Defense Technology & Military Forum

Defense Technology & Military Forum (http://www.defencetalk.com/forums/)
-   Military Strategy and Tactics (http://www.defencetalk.com/forums/military-strategy-tactics/)
-   -   Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever? (http://www.defencetalk.com/forums/military-strategy-tactics/do-you-think-greatest-empire-ever-3114/)

adsH February 8th, 2005 10:16 PM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by redsoulja
DSJ what are you talking about, are you out of your ignorant euro-centric racist mind, the Egyptians, Mesopotamians, Indus Valley and the Chinese were the First four great civilizations, heck when the Asians and Africans had such advanced cultures with massive literature, cities, large collosal buildings Europe simply consisted of barbaric nomadic tribes that were extremely primitive, other than Stonehenge there is very little great feats that teh Europeans committed. The Europeans only ruled the world because they were much more efficient at perpetrating violence against the rest of the world. They did not rule because of their religion, culture, history, or literature, they ruled with the gun. All the great religions were founded in Asia and Africa not Europe.I am not saying Europeans are the only violent ones, I'm just saying everyone can be violent for it is in the human nature. To assume that one group of humans is superior to other s is purely ignorance, and even when you look at the facts, the great civilizations before Greece were all African or Asian. And the west isn't modest today as no human civilization at its peak was ever modest, there are always exceptions. About Mongols being violent, what about the slavery of over 20 million African human beings? What about the millions of dead vietnamese? What about the numerous authoritarian regimes that the West has propped all over the rest of the world in order to maintain economic and geopolitical superiority, the very same regimes who have prevented the natural rise of democracy? These regimes prevent the developing world form achieving the same revolutions that the West achieved earlier. Webs i am sorry if i got a bit out of hand, this guy's racial ignorance just got my blood boiling!!!

YOu can't Just Say that Europe has Had some great Empires too, Greeks Romans and the Brits

dsj February 8th, 2005 10:18 PM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by redsoulja
DSJ what are you talking about, are you out of your ignorant euro-centric racist mind, the Egyptians, Mesopotamians, Indus Valley and the Chinese were the First four great civilizations, heck when the Asians and Africans had such advanced cultures with massive literature, cities, large collosal buildings Europe simply consisted of barbaric nomadic tribes that were extremely primitive, other than Stonehenge there is very little great feats that teh Europeans committed. The Europeans only ruled the world because they were much more efficient at perpetrating violence against the rest of the world. They did not rule because of their religion, culture, history, or literature, they ruled with the gun. All the great religions were founded in Asia and Africa not Europe.I am not saying Europeans are the only violent ones, I'm just saying everyone can be violent for it is in the human nature. To assume that one group of humans is superior to other s is purely ignorance, and even when you look at the facts, the great civilizations before Greece were all African or Asian. And the west isn't modest today as no human civilization at its peak was ever modest, there are always exceptions. About Mongols being violent, what about the slavery of over 20 million African human beings? What about the millions of dead vietnamese? What about the numerous authoritarian regimes that the West has propped all over the rest of the world in order to maintain economic and geopolitical superiority, the very same regimes who have prevented the natural rise of democracy? These regimes prevent the developing world form achieving the same revolutions that the West achieved earlier. Webs i am sorry if i got a bit out of hand, this guy's racial ignorance just got my blood boiling!!!

racist? the whole books called carnage and culture a national bestseller completely agrees with my point. mabe you would like to appear on the angry reader list of the author's site and see what victor davis hanson have to say about you. Just calling someone nice and strong and free isn't being racist. Vietnam was attacked as a result of their own aggression. Your ideas are exactly what hanson laughs at. I've met another one of you guys. Interesting.

The Watcher February 8th, 2005 10:26 PM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
dsj, you apparently over look the european dark ages which lasted well over 3 centuries and periods before that. every civilization has its golden period and its dark period and im sure europeans went through the same. they were at some point in time did some things which would be considered backwards in todays standard. civilized? i dont know about that. look at the ways they waged wars (crusades?) over 65,000 civilians died in one crusade alone, and then their stomachs were slit open to see if they swallowed any gold coins....(by your standards you would consider those people savages) !!! then look at the way they waged wars among themselves and not to forget the barbaric act of witch hunt that took place in europe and in UK. innocent women were killed because of superstitious beliefs in witches. :rolleyes:

dsj February 8th, 2005 10:29 PM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by adsH
I would attribute your Comments as mere ignorance; No one just appreciates other peoples Achievements without a cause. The Asians were civilized too, Middle East is the Birth Place of Civilization in-fact the City of Babylon the Birth Place of Civilization Located in Now Iraq. Your Spanner Comments don't seam to include the Hindu Civilization Which predates Any Significant Recorded History. Your comments don't indicate the Achievements by the Islamic Spain, Achievements that above all included, multicultural welfare society, Ship Building Sea Faring Navies and Trading across the world, there achievements in Modern Medicine like Anesthetics, The Word Algebra comes from the Egypt where the Whole concept of Modern Moths was formed, if you had studied Math’s then you would known that the Arabic Mathematical symbols were adopted into the Roman Symbols, which still is by far the Best ever produced. You don't seam to actually point out the Strives made by the Various Jewish Empires of the Time in the Vicinity of Jerusalem. Your comments don't indicate the Welfare culture the Spanish/ Othman and the Indian Mughal (Not Mongol, Mongolians). The Architectural wonders that were developed by Iranians like the Taj Mahel in India. Your Sheer Lack of appreciation of these cultures is just appalling. Go and read more then just one bias textbook. It’s the Duty of a historian to Record and Analyze History in the most Accurate manner, Unfortunately there are some that never choose to Honor this Tradition. This is a plague to humanity, because if we don’t record history as accurately possible then we only condemn our future generations to make those same mistakes again. Lessons lesson’s From the Past Yielded “United Nations”, a cooperation that would prevent War and Allow Nations to discuss there problems rather then Fight out the Dispute.


