Go Back   DefenceTalk Forum - Military & Defense Forums > Global Defense & Military > Geo-strategic Issues

Defense News
Land, Air & Naval Forces






Military Photos
Latest Military Pictures
Defense Reports
Aerospace & Defence


The Problem with Afghanistan

This is a discussion on The Problem with Afghanistan within the Geo-strategic Issues forum, part of the Global Defense & Military category; Originally Posted by Boer Kommando I am talking about current Afghanistan, current practices. so am I...


Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Rate Thread
Old March 17th, 2017   #46
Grumpy Old Man
General
gf0012-aust's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Australia
Posts: 17,997
Threads:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boer Kommando View Post
I am talking about current Afghanistan, current practices.
so am I
________________
A corollary of Finagle's Law, similar to Occam's Razor, says:

"Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity"
http://au.linkedin.com/pub/gary-fairlie/1/28a/2a2
http://cofda.wordpress.com/

gf a.k.a. ROBOPIMP T5C
gf0012-aust is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 17th, 2017   #47
New Member
Private
No Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2017
Location: Just south of the Tugela River
Posts: 23
Threads:
What I have a hard time understanding is what the goals are.
Boer Kommando is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 17th, 2017   #48
New Member
Private
No Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2017
Location: Just south of the Tugela River
Posts: 23
Threads:
If the US hit really hard in the tribal areas they would make the Pakistani Government feel rather insecure. Given India and China...
Boer Kommando is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 17th, 2017   #49
Moderator
General
ngatimozart's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Christchurch, New Zealand
Posts: 4,117
Threads:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boer Kommando View Post
If the US hit really hard in the tribal areas they would make the Pakistani Government feel rather insecure. Given India and China...
Wouldn't achieve anything except more hate and fighters for the anti govt forces. Nobody has successfully suppressed the tribes. Not Alexander the Great, not the British, not the Russians. The only modern difference between the Afghani tribal areas and the Pakistani NW tribal areas is somebody has drawn a line on a map, delineating to politically different entities. Like GF states it is a cultural issue and if you don't understand and accept the cultural side of the problem then you do not get the problem and never will. A lot of what is happening there, is traditional Eurocentric thinking and cultural attitudes orientalising the tribes; viewing, analysing and having "forcing" expectations upon them to act and react in traditional western societal group forms. That is alien to the tribes and it just alienates them further.
________________
The Rules - read them. Ignorance of them is not an excuse.
The Introduction thread for new members to tell the rest of us something about you.
ngatimozart is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 18th, 2017   #50
Junior Member
Private First Class
No Avatar
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Sydney Aust
Posts: 75
Threads:
Quote:
Originally Posted by ngatimozart View Post
Like GF states it is a cultural issue and if you don't understand and accept the cultural side of the problem then you do not get the problem and never will.
David Kilcullen's book "Accidental Gorilla" provides an excellent analysis of this mentality and examples of it in action (together with some suggestions as to how to deal with it).

Essentially it comes down to (with some simplification)
-- If you're in my area you're my enemy
-- If you help my neighbouring clan economically develop faster than mine, then you are both my enemy; and of course
-- An eye for an eye, a body for a body

But it's important to recognize this is divorced from any religious underpinning. the fact they are fighting you doesn't mean they are fundamentalists and treating them as such just expands the problem.
Boatteacher is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 18th, 2017   #51
New Member
Private
No Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2017
Location: Just south of the Tugela River
Posts: 23
Threads:
Quote:
Originally Posted by gf0012-aust View Post
more than a western or modern conceptual issue of "trust"

its a cultural disconnect. nation states will struggle to manage non state actors and where the NSActors have different drivers.

thinking that money can change cultural behaviour doesn't work
thinking that overwhelming traditional force can change cultural behaviour doesn't work
thinking that alliances can change cultural behaviour doesn't work
thinking that long term nation state relationships can change cultural behaviour doesn't work

you're talking about a country when the UN recognised entity is not even recognised by parts of its own population (tribe and clan driven)
I agree that the Western conceptual frame of reference does not apply. Not that it seems to stop us from butting our heads.

It is even beyond tribal. Much conflict is inter-tribal rivalry.

Unlike ISIS which seeks a version of the old Caliphate(s), the Taliban just want Afghanistan (and parts of Pakistan). I know that you gentlemen know this, but this seems to be lost in general discourse among the middle classes of the West.

Life expectancy is 60 years, just bellow Iran. I find it difficult to understand. It might be due to “urban bias”.

I believe something like 70% of the world’s heroin is produced in Afghanistan. I heard that the much published eradication programs (which include trying to help/convince farmers to grow grains) have come to a halt in many areas since it has proven to be exceedingly counterproductive – a sure way to lose “friends”. Per hectare no other crop can even come close in terms of return. Within the mix that is Afghanistan this crop is a significant variable in terms of funding and in large areas it underpins the dynamics of the society and its economics.

The state is weak and corrupt and would disintegrate without the backing of the West.

