then the next wants them, then the next, and on down the line. The region would have a great future if everyone could stop fighting and learn to live together.

But you are right about not taking a threatening posture. We don't put pressure on Israel, Pakistan or India about their nukes because they don't threaten other countries with them.

I still want to know who the scientist was who was killed. ...Bueller?...Bueller?....Anybody?
highsea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 16th, 2004   #12
Super Moderator
Lieutenant General
SABRE's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,677
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

Quote:
Originally Posted by highsea
I still want to know who the scientist was who was killed. ...Bueller?...Bueller?....Anybody?
I think he is talking abt Vannunu or what ever the name is. But he wasnt killed. I think he got re-arrestd couple of months back, but not killed.
________________
"It is better to accept an end with a horror then face horror with no end." - Karl Von Clausewitz
SABRE is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 16th, 2004   #13
Senior Member
Lieutenant Colonel
highsea's Avatar
Join Date: May 2004
Location: BFI Seattle
Posts: 1,091
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

Yeah, he was re-arrested, but he wasn't killed. The terms of his release was that he was not allowed to leave Israel or give interviews to foreign press.

The problem was that the first thing he did was start to give interviews to foreign media! So they put him back in jail.

He is widely regarded in Israel as a traitor, he might be safer in jail than out. Anyway, most countries have pretty strict laws about disclosing state secrets.
highsea is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 16th, 2004   #14
Super Moderator
Lieutenant General
SABRE's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,677
Threads:
Re: Israel's Nuclear Weapons Program

Quote:
Originally Posted by highsea
Yeah, he was re-arrested, but he wasn't killed. The terms of his release was that he was not allowed to leave Israel or give interviews to foreign press.

The problem was that the first thing he did was start to give interviews to foreign media! So they put him back in jail.

He is widely regarded in Israel as a traitor, he might be safer in jail than out. Anyway, most countries have pretty strict laws about disclosing state secrets.
if he is not safe inside Israel than y isnt he allowed to leave the country.
SABRE is offline   Reply With Quote
Old December 16th, 2004   #15
Banned Member
Major General
srirangan's Avatar
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: New Delhi, India
Posts: 2,351
Threads:
>> if he is not safe inside Israel than y isnt he allowed to leave the country.
Because he is guilty under law. Guilty persons aren't allowed to just leave, in any country!
srirangan is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:23 AM.