I never said that the east didn't have anything, that europe was always ahead of them at least in terms of military power. I again DIDNT say that the asians were completely fruitless, just that europe was always ahead of them at least in military power and democratic state.

redsoulja February 8th, 2005 10:36 PM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Adsh yeah i agree completely that they have had great civs but that does not give him the right to be ignorant posting such crap, specifically when the Middle East was the cradle of civilization.
Just because millions of Americans and British buy book about Western superiority doesnt necessarily mean the West is greater than the rest. And I also don't agree with this author.

dsj February 8th, 2005 10:44 PM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by redsoulja
Adsh yeah i agree completely that they have had great civs but that does not give him the right to be ignorant posting such crap, specifically when the Middle East was the cradle of civilization.
Just because millions of Americans and British buy book about Western superiority doesnt necessarily mean the West is greater than the rest. And I also don't agree with this author.

It's not right to call someone's posts crap. I no longer have the time to argue with you. Go to victor hanson's site and argue with him and join the angry readers. I think you are one of what he calls "Islamicist" If you are one, I'm not interested in hearing your fanatical aggression.

redsoulja February 8th, 2005 10:55 PM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Now youre making an assumption that I'm a muslim, and calling me a fanatic??? Personally I'm not an Islamist but if being one is wrong so is being euro-centric.

srirangan February 9th, 2005 02:01 AM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Dsj,

Civilization first began in:
- Egypt
- Sumeria (Iraq/Iran)
- Indus-Saraswati (Sindh, Gujarath, Rajasthan Punjab in South Asia), and
- China

I think you will agree none of these regions lie in Europe. These regions saw civilization while the rest of the wrold, including Europe, lived as barbaric tribals. So your claim of European Civilizational Superiority cannot be justified.

adsH February 9th, 2005 07:16 AM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dsj
It's not right to call someone's posts crap. I no longer have the time to argue with you. Go to victor hanson's site and argue with him and join the angry readers. I think you are one of what he calls "Islamicist" If you are one, I'm not interested in hearing your fanatical aggression.

I'm sorry I didn't know You carried so much Aggression against the "Islamics", well anyways. Can you email the Author Ask him about the “Undefeatable Armies of the Othman”, Can you ask him why the Spanish Armada Ruled the Sea at one time. Can you ask him why the Persians had been regarded in history as great Warriors. Could you ask him why the Indian Mughall Armies were regarded as one of the most powerful armies in the Region?.

Alexander the Great him self considered the Indian Rajas as brilliant generals of there time

. Every Empire is based on some sort of Power centre, that Centre requires Authority, Military is that authority. And every Empire has its peak then its demise.

SABRE February 10th, 2005 07:51 AM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by srirangan
Dsj,

Civilization first began in:
- Egypt
- Sumeria (Iraq/Iran)
- Indus-Saraswati (Sindh, Gujarath, Rajasthan Punjab in South Asia), and
- China

I think you will agree none of these regions lie in Europe. These regions saw civilization while the rest of the wrold, including Europe, lived as barbaric tribals. So your claim of European Civilizational Superiority cannot be justified.

Totaly agreeed;

All I know is that Sumeria/Babylon/Iraq is the oldest recorded civilization in the world today.
Egypt came later.

Empror Qin (Chin) founded the Qin empire in China & all I know is that was waaaayyyyy long ago.

Indus-Saraswati is about 5000 yrs old. PS not to forget the advent aryans in South Asia.

5000 yrs back as always Europe was in dark ages. Civilizations existed only in great cities like Rome, Athens, Troy, Sparta. Even the lands that surrounded these cities were barbaric. Romans fought many wars with Barbarian tribes.

When the Turkish Muslim Kalif sent his embassador to some European country the people over there asked him that they have herd that he can DRAW what people speek. That means they did not even have sense of writing 1400 years ago. My friend tells me that a movie was also made on this Embassador. Its called 13th Warrior (I have yet to see it).

But I have a question? R we dicussing civilizations here or empires? I think both r inter-related in should be discussed togather.

srirangan February 10th, 2005 09:10 AM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Quote:

That means they did not even have sense of writing 1400 years ago.
That can be easily disputed. Pictography ended with the Pharoh's BC.

adsH February 10th, 2005 10:01 AM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by srirangan
That can be easily disputed. Pictography ended with the Pharoh's BC.

Regardless of the disputes the House of Wisdom AKA World library was in Baghdad, it was where all the world knowledge was compiled into Books which was a considerably new way of storing knowledge.

srirangan February 10th, 2005 10:32 AM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by adsH
Regardless of the disputes the House of Wisdom AKA World library was in Baghdad, it was where all the world knowledge was compiled into Books which was a considerably new way of storing knowledge.

True, but it was wrong to claim that Europeans didn't know how to write 1400 years ago.

XEROX February 10th, 2005 11:05 AM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
greatest Empire in history got to be the Romans, it spanned from Eastern europe, England, west europe, greece, and parts of the middle east and northern africa


srirangan February 10th, 2005 11:22 AM

Re: Which do you think was/is the Greatest Empire ever?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by PJ-10 BrahMos
greatest Empire in history got to be the Romans, it spanned from Eastern europe, England, west europe, greece, and parts of the middle east and northern africa


Territorially speaking, the Mongols and Brit's definitely did better.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:29 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
Copyright 2003-2011 DefenceTalk.com. All Rights Reserved.