What a mess
Boer Kommando is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 18th, 2017   #52
New Member
Private
No Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2017
Location: Just south of the Tugela River
Posts: 23
Threads:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boatteacher View Post
David Kilcullen's book "Accidental Gorilla" provides an excellent analysis of this mentality and examples of it in action (together with some suggestions as to how to deal with it)...
I hope to get my hands on a copy. Thank you
Boer Kommando is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 18th, 2017   #53
Grumpy Old Man
General
gf0012-aust's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Australia
Posts: 17,997
Threads:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boer Kommando View Post
I hope to get my hands on a copy. Thank you
no shortage of videos on him when he's called in to give input

Kilkullen has also helped rewrite US manuals on COIN

Was not treated well by the ADF - was a victim of tall poppy syndrome
________________
A corollary of Finagle's Law, similar to Occam's Razor, says:

"Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity"
http://au.linkedin.com/pub/gary-fairlie/1/28a/2a2
http://cofda.wordpress.com/

gf a.k.a. ROBOPIMP T5C
gf0012-aust is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 18th, 2017   #54
Junior Member
Private First Class
No Avatar
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Sydney Aust
Posts: 75
Threads:
Quote:
Originally Posted by gf0012-aust View Post
no shortage of videos on him when he's called in to give input

Kilkullen has also helped rewrite US manuals on COIN

Was not treated well by the ADF - was a victim of tall poppy syndrome
That is really sad to hear. I wasn't aware of that. I wish our guys could be more perceptive sometimes.

I have read several of his books on the issues facing the world with so called radicals. They make a lot of sense and explain a lot.
Boatteacher is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 18th, 2017   #55
Grumpy Old Man
General
gf0012-aust's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Australia
Posts: 17,997
Threads:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boatteacher View Post
I have read several of his books on the issues facing the world with so called radicals. They make a lot of sense and explain a lot.
which is why the americans were happy to take him when he resigned after ADF wouldn't release him

highly regarded by petraeus and strong reachback
________________
A corollary of Finagle's Law, similar to Occam's Razor, says:

"Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity"
http://au.linkedin.com/pub/gary-fairlie/1/28a/2a2
http://cofda.wordpress.com/

gf a.k.a. ROBOPIMP T5C
gf0012-aust is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 20th, 2017   #56
Super Moderator
General
swerve's Avatar
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Reading, Berkshire
Posts: 6,619
Threads:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boer Kommando View Post
...Afghanistan ...

Life expectancy is 60 years, just bellow Iran. I find it difficult to understand. It might be due to “urban bias”.
According to the WHO, male/female life expectancy in Afghanistan is 59.3/61.9 - & Iran is 74.5/76.6.
swerve is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 20th, 2017   #57
Defense Enthusiast
Corporal
cdxbow's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Oz
Posts: 181
Threads:
Quote:
Originally Posted by swerve View Post
According to the WHO, male/female life expectancy in Afghanistan is 59.3/61.9 - & Iran is 74.5/76.6.
US isn't that much better than Iran, especially for males 76.9/81.6
Afghanistan is a basket case, Iran is not. I would like to second Boatteachers recommendation of David Kilcullen's book "Accidental Gorilla". It's not just a dry academic read.

Last edited by cdxbow; March 20th, 2017 at 08:49 PM. Reason: added
cdxbow is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 21st, 2017   #58
Super Moderator
General
swerve's Avatar
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Reading, Berkshire
Posts: 6,619
Threads:
For most countries at or above the world average income (& some a bit lower), life expectancy is starting to cluster in a fairly narrow range. When populations are adequately fed, vaccinated, have clean water, access to health & hygiene information & the other basics, they get close to the leaders. Iran (like China, Turkey, Albania, Algeria, Mexico, Thailand, etc.) falls into this category.

The dirt-poor & those which are stuffed for other reasons, such as AIDS (e.g. South Africa), are left behind.

Last edited by swerve; March 21st, 2017 at 07:44 PM.
swerve is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 21st, 2017   #59
Defense Aficionado
Major General
John Fedup's Avatar
Join Date: Sep 2013
Location: Vancouver
Posts: 2,178
Threads:
Agree, and the main reason first world nations are slightly above this cluster is drug access and better access to doctors. The huge amounts of dollars spent on health care in the West (especially North America) don't really seem to make an equivalent improvement, likely a result of our piss poor lifestyle.
John Fedup is offline   Reply With Quote
Old March 23rd, 2017   #60
New Member
Private
No Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2017
Location: Just south of the Tugela River
Posts: 23
Threads:
The only countries not to have been colonized in Africa are Ethiopia and Liberia, lovely places.

South Africa had the highest life expectancy in Africa, along with many other measures.The Africans in South Africa were by far the most advanced on the continent in 1964 and by 75 were the only stable African middle class in Africa. These are just facts.

What many people do not know is that the old Nationalist government of South Africa gave the tribes the most fertile land in SA to create their own nation states, with the aim of full recognition and Independence. About 30% of tax revenue went into building infrastructure for them like the best hospital in Africa, Baragwana. The South African doctor who made the first hart transplant, Dr. Barnard 64, was a resident.

I have some friends in Afghanistan, mostly security for US contractors. Sux not to see family, but the pay is not so bad. 6 on and 2 off. Dollars. Damn, wish I was was free.
Boer Kommando is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:58 PM.